The show on the right

>The show on the right
-Minimal hype along the lines of "oh, the guy who did Bake and the guy who did Saya no Uta are teaming up; might be cool"
-Far and away the biggest hit of the season; beats the show that was supposed to save anime ("FROM THE CREATOR OF the HARUHI ED dance")
-Lauded by elder statesmen of the anime industry, including Kazuo Koike and Miyazaki
-DVDs and merch still sell like hotcakes today
-At or near the top of most "Best Anime of the 2010s" lists

>The show on the left
-Hailed as practically second coming; as show that will "save anime" (sound familiar?)
-Kyoani cult shills the hell out of it, responding to people who even say the trailer just looks "okay" with thread derails and Yea Forums-tier console warring like this boards.fireden.net/a/thread/168895417/#q168902889
-Show debuts; sells less than a literal camping gear commercial
-Reception ranges from "okay" to "mediocre"
-Said cultist fanboys continue to attack nonbelievers and silence criticism

Kinda makes you think.

Attached: 1548298202811.jpg (4000x3023, 1.23M)

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/4t-GV4XcJak
violet-evergarden.jp/world/
twitter.com/SFWRedditVideos

Hard work > natural talent

This is why SHAFT will always be superior to Kyoto Animation.

I don't get the hype for madoka though. What am I missing?

Not OP but I guess you can try watching it instead of pretending you have because you’ve watched some YouTube clips. That’d be a good place to start.

Not to jump the gun but I think just calling Madoka the best anime of 2010’s is underselling it. I believe it changed a lot regarding the industry and managed to do it while being a great anime where as a lot of other influential series do that same thing but aren’t very exciting to watch.

Don't be an asshole. I watched it and for me it does not match the hype that surrouds it at all. And I am genuinelly curious to understand why you can't shut up about how good it is.

When will you ACTUALLY watch it? I know you’re saying you’ve watched it but when are you going to close down the site and literally watch the series instead of saying you have? Anybody who has seen it would instantly understand the question you’re asking.

>makes me think
The only thoughts Veg managed to evoke was what a goddamn shame it was that it didn't end 6 episodes in.

why are you so obsessed?

Attached: violet.png (1920x1080, 2.55M)

autism

That’s like saying you didn’t understand the hype behind EoE. I don’t like EoE but I can understand why it’s so influential and why so many people love it. It’s something you just know. The fact that you’re saying you can’t even understand the hype behind Madoka kind of makes it seem like you’re entire experience with the series is Wiki and YouTube reviews.

your*

and yet you made this thread. worse than both fanbases.

>he doesnt think violet evergarden is the greatest anime of the past 4 years
must be tough having taste this shit

Attached: came to have a giggle.png (1200x1035, 1.5M)

You weren't supposed to figure out yet that we're literally sending the Reichskommissars to silence dissent.

Attached: 1551661230262.jpg (1000x936, 132K)

Well that's not the case. I thought it was fine. A perfectly serviceable show. Nothing less, nothing more.
I liked the designs, even though I disliked the artwork and the quality of the animation felt inconsistent. The characters were kinda bland but the plot was interesting and creative.
But I don't get why it gets heralded as the second coming of christ. Is it because of waifufags? Is it because of the dark tone? Is it because of the subversion meme? Is it because of yuribait?
I don't get it.
But since you don't seem willing to explain yourself or even have any kind of a discussion I guess I will be better off actually watching some youtube review since at the very least I will get a different opinion.

2019, Madoka still hasn't changed anything. When is this supposed influence supposed to start exactly?

How about we list some ACTUAL influential anime for comparison.

Mazinger Z
Gundam
Minky Momo
Urusei Yatsura
Dragonball
Sailor Moon
Pokemon

Now please tell me what Madoka brought to the table that had never been done before and how it influenced anime over the last decade. Or admit it wasn't influential at all.

Eva is objectively a piece of shit though, only redeeming value is the music & Rei/Asuka
> Madoka is yuribait
Yep you never watched it, Everyone is canonically gay except Mami & Sayaka who is Bi

> Not mentioning Utena
Kill yourself

>still butthurt after over a year
How does it feel to have a cute anime girl living in your head RENT FREE?

Attached: Violet-Evergarden.png (1920x1080, 2.15M)

Both are boring shit.

>has to endure days of artillery fire in the trenches
>has to endure the stench of the dead for months on end
>can't bathe for weeks
>has to shit in the trenches
>shrapnel, dirt, pieces of dead bodies flying overhead
>charge the enemy through artillery fire, machine gun fire, and rifle fire
>loses both arms
>gets labeled a war criminal
Being Violetto is suffering

Attached: peaceful, silent Argonnerwaldlied in the distance.png (768x512, 336K)

You realize how much more magical girl series were created directly after Madoka right and how many of them even were almost directly trying to copy the series. Maybe try watching.. the.. damn.. show.

w-would you watch it with me?

I think Madoka is the best anime in the world and I’ve seen your favorite anime twice.

What a raging homo

go suck a cock op may your thread die under 100 replies like all the others

I will give you an answer.
I liked the show because of many things.
first the harsh contrast between the cutesy visuals and the tragic story. then the subverting of expectations. i just think pulling off something like that is not very easy. also the word shows some interesting visuals like the tech in the classroom or how madokas house looked. the show didn't have to include something like that to be a good story. but in doing so gave me something interesting to look while slower story parts were happening.
the consistency in the story was also a nice part. i just hate it when someone dies or something bad happens and two episodes later everything is forgotten.
the twist at the end was also great. on the first watch you have no clue if homura is a good or a bad. but on the second watch everything makes sense and you see all the little details in her character.
it's not a flawless anime tho. they should have used more grafik violence.
in the end not everything will hit your taste.

We have edgy magical girls anime airing every fucking season now. Before Madoka it happened once a decade.

Attached: [HorribleSubs] Mahou Shoujo Tokushusen Asuka - 05 [720p].mkv_snapshot_06.09.265.png (1280x720, 1.93M)

At least you gave me an answer, though it seems I was more or less right in guessing it is mostly because it's a dark magical girl show.
Now I know I wasn't missing anything.

It’s so much more than just a dark magical girl show. There’s a reason this one stands out as one of if not the best anime of all time. Try watching it.

you cant make me

Can we just fucking kill VEGtards, they have been insufferable lately

There’s tons of dark magical girl shows. That’s not why this one gets praised. Almost all magical girl shows end up being dark anyways. Madoka isn’t even really that dark in comparison if you want to go deep into it. The story of Madoka is why it stands out. Not the darkness.

You obviously never watched other magical girl shows. Your reply is painful

both are dead now so it doesn't matter

Attached: U5dtBW.jpg (986x986, 110K)

> Madoka is dead
> A new show is coming out this year, And we all know Movie 4 is confirmed

>please tell me what Madoka brought to the table that had never been done before
Nanoha had a larger effect on magical girl anime than Madoka did

>Madoka
A smartphone game, Magia Record, launched in August 2017, and an anime adaptation will be released in 2019.

Attached: 700899.jpg (890x634, 139K)

Sailor Moon gets dark
Tutu is dark
Utena is dark
Etc

sounds soulless as fuck

It didn’t but you can go away now ACK. You know you love Madoka.

And it will still end up being AOTY the year it’s released.

R E N T
F R E E

Attached: 1542987756923.png (722x648, 631K)

nice drone mentality

I like both.

Attached: idort3.jpg (400x342, 7K)

it's safe to say VEG fags live to bait

It’s not a drone. It’s a promise. If Inu Curry is involed and we get SHAFT head tilts and good music it’s guaranteed to be better than your favorite anime.

Then explain your reasons to me instead of keep telling me to watch a show I have already wasted 5 hours of my time watching instead of doing anything more fulfilling.

LOL NO YOU DONT YOU IDORT

Attached: u wot.png (1020x829, 1.09M)

How about instead of missing out on the anime of the century and the greatest episode of all time throughout anime history in episode ten of Madoka you cut your bullshit and go watch it for yourself like everybody else. We shouldn’t have to actively try and get you to watch a series like Madoka. As far as I’m concerned you’re a fake anime fan. In my eyes not having seen Madoka is like talking to somebody who missed Eva but claims to be an anime fan.

No you're fucking shaft drone/fanboy fag making your mind up something is good with the reasons you listed. I'd say the same shit if you were shilling the same for a kyoanus show.

No studio is inherently good. There's only good individuals/animators in the industry that bounce between different teams often, not the soulless studios.

> Anime of the century
> Thinking Madoka is even in the conversation let alone the best
YIKES

Attached: Spirited Away.jpg (425x571, 38K)

KHK, please commit suicide ASAP

Teaches me not to try to have a discussion on Yea Forums.
I will just keep trusting my opinion and my opinion alone instead of trying to actively engage with faggots like you.
Fuck you and fuck homura. I hope her and madoka never meet again.

I like spirited away as much as the next guy, but posting it in this contest will just earn you the label of normalfag.
Should have posted a Masaaki Yuasa work or something.

Madoka is overrated and Madokafags are insufferable. I've never seen another fanbase so arrogantly try to proclaim their favorite anime as AOTC as many times as I've seen Madokafags do so, unless it's one autistic retard repeating himself at every opportunity.

Attached: 1453070096100.png (420x420, 176K)

>Minimal hype along the lines of "oh, the guy who did Bake and the guy who did Saya no Uta are teaming up; might be cool"
You're forgetting someone.

Attached: 1538589309067.jpg (1280x720, 359K)

Select your meguca

Attached: 1552856311292.jpg (1047x1200, 292K)

>spirited away
>yikes

Dude. You’re so shitty at making bait.

You wouldn’t know if they’ve even met because you’ve never watched the anime. You don’t know anything.

>both have new projects in development
>dead

Nobody thinks Madoka Magica is AOTC. It’s either the greatest anime of all time or it’s actually literally god in the form of a tv series.

Madoka isn't nearly as popular as you think it is, there was a poll with 479k people voting & Madoka didn't even make the top 90. Even Kill La Kill was rated 40 spots higher

It’s not about popularity even though the Madoka game brings in like 300x more than Kill la Kill does. It’s about the fact that Madoka is probably the best story ever told.

> Madoka cucks actually believe this
LMAO! It wouldn't even be in the top 15 in terms of Manga & Anime alone, let alone all of fiction

Madoka Magica is the greatest story ever told in my opinion and I’ve been watching anime since Inuyasha first aired.

I could easily name tons of better anime & manga storylines then Madoka, and i genuinely liked it

PMMM is in fact a masterpiece.

watch better animes

They both suck, Kyoani and Shaft attract the worst pompous autists.

You're delusional, it wouldn't even be the best anime airing this season.

which will it be then?

lmao euthanize yourself

>Team is called "Magica Quartet"
>Shinbo
>Urobutcher
>Green pervert

Who was the fourth?

Mob II, Dororo, and Boogie are unironically better.

Both are shit and probably the most overrated shows of the decade, though VEG is slightly shitter

>adaptations
really nigga?

Attached: 1501164634407.jpg (1280x720, 139K)

see

Yes, these adaptations are better than Madoka.

how so?

Show on the right:

Nigger-tier character designs.
Slideshow animation.
Edgelord "story".

Show on the left:

An above average show with excellent art.

>dude flares lmao

While I don't like Madoka that much, I welcome every occasion to shit on VEG subhumans.

Attached: 155301103451.jpg (790x583, 79K)

>cheap filters
>excellent art
Bruh, look at this dude

Yes because VEG was animated solely through the use of filters moron

Attached: evergarden.jpg (1280x765, 314K)

there is not need for name calling

Show on the right:

Cheap, generic LN designs.
Badly implemented PS2 tier cgi.
Soap opera "drama".

Retard.

Mecha in disguise magical girls like Nanoha were literally never made again. Nanoha is still the only one in the sub genre.

>Madoka hasn't influenced anything
>Adult themed magical girl shows air literally every other season now
I refuse to believe you aren't shitposting user. Here's your (You), you fucking retard

>show about becoming magical girls to defeat witches
>turns into dark reality with actual death
>turns into selling your soul for a wish and magic powers
>turns into converting heroines into the enemies they were fighting
>turns into aliens using magical girls as farm animals for resources all along
>turns into MC isn't the MC of the show, it's actually the antagonist who is the hero
>turns into time-traveling turmoil
>turns into titular mc kamikaze'd herself into God incarnate to protect the past AND future
>turns into MC the only one carrying on the message of God
All in 12 fucking episodes. Not to mention cute girls, a bangin' Op., and some pretty nice art-styles along the way?
Yeah, Madoka is definitely deserving of its praise. And this is coming from someone who just finished binge-watching for the first time 4 minutes ago

and the movie ruins all that development
Enjoy!

I hate plotfags so fucking much

And even then, you have character struggle, character development, social themes, tension, and moral issues that are woven into this insane fucking plot.
What now? You still hate it for some reason? Because you are a brainlet?

Don't reply to me

eat dicks nigger
here's a (you)

How fucking dare you

Sounds like a jumbled mess of shit.

This thread is a VEG discordnigger trolling. 100%.
This is not an honest attempt to talk about anything.

Attached: 5FKaXgA.png (500x453, 285K)

Attached: saberclone a shit.png (476x537, 219K)

Not him, but sure. I want to watch it again anyways.

Vividred was a thing, and I loved it.

Watch more anime faggot, literally all of these utterly shit on Madoka in terms of story

Attached: imgonline-com-ua-CompressToSize-9ckqzCCc0Yt.jpg (2012x1887, 3.72M)

All those anime are unknown pieces of shit besides Lain and Madoka is far better than that show.

> Spirited Away, Utena, Higurashi, Nausicaa, Umineko, Promised Neverland, Perfect Blue
> Unknown
Kill yourself underage

Figure of speech. Those anime suck.

>Yea Forums hates madoka now
Whay went wrong?

Attached: 1450733314342.png (500x377, 226K)

A couple recap movies and rebellion.
Plus I'd wager no less 90% of Yea Forums weren't posters in 2011.

>minimal hype
hidamari fans hyped the shit out of it (I know I was one of them)

I don't even think it's possible to have a nice VEG thread

>Still mad about Rebellion.
Kek.

>Lauded by elder statesmen of the anime industry, including Kazuo Koike and Miyazaki
Sauce?

How VEG is dead if we have 5-10 threads per day full of meaningful discussion?

Madoka popularized the mahou shojo genre.

Madoka is ONE of the best anime of all time but calling it AOTC is just bait

>madoka
>didn't win the Oscar
>VEG movie
>wins Oscar very soon
I don't know Rick

VEG
>low-key sells
>can't beat camping anime
>not even best in its season bottom of the barrel
>literally got beaten by two camping anime
>instagram visual for no brainer

How does that even apply here?

Because it's cute girls doing edgy things, a subversion of the cute girls doing cute things which is what most people expected

>the only excuse madokafags can come up with to defend their favorite show is that you didn't watch it so your opinion is invalid
you know who else used to say that?
bronies.

Real madokafags don't say that, only baiting nigs

And I am here, thinking of both shows as incredibly lackluster products. Coincidentally, what saves both anime is their audio direction. Madoka's TV release looked absolutely appalling and it feels like they redrew half the show for the blurays, all while it does virtually nothing but throw twists and terribly exaggerated teenage stereotypes at its audience. Meanwhile VEG is just downright shallow for the vast majority of its episodes while being littered with amateurishly used establishing and invetory shots. But I guess you gotta give them credit for the fact that they didn't have to fix half the show for the homevideo release.

As cringe as VEG posters are, people like this clown are even worse . I can't even begin to imagine how much of a newfag someone like him must be, given how shows like Sailor Moon, Doremi and Kamikaze Jeanne used to air on public television in like a dozen+ countries around the globe. You people really are the perfect match for eachother. Ignorant teenager as far as the eye can see.

>and I’ve been watching anime since Inuyasha first aired.
Doesn't matter. What matters is how many different anime you've seen, from how many different eras they are and how many different genres they are part of. You could watch anime for 30 years, 10 shows a year, and be a bigger newfag than someone who's watched anime for less than 6 months.

>The show on the right
forgotten
>The show on the left
The best TV anime of all times, new standard for TV animation. AOTD.

Lol

>the second best selling anime of all time vs a literal who show
The winner is pretty obvious.

Attached: 1428002951487.png (248x313, 84K)

let them have their delusions, they do try so hard

Attached: 1533283171460.png (200x275, 41K)

Attached: 90400423.jpg (680x510, 59K)

yeah, it's totally NOT madoka fault we still ahve edgy mahou shojo every fucking season

>A bangin' OP
Pretty sure you're meant the ED, not OP.

How can someone list 8 twists for 12 episodes and believe for this to be a good thing. Never seizes to amaze me. You people really crave stimulation, don't you?

>"You people really crave stimulation, don't you?"
That's the whole point of entertainment you fucking tard

Reminder

Attached: 1549381365325.webm (640x480, 2.91M)

Fuck you for this bait thread you keep posting every fucking time. When will 20th Century Electric Boogaloo air. This KyoAni dry spell is making the KyoAni shitpost threads repetitive as fuck.

>more terrible LNshit
Who cares. When's Maidragon 2?

By JC Staff

My guess it will come out in 2021 or 2022.

No

>he still thinks Kyoanus is going to animate Iruru who they completely ignored during the first season

Ignore that guy, he lurks around waiting for someone to mention maidragon to say it will be done by jc staff.
>inb4 he goes "are you delusional you fucking retard?" to anyone who calls him out like always

That doesn't make any sense, given that SHAFT is lazy and creative as fuck while KyoAni just makes everything in a conventional but really polished way, speaking as a fan of both studios.

>madotard at it again
I never shilled this show before the season and i'm not studio cultist but this was amazing. When is the shitpsting going to fucking stop?

Nah, you deserve it

I'm an anime only who wasn't in a single Violet thread before the season. I just genuinely like this amazing show. How do I deserve it? I hate all studio cultists, they don't care about anime and will just defend a studios decisions good/bad. Blame the fucking mods for not cleaning up shit.

Do you really think that anyone will fall for your retardedly obvious bait khk? Fuck the oscars and fuck you nigger.

>be an anime hating scumbag
>be an insufferable piece of shit to the point where people wish death upon you
>proceed to write this comment
OH THE IRONY.

Attached: 1552821714195.png (1280x720, 1.34M)

Can we agree its one of the best of the century?
youtu.be/4t-GV4XcJak

what do you expect? the haters are literally braindead. These autist don't have the capacity to appreciate anime of the decade.

Attached: 35894775349534.png (1920x1080, 2.7M)

>Japanese style rice fields in 19th century not-Australia, with both palm trees and pine trees around them
This is why LN writers and the people who adapt their garbage should all be lined up and shot.

It's not-Pangaea.

Doesn't make it any less retarded and half assed.

We have these in Europe too you mongoloid. What 3rd world country are you from?

It does, but I doubt I'll be able to change your mind.

Actually, do not think too much, everything that Violet Evergarden lacks, Madoka has.

Did you also use to bow and eat japanese food, you dumbfuck?
It doesn't, because it showcases the same exact lack of effort into creating a believable ecosystem and culture as the rest of this LNshit.

Because you've made up your mind, don't care and are actively looking for reasons to hate the show.
violet-evergarden.jp/world/

Attached: 1552337281597.gif (466x479, 1017K)

>all this detail
>half assed
DIE

Attached: 937478253475.png (1920x1080, 2.23M)

>Did you also use to bow and eat japanese food, you dumbfuck?
You have mental illness. Do something about your irrationality.

hot

>can't even read
If the teenager who wrote this tripe shouldn't be blamed for the low quality and lack of thought put into the whole thing, the anime staff certainly should for not turning it into something acceptable.
Oh wow, a few shitty infodumps relegated into outside material. Does it fix the unimaginative and artificious mishmash of random shit without a single original idea of the anime? Have you even idea of how to do good worldbuilding for a fictional world?
I'll give you one example of it done right: The Wings of Honneamise. Every single detail of the world, from the tools they use, the dress they wear, their architecture, their technology, their rituals and cerimonies, their toys, their entertaiment, their beliefs, was meticolously crafted to be unique and different than ours but still believable and internally consistent, and it's all so precise and well done that you immediately feel immersed in this world and even wish to see more. And all this in significantly less runtime than VEG and while telling a better story.
Even comparing the effort that went into creating the setting of Honneamise to the lazy LNshit of VEG is insulting.
Damn, you sure showed me.

Attached: honneamise1.jpg (620x445, 112K)

Pic related is why

Attached: What makes Madoka good.png (2880x1800, 842K)

>VEGtards
is where you belong.

I did say that I didn't think I'd be able to change your mind.
But let me say this: basing your initial argument on the throwaway meme that was not-Australia, which was passed around briefly in VEG threads past, does not make me expect intellectual honesty with regard to VEG from your part.

That sure sounds like a convenient excuse to not address my post.

what went wrong?

Attached: [DB]Puella Magi Madoka Magica_-_01_(Dual Audio_10bit_BD1080p_x265).webm (1920x1080, 1.22M)

Then let's leave it at that.
I'm not about to start fighting about The Wings of Honneamise and VEG.

What about Evan Genesis Neongelion? Is it better than Meduka Meguca and Garden Everviolet?

Attached: 1551819056016.jpg (3992x2467, 2.06M)

Evangelion > Violet Evergarden >>>>>> power gap >>>>>> madoka

>can't even read
Oh I read your post but it's fucking invalid as proven by other anons before.

>mishmash
>not original
Wow you contradicted yourself in your own sentence.

Rebellion was great.
Yea Forums just hate everything and call you a shill or contrarian if you like it.

Evangelion is fucking overrated and only boomer with nostalgia Googles like that show. Dont know about the movies.

I held off killing myself to watch VEG. I have since resumed those plans.

Wait for the movie.

Dont watch it if you want to live later.
Its eye candy but plot is shit.

Yeah, sure.
There's nothing original about putting in a generic Belle Époque setting some inexplicable robot arms and random japanese customs. It's just lazy, unimaginative LN tripe.

Attached: honneamise 3b.jpg (1600x920, 207K)

If he hasn't already, he should watch it. Or at least ep10.

Attached: truth.jpg (526x549, 148K)

tl dr
>it's shit because i have shit taste

nothing.

Attached: 1326544855.jpg (76x88, 2K)

>implying
not him, that's a distance shot. Violet Evergarden's designs are very detailed, there's no excuse for madoka. Also the shadows.

>It's just lazy
What a load of bullshit. That means nothing when you can't accuse the realisation of being lazy. This show is as far removed from laziness as it gets.

It's pretty clear from the resolution that is a distance shot. This on the other hand, isn't.

Nice rare. Saved.

Eva>=Madoka>>>>>>Veg

Newfags
Rebellion was a perfect sequel, Yea Forums is retarded

Iwakami.

Evergarden > Madoka > NGE

Madoka > your favorite anime

but user...
madoka is my favorite anime

That’s Madoka is especially better than that.

Attached: 1231654744666.png (269x440, 230K)

Checked.
What a potent hagu.

LOGH > Madoshit

still a distance shot.

this, but unironically
Higurashi is a better "time leap" anime than Madoka and I'm a massive Shaftfag. Even Fate/Extra and the Fireworks movie was better than Madoka. (not quite true desu, but rebellion was pretty shit)

Attached: PinexPalm.jpg (297x397, 49K)

that's another distance shot you underage faggot

Sure, bud.

Attached: distanceshot.jpg (3072x2304, 2.8M)

Still missing the rice field, bud.

Attached: 24893237829845.png (1128x635, 510K)

>HAS HASN'T REALISED THAT LN'S ARE THE HIGHEST FORM OF LITERATURE
a moment for this user

Attached: 230847289324.png (640x480, 627K)

Rice can be grown in any warmer climate - how dumb are you?

>SHAAAAAFT!!!!
Saving anime AND also popular in both Chinas.
>Kyoanus
Can only make money off China.

in the foreground and it's shit (and in fact the whole whole sequence is shit)

Attached: ninja Saber.jpg (1920x1080, 235K)

>khk still pretending to be retreaded
I can cherry-pick too.

Attached: 93843792743895.png (1920x1080, 2.28M)

It's very fun to post images of Violet but I'm sorry, this is my last reply.

Attached: 12365448774465.png (1920x1080, 643K)

Well schizo kun this is what the average scene looked like.

Attached: 0493284450435484.png (1920x1080, 1.15M)

You won't be missed.

So, you can't find one. k

Why are these 2 shows getting shitposted endlessly?

>5-10 threads per day full of meaningful discussion?
>one newfag spamming the catalog with DOA tiolet veggergarden threads that reach ~10 posts with 7 ips max
Fucking kek. Did you really think Yea Forums is retarded enough not to notice?
Even the live threads were fucking dead with 60 ips and bump limit after more than a day.
Dream on VEGGturd.

I want that image but with your autistic hat!

The shows aren't very good but the fanbases are extremely delusional and defensive, a deadly combination.

>How VEG is dead if we have 5-10 threads per day full of meaningful discussion?
My sides.
You have either waifu threads dedicated to Violet that die after 10 posts, or purely shitposting threads like this that only get replies because you try to pick a fight with another fanbase to stay relevant. "Meaningful discussion" was already dead while the show was airing.

autism.

Both fanbases believe their show is exceptionally good (but only one really is), so comparing them helps stir up "discussion", especially for the worse one.
I won't say Veg is shit, but other than being pretty it really didn't impress me like Madoka did.
Also autism, Madoka has some of the most autistic fans on Yea Forums right now

Attached: image.png (209x265, 53K)

Not so fast

You can complain about veg's animation and story all you want, but there's no denying that the ost is god tier

It's shit, not because of the quality of the music itself, but because of how it's used. There's not a single fucking second of runtime when the orchestra isn't blasting at full volume, trying to tell you what emotion you should be feeling every damn moment. Someone should learn the value of silence.

>being this new
They're both anime of the decade contenders.

>It's shit, not because of the quality of the music itself, but because of how it's used. There's not a single fucking second of runtime when the orchestra isn't blasting at full volume, trying to tell you what emotion you should be feeling every damn moment. Someone should learn the value of silence.
seething

Madoka is just pulling gadget after gadget out of your ass with cookiecutter characters while violet actually gives characters meaning and development. The show is NOT about Violet. Its about the characters around her.

>trying to tell you what emotion you should be feeling every damn moment
wow you're a retard. i never once thought this while watching this. I notice a lot of people's problems with this shows seem to come from their own preconceptions.

That's literally what Madoka is about lmao

I'm sorry that you aren't very perceptive.

I'm sorry that you read into things too much and that it prevents you from enjoying genuinely good shows.

Madoka is a forgotten show. Nobody cares, only a handful of mega-autists who desperately bump their dead shitpost thread.

The sound direction trying too hard to spoonfeed the emotion of every scene on you is a legitimate flaw, without preconceptions attached, and something that anyone who doesn't consume media entirely passively will immediately notice and be annoyed with. The show either doesn't have faith in the audience's sensibility, intelligence and attention, or in its own ability of actually being able to deliver on the scenes. Either way, it's shit, made specifically for the braindead bingewatching Netflix audience.

Legitimately why does bait get to stay up constantly and an animation thread deleted

This coming from a vegfag, lmao. Actual good discussion of Rebellion is fairly frequent buddy, despite the autistic shitposters.

See

>vegfag
>implying
stop replying to yourself "lmao"

>This coming from a vegfag, lmao
More like a typical desperate Madoka autist LARPing as another series fan. There is no depth Madokafags won't stoop to.

You're probably right, fuck this thread anyway

>tfw no talent or will to work hard
Am I better than either one of them?

Are you upset because no one ever compared Madoka writing to Charles Dickens and Oscar Wilde?

Ahhhhh! Guys! I’m going crazy! I just finished binge watching Madoka and I don’t even know where the fuck to start. Holy shit. This is the only thread up right now so I’ll take it. I take back everything I’ve ever said that’s negative about the series. I take it all back. I don’t even know what the fuck happened guys. I DONT EVEN UNDERSTAND WHAT THE FUCK HAPPENED! All I know is Mami broke a teacup and Kyoko threw an apple down the river at the end? What the fuck was that? Who was the girl with the white hair? Why did Homura just lose her shit and become satan? She literally made Sayaka cry just by talking to her. She said she was going to destory the world? Didn’t she built it? Holy shit! I have so many questions!

Also the Incubators are aliens? Am I retarded or is that what they are? I think I remember them saying that and that they built human life from scratch or something.

Homura is in her late twenties because of the time skips? Her brain aged every time?

And now I’m guessing she’s the enemy of Madoka who she supposedly loves the most and she’s going to be the enemy of everybody once the wraiths are killed? Why? Why wouldn’t she just try to rekindle their relationship and explain herself? Does she have to fight?

The intro ending change in episode ten was amazing btw. That entire episode was probably one of the better episodes of anime I’ve ever seen in my life. Top thee for sure.

Yikes.

And episode 11-12 makes for possibly the cleanest ending ever with no question. I’ve never in my life seen an anime end as neet as this Madoka series did. Fucking hell. Rebellion was almost not even needed but it was so good that I’m still glad it exists. I’m not even sure which I enjoyed more at this point because I don’t even know if I can comprehend what I seen in Rebellion without watching some theory videos and discussing this series for a bit.

Also who was the white haired girl? I think I missed something major.

This thread is too slow. I’m going to go find some videos on what the hell it is I just witnessed. I’ll be back later if anybody bothers to answer any of the posted questions. I have a ton more. Like, a TON more but I can’t even think right now.

If you're real just start a new thread

I enjoyed Violet Evergarden

It wasn't fantastic, but it was still good

Will KyoAni win a fourth straight AOTY?

Attached: 1532264090213.jpg (2494x2060, 2.18M)

>Reception ranges from "okay" to "mediocre"
projecting
both great

>Minimal hype
Holy shit you're serious aren't you?
It was advertised to hell and back.

Attached: 451a9bf9546f5ff4395a99d314d52d9428037070_hq.gif (500x281, 1.3M)

>Shaft
So fucking lazy they finish episodes minutes before it's suppose to air on TV. Shaft's BDs and TV releases are night and day.
>KyoAni
They finish their shows weeks before it's suppose to air and barely fix anything in their BDs.

Attached: 1547935259414.jpg (1920x1080, 219K)

MOLNING LESCUE

That just means you're bad at explaining stuff, though. Fucking moron.

probably. the industry is dead and Kyoani is the only one putting out actually good anime right now.

dont throw souls

It gives the lower threads a moment of respite, after which the autists spreads once again into the blue board

Why do you keep making threads on it fag? We get it you don't like "x" anime.

Attached: sherachib.jpg (480x480, 29K)

Kyoani's frame-to-frame animation is polished. Everything else is sacrificed for that animation and it results in a neverending stream of mediocrity.

They are both nice