2011 was a solid year but i think that was what started leading it into becoming a shit show
When did it peak?
Jaxson Cruz
Jacob Adams
peak: 2006-2009
nadir:when Hogan and bischoff showed up.
Jonathan Anderson
2004-2008 was great
It started sucking when Hogan and Bitchoff came on but they still had some cool stuff so it was 50-50 for a year or two like Styles/Angle, Based Pope, Angle/Nigel series...
Joshua Hernandez
Don't pretend that Gargano and Cole have less charisma than TNA-era Daniels and AJ.
Justin Russell
Pealed: when Angle came in
Started going to shit: When Angle had his first match
Liam Richardson
Peaked in 2005. Always had more bad than good but downhill was after signing Hogan.
Oliver Myers
Peak: early Spike TV era, 2005-2006 (until Russo came in)
Went to shit since then, people just don't remember the awful stuff from 2006-2008 so much because there were so many signings coming in. Oh, and I hate when people parrot the MUH RATINGS argument. Look at where Impact is now. The ratings didn't mean shit in the long run, especially not with those pitiful PPV buyrates.
Anthony Garcia
when Hogan and his Whore of a Daughter came and shit all over it ruined the product
Colton Gutierrez
2005 was the peak, carried on till 2006 until after Slammiversary then it went downhill fast. I actually quite liked 2007 as a whole but the years following there were only a couple bright spots, there were more cringe than good throughout the years.
Mason Rogers
2012 was the last actual good year. YOU CANT DENY THIS