Which side do you think is the better design?

This

Depends entirely on the setting/atmosphere they're going for.

>Doom
>horror game

Doom is an action FPS, no horror about it. Unless you're unironically talking about doom 3 which wasn't scary at all and relied mostly on monster closets

I think you should stop posting twitter posts and pretending its content.

Left is good if you want zombies.
Right is good if you want aliens.
Both are good for different reasons.

Thumbnail actually makes it look like some kind of fucked up fusion of the two, which would actually be a cooler design than either one on its own.

Attached: 1465953040841.jpg (374x421, 38K)

Cringe and ESLpilled

oh I loved catdog

Right doesn't even look like a Silent Hill design, it looks like a sub-par Resident Evil design that's trying to fuse the infected dogs with a Licker

Left belongs in a horror game
Right belongs in an action game about demons. Something like Doom or Devil May Cry.

>Japan good
>Western bad

I actually unironically believe this though.