Honestly who is the genius that looked at penalty kicks and thought, "The goalkeeper has an unfair advantage...

The keeper has never been allowed to leave the line until the ball moves. The problem now is that it has never been enforced. By the letter of the law literally every penalty kick ever taken is void because enroachment isn't allowed and have you ever seen a kick without encroachment from other players? I haven't.

No just tired of VAR.

Thats not the point. The Scottish keeper wasn't off the line until the shot had been taken, ref and VAR team fucked up.

Attached: OOOOOOOOOOOOH.png (942x586, 456K)

Get rid of penalties and just make fouls in the box count as direct free kicks from where the foul was made like what happens from the rest of the pitch.
Make the 6 yard box the barrier for when a penalty kick is awarded instead of a free kick.
Also bring back indirect free kicks for the appropriate fouls.

youtube.com/watch?v=etESI2z-BTQ&t=3m10s

Every single pen would have to be retaken in 2019.

This.
Also, how many times have people ran into the 16 m box before the shot and nobody EVER complains about that shit. This autistic enforcing of rules just for the sake of enforcing the rules has to stop.

That said, this was a mega choke, pretty kino desu

So you want more inconsistent and arbitrary decisions at the referee's discretion? No thanks.

Goalkeeper not allowed off the line.
Striker only allowed to make one step as a run up.
Both teams have to line up on the half way line instead of the box.

Penalties ARE supposed to be near guranteed goals.

I do wish however they let the keeper run up to the 6yd line once the kicker starts his run up. That way we won't get stuttering faggot kickers like neymar.

>Goalkeeper not allowed off the line.
Ok.
>Striker only allowed to make one step as a run up.
I like memey super long run ups, but I agree that stutter steps and the like are dumb.
>Both teams have to line up on the half way line instead of the box
I really like this idea.

Are you trying to reverse engineer this ?

>Also bring back indirect free kicks
That would confuse the Americans to much to ever get into the sport.

You clueless fucking wog.

Pretty based and would stop so much faggotry during penalties. One thing though why does nobody round the keeper is it not allowed?

Anyone remember in the 05 CL final when Dudek was basically on the 6 yard line for the shootout and it was allowed

If I remember right you only had a few seconds to score or it didn't count.

I'm pretty sure it was allowed, and was probably done. There was a 5 second time limit, you could only take one shot, and you couldn't move backward.

>What if a keeper was 2 metres in front of the goal, would that be against the rules?
Yes. The rule clearly states that the keeper have to be stepping on the goal line when the player kick the ball
But that rule is almost never enforced

Shouldn't have been as the rule was true then in 2006

the guy who wins the pen should have to take it

the guy who wins the pen should have to take it, from the spot of the foul, and with the guy that committed the foul as the keeper

god forbid these people playing a child's game for a living actually have to follow the rules finally

that seems way more entertaining though much more skill needed rather than toe punting it into the top of the net

The penalty kick isn’t meant to be fair
Often times penalties occur when a goal would have probably been scored if not for some illegal action
It is meant to be a goal like 80% of the time or whatever

>from the spot of the foul
oh shit it makes sense, can't shoot closer the than the normal spot if the foul happened closer tho

Attached: 1545253463471.png (518x496, 146K)

It's total bullshit. VARball does not represent how football is really played. The box has been opened and there is no way back. It's made it worse than American sports.

ive been in a masturbation induced coma for 2 days, cliffs on what happened?

>reads thread
>it's a bunch of basedboys who have never touched grass being pedants

t. cow

keeper is allowed to move freely within his six yard box during the penalty
penalties are now solved

>the six-yard box finally has a reason to exist since indirect free-kicks don't anymore
I like it.

based

"way out" is not an objective metric, dumbass

>centimeters
>tf
Explain yourself.

unironically based and far superior and WAAAAY more entertaining than what we have now.

based old-time MLS

The rule has been in the books for a long time, but now they have the means to penalize quick reactions with bullshit metrics. Unless they implement VAR at the youth level everywhere, they shouldn’t penalize goalies for what has now become muscle memory from years of training.

adulthood is realizing this makes more sense

No they are not. Otherwise diving would get even more out of hand which is what I think is gonna happen& has been happening. I wish divers were called out as much as goalies are now being targeted.

>probably

Sure. All shots go in until they don’t. I hate that guaranteed opportunity bullshit because more often than not, people ask “how the fuck did he miss?”

Metric is objectively superior

The moment the offensive player makes his first move, the goalie should be allowed to be a goalie.

This

I'm pretty sure anyone from a top 5 league can chip it over the keeper

what's the advantage for goalkeeper leaving the line?

Attached: download.jpg (230x219, 8K)

1 hour in paint, I hope this explains it

Attached: penalty.png (337x293, 3K)

>clear and obvious error

Attached: screenshotpen.jpg (1172x629, 83K)

based American scholar

Based and MLSpilled

30 year old boomer here. fuck I miss old MLS, teams were shit but the games were fun to attend and the fans weren't as cringe

>throw in done 10 yards away from where it went out
No one cares
>freekick taken 5 yards away from where the foul was made
No one cares
>keeper 2 inches off line for penalty kicker
Blow whistle 13 times, go straight to VAR, contact FIFA, check star patterns, take a piss, call Pele for advice, still make the wrong call.

Yep, that's what it was

This is a very stupid idea

youtube.com/watch?v=p9-o7CDfG-Q