How can one game with so many flaws still be so based?
>The weight system is trash >The wardrobe and stashing outfits on horses is trash >All of the cut Love Interests mechanic for Arthur >You cannot close your winter coats in the "modify" section in the wardrobe >There is no formal suit outfit, you have to make a half-assed one yourself >You cannot get rid of your guns permanently or stash them so you don't have to flip through so many >No reward (other than satisfaction) for fully customizing the camp >It can be a hassle to get the ingredients for ammo or tonics >You can't sprint in camp like you can in Beecher's Hope >The missing pitchfork at Beecher's Hope >You can't even take a bath in your own Ranch house >Beard grows unevenly >You lose honor for defending yourself from non gang NPCs >The Trapper is useless and does not provide many in-game stats >When you are hunting for a specific (non legendary) animal, it decides to never show up or show up as a one star
>you lose honor defending yourself from non gang NPCs Only if you kill them iirc. Also, if you don't pull a gun when you get shot at you can manipulate the A.I law enforcement to kill people sho start shooting at you.
>hunting This is simply confirmation bias The animal spawns don't have an advanced sensor that reads your mind and despawns shit when you want to find a specific animal.
>you can't take a bath in your own house This is very stupid especially since Beecher's Hope does have a fully furnished bathroom. Imagine Abigail coming to give you a nice rub and tug too for the ''special bath''.
Josiah Watson
>All of the cut Love Interests mechanic for Arthur What?
Dylan Wilson
>You cannot get rid of your guns permanently or stash them so you don't have to flip through so many I really hate this shit in rdr 2 you can only take skin from animal with animation when in first game you can take animal skin and meat with animation fucking SOULLESS
Jace Sanders
The mash X to use the horse mechanic is trash, especially since it’s still pretty slow.
Ethan King
Beechers Hope is an utter failure. It should feel more like the camps. You should be able to replenish food and ammo. Imagine being able to buy food for the house and the kitchen gets full. You should also be able to bring Abigail animal carcasses like with Pearson so she can put it into her meals.
Ryan Cooper
>fucking Soulless Agreed, RDR1 was soulless with it's lack of skin extraction animation.
I think it's a good idea to make horses feel more than just horse shaped cars.
Jayden Thomas
Many months ago, there was a leaker who (accurately) leaked most of the story and features the game would have. One of them was that Arthur could romance Mary-Beth and/or Charles. This was proven to be true due to some cut dialogue and you can see some of the tension from those characters from chapter 2 and 3.
Hudson Bailey
bullshit
Jason Wright
>Mary-Beth and/or Charles >Charles wtf? Glad they cut it, Don't need faggot shit in a western.
The biggest Flaw was people thinking Micah was a rat the entire game. Also the fact Arthur hated Micah from the start and even when being nice he still antagonizes unless it was Guarma.
Thomas Sanders
wrong, button mashing to run is one of the best things about R* games
Jeremiah Cook
Biggest problem is the survival shit is too trivial. You can just refill your cores by sleeping so why was the feature even included. It’s like there’s no reason to really care about food other than immersion purposes. Even then cooking meat is really easy and refills your cores. I just feel like so much of this game doesn’t add anything to the experience. It also sucks that you are hardly ever in Ambarino, so you can wear the outfit for hot weather basically all the time.
Josiah Butler
did you even play the game?
Benjamin Ward
Uhh...yes? What did I say that was wrong?
Andrew Hill
Holy shit get rid of the bandolier and easily 10/10
Hunter Thompson
To run, yes. Using it for the horse is overkill
David Brown
yeah
Matthew Clark
just turn on cinematic mode or use fast travel lmao
Alexander Lee
That's a load of crap. The devs said themselves arthur was going to form a relationship with sadie but not long before release they decided it didn't quite work for them so they cut many scenes & an extra couple missions between the two. They said you can still see a hint of a connection between them near the end of the game, also including some dialogue where sadie talks about arthur like she's falling for him.
Justin Anderson
That didnt fit but all the hamfisted politics did
Really jiggles your jellies
Dominic Smith
Well yeah, that’s the problem. I shouldn’t feel the need to do that. I don’t like using fast travel in open world games but in this game it’s like they wanted long horse travel to be as annoying as possible
Ethan Williams
Good thing they didn't. Sadie is insufferable.
Gabriel Bennett
>You can't even take a bath in your own Ranch house This one triggered me the most desu
Ethan Hernandez
>I shouldn’t feel the need to do that
>The horses are too hard to control! >Well, you can turn down the complexity by doing this >NO I DON'T WANT THAT
Everything about the post game sucks. Playing as John just feels like dumb fan service and not something that really fit. Plus his model in this game really sucks, you lose the ability to swim, you lose most of the call features. It’s also a bummer that the railroad and timber companies are both totally gone, making the world feel a lot more lifeless.
The character change was pretty cool in the first game but here it feels really forced and like a downgrade.
Luis Reed
it isn't more or less political than any R* game really. This was never going to be a gritty hard examination of the racist west, lil' zoomie
Jack Gutierrez
There is no complexity in tapping A over and over and over.
Samuel Peterson
Imagine being this much of a cuck
Asher Fisher
Pretty sure Arthur's voice actor said it was Abigail. This is evidenced in the game like when Arthur opined he should have married and settled down with her at one point in his journal. Also makes sense that it would have been removed for being too out of place cause of her relationship with John whereas Sadie wouldn't have been that out of place.
Brandon Evans
The bland free roam music was a disappointment, especially compared to RDR1
Easton Bennett
and yet here you are complaining
Benjamin Kelly
I'm just saying what the developers said. I can see the sadie thing far more then the Abigail thing. If there was an Abigail thing I imagine it happened during the year when John left, before the game starts
Asher James
Wrong. Rockstar parodied poltics, but never had you doing.womens marches and teaming up with indian nigger mutts
Cooper Sanders
Nice source
Carter Perez
It’s tedious, not hard or complex.
Oliver Wright
okay GTAIV has you go on a boat picnic with a gay guy
Jace Williams
but you asked for a feature literally already in the game
Andrew Nguyen
This game reeks of cut content all over the place. Homes with signs for sale that probably were meant to be bought, the railroad company was probably meant to be more involved than it was, valentine is really detailed but the other cities have few interiors, new austin is empty as fuck. And it does indeed feel like romance options were intended at some point but dropped.
Logan Lopez
And what is that
Christopher Myers
not having to tap when riding the horse, keep up.
Evan Jackson
cinematic camera is shit and so is fast travel, neck yourself
ah yes the same "leaker" that said you'd be able to force horses to have sex that guy wasn't even credible
nah Roger said the cut stuff was with Sadie, but he also replied to a comment about a guy who asked the same thing about Abigail, so that's why you're probably confused.
Aaron Taylor
You win. I couldn't have even imagined such a response
Angel King
fast travel is great when it's implemented right, like in rdr2
Adrian Peterson
Read Arthurs journal you stupid fucking nigger
Bentley Torres
i haven't played the game i just jumped in randomly with a dog pic, does it do that bullshit where if you were to walk to a town it would take 5 minutes but if you fast travel it takes 1 hour? Honestly my biggest gripe about fast travel.
Gabriel Bailey
But you do have the tap to go a decent speed on the horse. I don’t want to have to turn the gameplay totally off to make horse riding tolerable. It would be nice if simply playing it wasn’t so tedious
Ethan Bell
but it isn't tedious
Noah Campbell
also the horse maintains the speed you set it to in cinematic mode
Jack Martin
Access to fast travel in openworld games should be limited to, from cities and towns to cities and towns.
Adam Parker
pc version when?
Jason Rogers
not even worth it unless they patch the horrible control input lag