I actually liked how they didn't just make the protag switch between Arthur and John a superficial model / voice change but they actually made it so that there are things you start as Arthur but can only finish as John and scenes made specifically for John whereas the RDR1 epilogue really does that for the one mission where you take down Edgar Ross as Jack. RDR2 is basically the model on how to do post-game sections in games like this.
What did Yea Forums think of the story and Arthur in Red Dead Redemption 2?
Isaiah Phillips
Kevin Campbell
No more Redemption title. Time to close the book of Van Der Line gang tale and open up a new tale with new Red Dead title. I want my peak 1870s Wild West goddammit.
Brody Lewis
No more ham fisted sad endings that completely ruin the tone of the endgame/exploration aspects of the open world game. Sick of being emotionally manipulated into feels over good characters in shitty games with average gameplay.
Andrew Butler
Need a DLC about tbe Blackwater heist. I wanna see how it actually went to shit and meet the Collander boys and that dude that bled to death on the Wagon.
Hunter Diaz
>RD2 ending is hamfisted
Are you retarded?
Lucas Hughes
>not wanting to play as mac
>not wanting to be arthur in blackwater scheming with hosea in an eternal summer scenario
wtf mate
Sebastian Fisher
I also wanna see young Jenny. She was mentioned to have been killed but unlike the Callanders who were mentioned to have been shot specifically Jenny was killed in an unspecified way maybe captured and hanged?
But yeah, I'd love that DLC too. We would need to play as a non-Arthur protag though since Arthur did not participate.
Hunter Ward
We play as Mac Callander obviously, the ending is with him half dead with a pool of blood around him and Milton is crouching over like the parasite ghoul he is.
Aaron Perez
You don't think the pacing towards the final chapters is very erratic and the epilogue is nothing but fanservice and very hacked together just so it can lead into the first game and have a reason to exist.
Owen White
Yeah I'd like that. Maybe put some content in New Austin as well, Mac is more convenient than Davey because we know what Davey looks like but we don't know much about Mac.