Why specifically does everyone hate this case?

Why specifically does everyone hate this case?

Attached: big top.jpg (1280x720, 111K)

some of the things are poorly executed, like forcing you to say the culprit didnt have an accomplice when he clearly does and you have to prove it later anyway

>THE CAPE FLEW OFF THE BODY
>AND LATCHED ONTO THE BUST
>IT THEN GOT PULLED BACK TO THE WINDOW BY THE CRIPPLED DUDE ON THE THIRD FLOOR
>BY THE WAY, OUR CRIPPLED WHEELCHAIR BOUND GUY LIVES ON THE FUCKING THIRD FLOOR
>HE ALSO ALLEGEDLY CAN'T SEE OUT THE WINDOW PROPERLY BUT USED A BOX HE SOMEHOW LEFT THERE, FROM THE THIRD FLOOR, TO "AIM" AT HIS VICTIM
>OH AND GET THIS, THE REAL VILLAIN WAS SUPPOSED TO FIGURE OUT THE BOTTLE OF PEPPER WAS A REFERENCE TO HER
>DID I MENTION HIS PET MONKEY MANAGED TO LIFT A VERY HEAVY GAUDY STATUE THREE FLOORS UP AND LEFT IT AT THE CRIPPLE'S ROOM
>OH AND THE CRIPPLE HAS BEEN HIDING IT UNDER HIS WHEELCHAIR AND NO ONE NOTICED HIS WHEELCHAIR GOT REAL FUCKING HEAVY WHEN WE WERE GETTING HIM OFF THE THIRD FLOOR ROOM!
I actually like the characters introduced in the case, personally but holy fuck was the plot twist and overall case logic atrocious.

Attached: 1516124270846.gif (301x264, 545K)

>but holy fuck was the plot twist and overall case logic atrocious.
But that is the reason it was so good

I guess, but AA is full of dumb bullshit.

can you actually name something that's close to being as retarded as the cape and the bust?

the pendulum maybe? and it's a big maybe

It felt like there was no way Moe and Regina were the murderer and they went out of their way to make the ventriloquist innocent on the first day. Felt like it either had to have a seriously unique twist, but they ended up just introducing a new character. It kind of killed the mystery when it seemed like it "flying away" would have coincided with the fact there's a guy hanging out on the floor above. There's a lot of dumb shit in AA, sure. But the actual structure around it just kind of sucked. The 3 other witnesses felt like they were in a competition to annoy the player the fastest.

This blind child stole a gun from an interpol officer five times his size, shot him with a gun that could dislocate the shoulder of a grown man then carried his body all the way up a flight of stairs before just happening to pass out. This is a story nobody working on the investigation thought was dumb.

Interviewing a parrot.
Characters being fooled by a red Phoenix Wright with a paper badge.
A character thinking a television broadcast was actually happening live in his room.

I just ended that case and i want to say FUCK MOE AND HIS STUPID JOKES AND FUCK ACRO AND HIS STUPID WHEELCHAIR

Also why the hell did the ringmaster take max hat and cloak?