Why does every other VN feels so souless after reading this one?
either writing is pretentious wannabe deep, with mindset that gore, rape and other dark shit means good story
or characters are walking stereotypical japanese tropes. Is it so hard to write a girl thats not a cardboard cutout of some dere type?
cant japs make a good "game" in the genre they created? They all copy eachother with cool gary stu MCs and shits like pointless ecchi scenes where you walk into bathroom when the girl is changing
so far i've been dissapointed by grisaia, kara no shoujo, yume miru and fate shit
I just want normal, down to earth story with real characters
Why does every other VN feels so souless after reading this one?
Other urls found in this thread:
store.steampowered.com
youtube.com
vndb.org
twitter.com
Wasn't there one VN on steam where you're a clinically depressed guy who gets a Yandere gf? That one looked alright
I think you're just braindead. KS was easily one of the worst VNs I've ever played, and I've played some absolute shockers. It's worse than any English translated VN by a solid mile, I was impressed by just how poorly made and amateurish it was.
The characters in KS aren't "realistic", they're just boring and all utterly cliche in their own ways.
faggot
Katawa Shoujo was really overrated by Yea Forums. Not even being contrarian I liked it but it really wasn't anything special. The millions of threads on Yea Forums didn't help either.
Yeah, here we go
Crimson Gray
store.steampowered.com
Might be worth checking out
It even got a sequel
>western """""visual novels""""""
kys
ITT bunch of contrarians
Yea Forums has truly become reddit
>those visual novels
Maybe try playing something more normal and keep in mind they are basically anime in a different format.
ギャグでいってんのか
Because Japan can't write for shit
What is a VN that isnt just about romancing some dumb animes, like is there any game on that format of choosing options and mostly reading that doesnt involve just anime cliches and romance? Maybe solving a mistery or something interesting
Hotel Dusk
Ace Attorney
Ghost Trick
Katawa Shoujo was decent, but for every good western VN there's like 50 superior VNs from Japan.
Too many m8, but only if you know Japanese.
>Why does every other VN feels so souless after reading this one?
Because it was your first VN you enjoyed and you're expecting every other one to hit the same beats as KS while only playing what the VN casuals on Yea Forums recommended. I don't know what the fuck you're doing reading Grisaia, KnS, Yume Miru and Fate if you want a "down to earth story" like you said. There's VNs like Narcissu, Kana Imo, ef, Shinigami no Kiss, almost every Key VN and more that completely shit on KS, which is also a great one itself.
There are thousands of VNs out there, and if you can't find another one to enjoy then that's your fault.
SOON
Sometimes gore, rape and other dark shit do make a good story tho, read Wonderful Everyday
Higurashi
Umineko
Dies irae if you like chunni
Play Steins;Gate, and then Umineko.
>grisaia
moe slice-of-life crap
>kara no shoujo
edgy guro shit
>yume miru
pretty much a nukige
It's your own fault for picking such shitty games to play first.
>Umineko
>mystery
can someone just please tell me a VN where i can fall in love with a tomboy and confess to her and go out with her
well OP posted it
seconding this
i just realized i don't think theres been an actual tomboy in any of the ones i've played
read a book
Overrated garbage
Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors.
crapawa shitjo is not a game.
>a game with so much dark and miserable shit in it actually managed to deliver a message about accepting life in its entirety, with all of its bad and sad things
>prologue is a thinly-veiled "fuck you" against escapism
How did he do it?
suggest something that is better then, user
>download a bunch of VN's I wanna play
>can't sit down in front of computer and read for hours and hours
How can I fix this?
Fuck you Libitina I’ve been waiting two years
Because KS is the literal definition of soul. It was a passion project, and was distributed for free.
It may not be the best VN, but it sure is pretty soulful.
Get a better chair and maybe a nice drink.
You've been living your life too correctly
Join us the carpal tunnel, insomnia and scoliosis club
>56 VNs in my folder
i feel you user..
any of the VNs he disparaged are miles ahead
AHhhhhhhh, Katawa Shoujo. . .
Now THAT was a game!
Don't give up. It'll happen for sure, we just don't know when.
>pretentious wannabe deep, with mindset that gore, rape and other dark shit means good story
This is exactly what I want.
Maggot Baits fucking when?
Disgusted but also aroused
What if I don't want shitty nip tropes though? Grisaia and Fate in particular have some of the worst writing I've ever seen.
Then read a fucking book.
its because ks was made out of passion without thinking about profit while japanese companies need to make that sweet yen.
They do big research what sells and who is their target and create typical shit to please as many horny teenagers as possible.
You get bland, smart but relatable MC and horny heroines cause whole vn genre is just powerfantasy for loosers who got none of these things irl
Thats the same reason why most popular anime currently are isekais where black haired teenager gets transported to fantasy world with rpg mechanics, then he gets harem and becomes op because he played those games for hours in his neetcave, sometimes theres a gimmick but usually everything is the same. its just animated powerfantasy for people too lazy to daydream themselves
shit sells
I didnt like it
Saya no Uta was the only VN I could read without falling asleep
Is this pasta
This.
No idea, but it's the truth.
>What if I don't want shitty nip tropes though?
If you don't want nip tropes don't play nip games dude. It sounds more like you dislike the genre in general and simply liked KS because it subverted the tropes you don't like
get off of Yea Forums for starters, close everything, turn off any distractions
Play Clannad
>tfw really enjoy story-heavy games but can't sit through a pure visual novel because i need some form of gameplay to keep me engaged
Rance and Evenicle were a blast, what are some other visual novel/JRPG hybrid games? Maybe something more serious and less sex focused?
You've only read that VN so whaddya know
VNs aren't a genre, they're a medium. There's plenty of nip VNs I liked, even romance heavy ones.
L
O
L
Katawa shoujo has been a retarded braindead fuck detector since day 1, if you "like it" it's because you're unironically retarded
Canvas 2
Have you played Kamidori or Utawarerumono?
>romance heavy
Then how can you say you hate japanese tropes if you cleary enjoyed some of the most overused ones?
>disappointed by Yume Miru
Well shit user, I was coming in here to suggest that. Anything specific you didn't care for?
Well, if you want mystery AND anime cliches, Danganronpa.
>Evenicle
Literally the funniest game I've ever played
Rumor I read on here was that several translators they hired just straight up quit mid-way through because the material was so fucked up.
That's why it was announced in 2016 and we're approaching mid-2019 without a release date.
I'm pretty excited.
Clockup really teeter totters between "fun nukige for everybody" and "fucked up gore show"
Chaos;Head and its sequel Chaos;Child fit that description really well. C;H is not on Steam,so download it off somewhere and use the Di-patch because it hasn't been officially translated yet. The Chaos games are in the same continuity as Steins;Gate,except they're more interesting. You're basically solving a giant serial-murder case called the New Generation Madness,the events that unfold are really amazing. Applying the Di-patch is really easy,don't let that extra mile discourage you from experiencing this
This,except play the series in release order like a human being and start with Chaos;Head instead
I don't read VNs because I'm jealous and can't get the things shown there in real life. Hell,I wouldn't want any of that harem shit irl. I just like the characters and sometimes the main story that is being presented
I'm playing through a visual novel which I'm not going to mention because of spoilers and it's so broing I want to gouge my eyes out, but the story is kind of good and I want to see the end of it.
Fuck this medium, I swear i'm out of this after reading this one
YU-NO was really good. Came for the stepmommy but I just couldn't not care about the rest of the game.
Same, I don't want to fap, I just want to see how fucked up the vn is
>Yea Forums has truly become reddit
Ain't that the truth. Some user was kind enough to actually stream Kung Pow last night and only 15 people showed up. This place is dead.
I'd consider starting with some short stories.
if you want something down to earth then narcissu.
Planetarian if you don't mind some sci-fi and phenomeno for typical ghost story.
What I liked about KS was how 'normal' it was. It's been hard to find another VN set in modern times in the real world with little to no fantastical elements to it.
I missed it, saw only last 15 minutes
>westernshit
And now I'm flaccid.
Zero Escape my dude, play 999
It is really difficult to be more interesting than one of the best written VNs in the history of VNs. Seriously each route following the boy cripple and his pals from Yamaku Academy as they live with assorted disabilities has been distinguishable from the others. Aside from the beautiful imagery, the series’ only consistency has been its amazing OST and effective use of editing transitions , all to make friendships seem friendly , to make love seem real.
Perhaps the die was cast when Suriko vetoed the idea of a Rin foot job scene; he made sure the series would never be mistaken for a fetish content , just ridiculously wholesome stories. The Katawa Shoujo series might be anti-Christian (or not), but it’s certainly the anti-James Bond series in that it is actually good.
>d-d ddlc was better though though
"No!"
I don't know man, I read the Shizune's route after all the shilling on Yea Forums and I thought it was a boring piece of crap with no depth to it
Fata Morgana is one of the best VNs ever made.
Should I play that, Kara no Shoujo or I/O? I have also heard good things about Ever 17.
What the fuck
I read them like any book, i wan't story, I don't actually think I'm there.
You have to have an astounding suspense of disbelief to enjoy Chaos Child
Kara no Shoujo is an edgy piece of crap
Go with Ever17
Yea Forums KS fans are pure embarassment
>reads western VN trying hard as fuck to be japanese but failing soulles garbage
>calls real VNs soulless
No user you are the soulless
>I just want normal, down to earth story with real characters
You are way to casual or way too gaijin to realize why anime tropes are the best.
Also KS had god awful writing
Its not the truth, its just an idiot that doesnt understand otaku culture.
You people need to fuck off and read books.
Stay away from japanese stuff ok
See? you just dont fucking get it
Fuck I miss when this board wasnt so casual and westernized
Asking this here because it doesn't deserve its own thread and someone will likely know
I'm playing Steins;Gate and have got the suzuha, faris, luka, and mayuri endings. To get the kurisu and true endings, I understand I need to make sure I reach the end with some and all of the true ending flags, and I've got a guide pointing out what I need to do and when.
It sounds a bit tedious though to go all the way back through. If I skip and leave it, will it stop skipping when I reach a true ending flag, or do I have to keep my eyes constantly glued to it as I skip through the entire game to make sure I pause at just the right moment to not miss a flag?
>series
Do they share anything besides the genre and the semicolon in the name?
reminds me of saya no uta. although the circumstances a little different.
Congratulations on being the most retarded poster in Yea Forums in the last 6 months.
cartagra and kara no shoujo.
umineko.
higurashi.
saya no uta.
>gaijin
>westernized
Being blind to flaws in weaboo culture is not a good thing. No matter how many japanese cocks you slurp you wont become japanese your self so stop.
Overused tropes are bad and you should feel bad
Umineko is exactly what you're looking for.
>i-its not bad he just doesnt understand our culture
i think he described whats bad in anime community pretty well
you cannot deflect every criticism with
>baka gaijin
>different culture
I only played through it once and got a Hanako gf
>not making it to the best route
but he did
Every popular VN
Because you lack reading comprehensions, and decide to read garbage VN's.
KWSJ is mediocre at best.
>i think he described whats bad in anime community pretty well
It was a generic as fuck criticism, every type of entertainment wants to pander to its target demographic.
Hanako's route could have been longer with much more character development, but I enjoyed it a lot. The final CG in pic related is the cutest one in the game
this has been the case for awhile now
someone only played an hour of the game and assumed the rest was shit.
Or he got Shizune's route rite
I played 5 fucking hours of this absolute garbage on launch day, fuck off. Every single girl managed to be shittier and more half-baked than the last.
E17's last route is 11/10, the rest is horrible.
I/O is mind blowing but flawed, you'd want to read it last.
Does this count as VN? If so it's one of the better ones
Add to that Fate stay Night and subahibi
But rin is the only well done route, all the others are full of melodrama. I appreciate KS because it was targeted at us, but its definitely baby's first VN.
Katawa Shoujo is unironically one of the best VNs ever made.
>so far i've been dissapointed by grisaia, kara no shoujo, yume miru and fate shit
Then stop reading shit VNs. You can't read garbage after reading KS.
These are some good ones
>Muv-luv
>Utawarerumono
>Swan Song
>Eden* They Were Only Two, On The Planet.
>Kana ~Imouto~
>Wanko to Kurasou
>Planetarian ~Chiisana Hoshi no Yume~
>Saya no Uta
>Cross†Channel
>Ever17
>Fata morgana no Yakata
What the fuck is wrong with you braindead KS weeaboo shitter? Fuck off to your shitty ERP general
>Katawa Shoujo is unironically one of the shitiest VNs ever made
FTFY
The answer is a lot more simple than you'd like it to be. The girls are vulnerable due to disabilities which triggers the white male's innate instincts for empathy and his genes demand he protect her. So any event that happens to her has 5x more impact than it would if it happened to a normal girl (assuming both were equally cute).
>become
I think you would be surprised if it was revealed how many people crosspost on Yea Forums and reddit.
If mods somehow magically rangebanned anyone who ever posted on reddit, less than 30% of this board's population would survive, but I think that would be for the best.
Shitkawa shoujo is literally a fucking cult. They're even harassing Japan VA and spamming their email to force them making Katawa shoujo anime. What's a bunch of delusional pigs. Fuck weebs
any source on that bozo?
>pandering muh disable girls hurt feeling pls love me /r9k/
>ripoff artwork from Japan artist
Pathetic
Just ask any faggots from that piece of shit general
>read this to know what the fuss is this
>every characters are boring anime shit but they got disable
>lel Yea Forums reference
>soapy anime drama i already seen hundred of times
is this supposed to be good?
>whole vn genre is just powerfantasy for loosers who got none of these things irl
VNs are just picture books. You're basically saying literature itself is for losers to live out their fantasies. That is the very essence of fiction, no matter the subject, content, or genre. That is what reading is. A place to explore possibilities that you'd never encounter in real life. And, news flash, reading is on the oldest and most popular past-times man-kind has ever known. Apologize to humanity.
shit dude, i love KS to death, but taking that glance of morbid curiousity at the general over at /vg/ literally made me horrified
those people are fucked up
999 and VLR, no romance and heavy on the mystery and atmosphere.
Try Death Mark as well. The puzzle solving isn't as good, but the story and atmosphere are top notch. Especially the DLC episode.
More like made out of passion from ripping of other anime and VN out there you fucking piece of shit
Yu-No's characters have soul!
Ayumi doesn't
>literally ripping off Raita
>soul
The fuck is this faggot talking about?
Yes,the main villain and main themes for example. Several characters also make appeareances in different games in the series. Reading it by release order really is much more enjoyable because you can quite clearly see the connections and references in there
are you really fucking implying that whole literature is on level of weebshit vns in term of self inserts?
how retarded can one user be. it really shows you didnt read many books in your life.
not every book needs to have easy to insert smart and popular MC at my age.
fiction is not the same thing as powerfantasy. good character can be relatable despite being different age or gender,
book can be good thanks to engaging story, interesting characters or overall worldbuilding
most vns got none of those traits, they are popular for different much shallower reason
most vns (and isekais) boils down to mc being same age, same ethnicity and same gender as target reader, but popular, idealised and with girls all over him just so reader can easy say
>hey that could be me
vns are the same for teenage weebs what twilight and 50shades is for teenage girls
fiction isnt bad
powerfantasy wank is bad
This is bullshit,every SciADV game makes a huge effort to make everything as believable as possible by implementing real-life science into everything that may seem even stranger without it. Many things are really well explained as to how they came to be and fit the main themes of the series. The Chaos series is still a murder-mystery at heart
Who is best katawa and why is it Lilly?
>KS releases
>mouthbreathing retards still worship it
>DDLC releases
>mouthbreathing retards worship it
What's gonna be the next VN to garner such a following?
Just say it,I want to read it too
Definetely Chaos;Head first,then Kara no Shoujo,Ever17 and lastly I/O
user criticises dating sims
that means he hates books
what
I only read moege!
There's a setting that makes the skipping stop when you reach a D-mail section
I didn't like steins gate. It's real mainstream and popular though so I don't get it since I enjoyed all the other big name VNs.
Higurashi is particularly good.
You don't realize that KS also borrows nearly every anime trope out there,do you? Does it feel so much better reading a badly thrown-together western garbage VN than a normal Japanese VN? Does that make you feel special?
>i use "western" as a pejorative
Sure why not,Danganronpa is also a VN and much more active in terms of gameplay
>Why does every VN feels so souless*
FTFY
Steins;Gate is overrates garbage and overshadows the rest of the series' games that are insanely underrated and much better,like Chaos;Head. Some user in this thread already talked about it
>not being able to comprehend that western VNs are just desperately aping off Japanese media and failing really badly at it
Just play Majikoi.
From there knock yourself out, but you should find the true destination afterwards.
>implying Western VNs are good
These both are adventure games.
any VNs that have guro/rape in them that arent saya no uta? i'll settle for some noncon implications too
>Adventure games
Sorry, they're literature. Like it or not. Just because it involves anime tiddies doesn't mean it's not a written story with the intent to entertain the reader.
You'll get over it.
Besides, you faggots can't even decide if they're games or not. Now you're going to fight on whether or not they count as literature? Just fuck right off. Retards.
You have to understand that Japanese people who make VN's don't study how humans interact. Miyazaki mentions this. Thats why you have the strangest dialogue in certain games and totally unrelatable characters(Sakura Matou for example). KS on the other hand was written by people who have that social experience to draw on. Its rich and accurate in its portrayal of human relations and social conduct. This makes it infinitely more relatable.
Do you smell the farts coming out of your ass?
number of posters didnt go up after second reply
not suprised
>hating WHOLE subgenre not for reasonable flaws like writing or art, but purely cause it wasnt made in glorious nippon
>every single Western VN is bad because its western
thats regionloathing on another level
now i bet you could spill some HONEST opinions that ks has bad writing or everlasting summer is boring. and they would be your unbiased opinions right? i wonder what would happen if you couldnt see what country is game from.
you are worst kind weaboo
go back to /jp/ and remember you will never be japanese
t. Natsuki
your reading comprehension is horrible
noone is saying they are not literature
we are saying that they are bad, lowest kind of literature
Hi anons, thanks a lot!
I stopped reading VNs. I get too immersed into anything I play/read and I couldn't handle the soul crushing depression I'd get after beating one anymore.
Play Yume Miru Kusuri, also KS is good, but it's kind of really entry level for newbies at playing vns, and don't hold it as a standard for vns, it has it's problems but KS is good for someone new in vns, but don't hold it so high
You are right about Sakura being unrelatable.
Everything she does frustrates me as a reader, let along her annoying tendencies.
>Japanese people
>Thats why you have the strangest dialogue
we both know you're an EOP who reads translations though, user
What the fuck are you talking about? That second guy wasn't even me,you clearly don't know what you're talking about if you pull poster numbers out of your ass. Not liking a bad fake for being a bad fake and therefore being really bad at faking something it desperately wants to be is valid criticism by the way. You don't even have to be a weeb to realize that,so hats off to you. You can go shit up /vg/ now
Of course the nasty weeb starts talking about farting and ass first chance he gets
Depends how important you want choices. If you want some choose your own adventure thing with a billion different routes you're in the wrong genre, a lot of the time choices are just there to facilitate the early route split and to add some bad/alternate endings. Higurashi and Umineko sound like what you'd want but they don't have choices at all, they're just stories but in VN format with graphics and sound (Umineko's OST is god tier, if you don't read it at least listen to the OST). There's a site called VNDB in case you didn't know, you can look at the most popular/highly rated stuff there and look at the genre tags
He's calling you a pretentious fart sniffer,can't blame him for that
This is literally the opposite of the whole point of doujin culture. It's all made with passion, that doesn't necessarily make everything good because passion without talent doesn't result in much. But literally nobody makes a VN to get rich
>country having exclusivity to a fucking genre.
>if its not made in japan its and if its fake its bad, is a valid criticism.
>my rating of the game is based on its production origin and not on the content itself.
> i would rate differently the same product if it was made in japan or america.
you are on the same level as nintendo fans who gives +3 to game rating if it was made for or by nintendo
im not even angry, im just sad that people with such mindsets exist
also dont look where first anime took inspiration from or on what artstyle they were based on. your whole world could crumble
I'm starting to think you're acting retarded on purpose. Did I ever say that Japan has exclusivity to the typical anime tropes? No. Are westerners able to copy the tropes the Japanese have mastered and using them accordingly in their own knock-off VNs that try so hard to act like they're Japanese? No. Is that so hard to get? I also wasn't aware of the fact that the first anime in existence is created every single anime trope ever,very interesting logic that retards like you borrow from
DDLC was my first VN, so it holds a special place in my heart.
I haven't tried KS though, even though most say it's the real "first VN" to try. Is it legit good, or is it like DDLC where the characters are what let it have any semblance of being great?
Neither DDLC nor KS are great though
Legit good.
Said the Fate fag.
the fuck tropes you talking about.
we were talking about games as a whole
anyway really not a single vn outside of japan cannot make those tropes good in your opinion?
western vn doesnt need to copy or use japanese tropes at all to be called vn, sometimes they can even subvert those tropes.
you dont hate western vns for
>bad use of japanese tropes
you hate them just for being western
just be honest with yourself . Would you rate the same way identical vn but one was japanese and the other one western
But is it good?
Opinions from people who don't just play English original VNs please
House in Fata Morgana and Umineko off the top of my head.
>Overused tropes are bad and you should feel bad
Just throw in some galaga between chapters and youre set
EOP discussing translated only VNs
tbf only the good VNs get translated
come on user you know he wont answer that question. we already know the answer, he is biased /jp/fag