Guys, I need help bad. I work at a game studio and they're trying to make a moba. Yes, a Moba. I don't even understand, isn't this genre fucking dead? Why? Nothing can compete with League of Legends and Dota 2 now, it's OVER. Also their ideas are so fucking bad it's insane, they want to give the characters more than just 4 skills, it's tons of bloat and so goddamn retarded. Example of characters they have working on:
>assassin girl, literal ripoff of Kat and Eve from LoL, and Valeera from Hots, has ALL skills from each of these characters fucking COMBINED, so much mobility it's fucking disgusting >some fishman character that is an unholy fusion of both Teemo and Fizz's kit, jesus fucking christ fighting this faggot in the alpha is hell on fucking goddamn earth >Jhin's kit mixed with Lucian, nuff fucking said
I seriously think these people are fucking retarded and have no idea how to do good gameplay, they're literally just fucking stealing entire kits from random moba characters and merging them together, that assassin girl I mentioned has like 12 fucking skills, TWELVE SKILLS. What the fuck.
Can I get them sued by Riot and Blizzard and Valve or something? Is there some copyright on these different skills I can exploit to get this project shut down?
Sounds like Bloodline Champions/Battlerite if they went into a standard MOBA laning phases just with more things to press. If it's different enough to stand out then I don't see the harm in trying it. But yeah MOBAs are impossible to get into since nobody wants to move onto a different one as they've put a lot of time and effort to getting decent at one already. They aren't dead though, although it seems like Battle Royales are what's hot right now.
Nathan Reed
just do your job, your position isn't in the department of taste
Joshua King
Nah, can't copyright skills, well, you can, but you'd have helluva time defending it in court. Just take your money for development, ship the game and find new work.
Joseph Wilson
Invoker has 4+10
Lucas Wright
its worse, its like hots where it isn't even standard lanes, and there's environmental hazards and other shit like that. I don't know wtf they think they're doing.
No one who is sane is going to want to play against a fucking assassin with 12 goddamn skills, including shit like stealth, teleports, and all the fucking asshattery Katarina alone has. It's like their design philosophy is "lol make everything broken as shit"
Levi Morgan
>accidental anal
Liam Adams
I fail to see how that is your problem. You clearly work for an indie studio and therefore it's death was inevitable. Just polish up your resume and do your job
Christopher Rogers
he can't use them all at once, imagine if invoker could literally just hit one of any 12 keys on his keyboard and throw skills out
also he's a mage and has weakneses, wtf weakness would a highly mobile assasssin with stealth shit even have
Too bad this is a MOBA or supposed to be a variation of one, not a goddamn MMORPG. No Moba has characters with that many skills, and even Invoker is gated off by having to do those orb inputs to do his moves. He can't just hit 12 keys as shit happens.
Ayden Kelly
They are essentially competing for customers that have most likely already sunk in thousands of hours and hundreds of dollars in League of Legends. It's not viable. Very few people swaps MOBAs because the formula is very one dimensional. New MOBA players will ONLY want the most simplest renditions because more buttons=harder and they don't want the most intimidating skill curve, which is where League shines. If you are signing up to play a genre of game infamous for its toxicity, would you want to play the one with 12 skill champions? Hell no. Only players well familiar with the genre would swap and then return once they remember all the bonus features Riot/Valve offers.
Cooper Morgan
>implying this game won't ruin their company
any company retarded enough to make a moba post dota 2 and league has it coming
Juan Evans
Mobas play exactly like MMORPGs.
Adrian Flores
This company is also dumb at handling toxicity, I talked with them about it and they basically said trash talking and being toxic won't be banned unless you use racial slurs or death threats/act overly vicious. In other words, you can tell someone they're garbage and should uninstall and wont get banned so long as you don't say nigger. Which is bullshit and just encourages toxicity.
Ayden Morgan
What's your job title?
Michael Brooks
They play nothing like mmorpgs. They use an isometric from above camera and use click to move, mmorpgs use a behind the character camera and wasd controls
Andrew Perry
Yes yes great astroturfing now fuck off
Dominic Cruz
>This company is also dumb at handling toxicity, I talked with them about it and they basically said trash talking and being toxic won't be banned unless you use racial slurs or death threats/act overly vicious. In other words, you can tell someone they're garbage and should uninstall and wont get banned so long as you don't say nigger. Which is bullshit and just encourages toxicity. that sounds based though
Tipped your hand, Senpai.
Austin Collins
Thats how valve does it and they make bank
Brandon Murphy
Sounds like a pasta desu senpai.
Kayden Butler
They're target select and hotkeys. The mechanical skill involved is exactly the same.
Jordan Long
nah you get banned for saying nigger in dota 2
Gavin Gutierrez
Suggest to add big anime titties to every character. That'll do.
Justin Bell
are you from 2013? I think that was the time everyone tried to jump on ASSFAGGOTS bandwagon and many cancelled
also you sound like an underaged idiot
Easton Brooks
If you want to attract customers, marketing that you arw more competent than your comptetitors is key Handling the number one complaint of the genre with less restraint is a sure way to bankruptcy
Abandon ship while you can!
Christian Price
lmfao no you don't. I haven't played in a few months or hafl a year, and my roommate used to say, "I've never seen anyone type nigger so fast".
Did something change?
Daniel Powell
Why not take this opportunity to spark innovation and pursue interesting new directions in this tired old format?
Here's your one rule that will guarantee people will play your new MOBA: not another fantasy setting. Do futuristic cyborgs and shit. Do WW2 tanks and shit. Do historic medieval heroes and shit. Do a MOBA but with insects.
>nah I'll whine instead
ok
Cameron Bailey
do they have any usp's? do they have a unique artstyle or control method? anything that'd give them an edge over smite or hots (the ones that they'll actualy have to beat since lol and dota players are way too entrenched) if they have anything to offer then stick with it, if not then you may want to move on
David Baker
battlerite
Nolan Martinez
That hasn't been a thing since floppies, user. There are already strong magnets inside hard drives.
Aiden Lopez
Then you have nothing to worry about. You'll be vindicated either way. No point in wasting your time on something that is going to happen regardless. Go work somewhere else where you'll actually enjoy what you're doing so you're not a vindictive little shit.
Oliver Hughes
Cluck cluck cluck cluck CLUCK
Caleb Martinez
the setting for this game looks ripped off of warhammer 40k and dune, so I already know it's gonna fail for sure based on that alone, people aren't gonna want to play as edgelord characters in some edgy looking maps
Josiah Reed
CATER TO FURRIES.
Parker Evans
Wtf that sounds based, tell us the name
Nathan Green
>the warcraft 3 moba about playing a ship you slowly upgrade into the craziest shit and repair by standing in a dock until you manage to send your ships past enemy lines to their docks now thats how you innovate
Dylan Reed
No you don't. I've shit talked chinks,russians,germans and more and still have 10k behavior score.
Carson Lee
>falling for viral marketing this hard Jesus christ, kill yourself. You too OP
>Can I get them sued by Riot and Blizzard and Valve or something? I mean, you could get sued for breaking NDA.
Jeremiah Thompson
Someone already made a game like that. I distinctly remember being able to choose between several different ships and equipment. Then you had to make it to their base and destroy it.
Jace Lopez
I don't get why people always say MOBA is dead. Every single one of them is: >top, mid, bot, jungle lanes with clearly defined roles and metas >mage, ADC, fighter, support, tank, assassin - no exception >boring fantasy shit
Change literally one of these and you have an entirely different experience you can market to the millions bored to death of the big two.
Joshua Foster
Just make it and get paid. Or give somebody else the job buddy,
Brandon Perry
Better then boring stale “fantasy” league
Isaac Wright
This post made me fucking LOL. I hope its true.
Luke Reed
this shit literally does not matter you faggot
sounds like they aren't the problem in this scenario
Connor Foster
no title yet, its currently under the name "Project Babylon"
Caleb Parker
>Random indie game steals from LoL >LoL stole from DotA and other games >DotA stole from Warcraft >Warcraft stole from Warhammer and DnD
And so the cycle continues
Carter Robinson
>>boring fantasy shit
you mean you don't want to play as a buff man with a sword and huge pauldrons or a buff man with a beard and a pirate gun?
Samuel Sullivan
I betcha this guy is either 1) Lying, or 2) In QC. Get a skill that matters, then you get to have input.
Nicholas Williams
>baby that has only played league thinks he knows anything
Jaxson Carter
yeah but this stealing is worse, how the fuck can you literally steal entire kits and slap them together? this is some mugen level shit, like those edits where people give K' Iori's moves added to his own or some shit
Cameron Green
Will this game be a top down moba though? There’s like 500 of those on steam.
Leo Ramirez
I love Katarina!
Dylan Kelly
Name one big MOBA that isn't exactly what I listed.
Joseph Mitchell
Option one: Do your job, get the game done and count your money while it flops and the company crashes. Option two: Go to the boss/executives/design leaders and tell them what's what. Tell them their design is lazy and retarded and that the game is nothing but a rip-off of a dead genre. Might make a difference, might get you fired. Read about their failure while looking at job listings and know you did what you could to help them. Option three: Quit. Avoid discussions of morality, and just accept this project is a dead end. Look for a better one elsewhere. Later down the line read about their failure and be glad you didn't sink with the ship.
You can't get them sued, btw.
Brayden Reed
Dota
Lucas Richardson
it would have to be, how on earth would you be able to control characters that teleport all over the place if it had a camera like smite
Jayden Wright
she was one of my mains
one of my fav skins was the asian one since you could see the curves of her ass better when zoomed in
Can mods ban this thread for viral marketing? This entire "sabotage" pretense is clearly fucking asinine and this chucklefuck is just advertising features. Delete this faggotry.
Why would you even care to sue the place anyways? Why does morality matter so much that you want to quit and sue? Let them make the shitty league clone and let it die on steam
Caleb Martinez
>no mana just cooldowns >don't do this for every champion Why the fuck is rito so fucking stupid holy shit
Ryder Anderson
Unironically dota
Gavin Myers
>implying an assassin that is highly mobile with 12 skills is a feature anyone would actually enjoy >implying it wouldn't cause massive salt and rage
Yeah I know I can't wait to fight against a stealth assassin that you can't escape from and has projectiles that hit multiple targets
Wyatt Taylor
if fizz had no mana costs he'd be even more hellish to fight
Alexander Bennett
If they insist in going full MOBA, try to pander hard to waifufags and furfags to, at least, recover the money spent on it.
Dylan Wood
some of the female characters have big tits and long legs and some skins are revealing
also one of the characters is a buff lizardman
Jason Williams
Then go full on with that, don't fall for the diversity meme. Maybe make one character gay or something to cause some controversy or some shit and make your game be heard. The rest, go full waifufag and furfag pandering. That's going to be easier than getting the project shut down.
Jack Barnes
that ruins the warhammer 40k aesthetic then, women in that weren't fapbait
Joseph Watson
When did I say that you stupid nigger? Case in point
Ryan Ramirez
I swear this topic sounds entirely the same as the one about some guy making a fighting game.
One side has autism here.
Mason Lee
how is describing a feature people will hate a form of viral marketing then?
Andrew Rogers
your game better have sexy elf women in it
Henry Davis
If they're paying you steadily just do it. Sounds like it's a trainwreck so keep an eye out for other work and as long as you're ready to jump ship when it fails you're good.
Anthony Parker
>how is literally the oldest viral marketing trick in the book marketing Fuck off you weasely faggot
Joseph Morales
>hey guys, our new soda tastes like dogshit >oh boy, I as a consumer can't wait to try that product!
Dont be dumb.
Nicholas Watson
>Can I get them sued by Riot and Blizzard and Valve or something? Is there some copyright on these different skills I can exploit to get this project shut down? That's not how this works and you're beyond stupid if you think it is
Justin Ross
you need an engine that allows the characters to interact with each other on a more direct way. dynamic hitboxes and more complex animations. not this basic bitch shit that league has where when Lee kicks a champ he is kicking the hitbox and not the actual model.
other than that a 5th ability is totally fine if you make sure that the kits have ~2 one hit wonder abilities. evry kit in league is spammable q, one hit wonder and then 2 abilities for the gimick that the champ has. just adjust thsi and change it for a 5 skil system. it is possible but i doubt you have the money or talent to do this right
I am pretty sure you can't blatantly steal an entire character's moveset for your game. Some company can't steal Nero or Vergil's moveset, make a game called "Demons Can't Sob" and make money from it
Jackson Jones
No they don't you fucking dunce
Benjamin Jones
>It's like their design philosophy is "lol make everything broken as shit" Looks like you found your niche
Kevin Turner
I regularly call people taco niggers and say shit like "sorry I don't speak nachos bell grande" and I've never been put in low prio
Xavier Hernandez
this is how league was at the start as well. but once they grow big they clean out all the toxicity for the gamr grillz and investors.
Dylan Watson
Ever heard of Supernova? Yeah I didn't think so
Luke Williams
They totally can, it's not copyrighted. That isn't even what you said they're doing anyways.
Hunter Davis
Dota already has that covered though
Jacob Bennett
That's not what you're doing at all and you know it you insufferable shitstain.
Elijah Rivera
is there a tomboy in the roster, this is more impotent than you might think
Jack Wright
>Implying the new mana items makes champions run out of mana Seriously, the only mage that can run out of mana after the first item is Aurelion Sol, the rest have a watered Urf mode.
Eli Parker
That has and still is a thing with HDD's. Its just that modern HDD's require a stronger magnet to erase them and definitely won't fall victim to something like a refrigerator magnet or anything that user likely has readily available.
Matthew Hernandez
>12 skill >stealth Do you make moba or mmorpg
Jack Richardson
put girls with big titties and lolis and your game will be fine, otherwise dont promote your shitty game on Yea Forums
Jayden Evans
they claim its a moba, but I never saw a moba with shit like this. This assassin bitch throws daggers like Kat, can pick them up and attack with them like she can, can blinkstrike to them or to enemies, does that spin shit she does, and has Eve and Valeera skills too from Hots. It's fucking bullshit. trying to fight this bitch in the beta feels like playing a fucking action game not a goddamn moba, and its stressful as fuck.
Michael Gonzalez
Yes you can. Otherwise, literally every fighting game with projectiles can be called a "street fighter ripoff". Or every fps can be called a Doom ripoff. You can't patent mechanics and even if you could, it takes a good and motivated legal team to defend it in court.
Josiah Reed
But stealing entire movesets should be a different matter entirely. I shouldn't be able to take Zed's kit from LoL and literally copy paste it into my own game on a different character. You at least have to change something, and by something I mean the actual skills, not "it's Zed ult but does less damage lol"
Joseph Murphy
is this the same autist op who kept making threads about some shitty fighting game
I never made any thread about Mortal Kombat 11 though
Benjamin Sullivan
is there a tomboy in the game
Anthony Price
I Have a question: What does your game provide that's diferent from other mobas?
What i can see your team doing is making each character have 12 abilities, but can only have 4 active per game. Think like darkest dungeon where each character has more abilities they can equip. Make few characters, but with a lot of meat to chew. From there you can copy dota's big item list or Hots ability tree thingy, or LoL's abilities level, maybe make something new! Mobas are always 5vs5 defend your base, maybe rethink that formula, they should be aggresive about an objective? Search&Kill the enemy in a map, maybe gather a source and each team tries to sabotage the other while trying to acomplish their own objectives(eh, not a fan of this last one).
The managment is shit as far as i can read, so try to make usefull things for future works.
How the fuck is it a plug, no one wants to deal with that shit. People bitch enough about characters like that in these games.
>try the alpha >face this bitch >she runs off and stealths >am wondering where the fuck she went, go to attack some minions >a minute later I'm in a smokescreen, get stabbed a bunch a times, go to run, she throws a dagger that hits me, bounces off and lands behind me, she yanks me back to her, teleports to me, throws another dagger that lands on her, spin slashes me, blinks to the other dagger and slashes me again, does that spinny move shit, an ally comes in to help and the bitch blinks to him and stealths away
fuck this shit
Adrian Jenkins
there's a girl similar in build to jinx with short spiky hair and she fights using a lead pipe and beat em up style character moves and combos
Cameron Jones
Definitely not, in pubs I start spewing out racial slurs the moment I see a chinese or peruvian player on the enemy team and I've never even been chat restricted. You honestly have to be a tremendous asshole as in you actually ruin games to get below a 6k behavior score.
Adam Sanchez
What platform is it for?
Isaac Turner
this is true, I got a premade with 4 white nerd guys that kept singing "nigger nigger nigger" in voice chat and typing it in all and nothing happened to them
Jackson Walker
give her a cute nerdy rival/possible boyfriend
Anthony Thomas
Oh, is this the part where I engage with you about this needlessly detailed scenario? I'm not playing your little game, nigger. Not your mobashit or your marketing scheme.
Brandon Gomez
its detailed to show you how awful and unfun this shit is to deal with. this is just gonna drive people away
Jayden Diaz
that sounds so fucking infuriating, I'd ragequit
Mason Bell
Yeah you totally need to drive people away from this game that literally no one would have known about without your thread here. Drive yourself away and off a cliff you slimy cunt
Hudson Diaz
is there a cute nerd in the game
James Myers
That would either make Anivia broken or useless
Jose Clark
LOL has always been shit and DOTA 2 ruined itself with constant new meta shit.
Your company might have a chance if they do something different, but likely they'll make another shitty dota clone.