>It wasn't that good...
what kind of person do you imagine
It wasn't that good
Julian Richardson
Logan Sanders
determinist
Kevin Morris
Jose Brown
An idiot who thinks he’s smart
Nicholas Watson
>garnett translation
understandable - at least it wasn't p&v's i guess
should've read slater's or ready's, hell, even mcduff's
Jordan Brown
the fuck is bad about p&v?
Ian Johnson
Austin Nguyen
An ordinary person becomes tortured by his own misunderstood ideas of "greatness" that he commits a heinous crime in order to prove to himself that he is just like those "great" people he admired.
Then he tortures himself mentally and psychologically of what he had done, thus concluding that he is no so "great" after all...
It's a timeless idea so well demonstrated. Gud book.
Carson Sanchez
>slater's or ready's
I can't imagine preferring these also-rans to Garnett, the superior prose stylist by a mile.
Brody Scott
The stereotypical contrarian
Someone that says X book is overrated or something to hide in advance the fact that he hasnt read it. By saying X is overrated he states that has read it but doesnt want to discuss it because if you try and discuss it you become the brainlet that likes X even tho X is overrated.
Noah Murphy
me
Kayden Bennett
Yes. This is the aspect of the book that is so great to me. Not just the descriptive thriller aspect, but the timeless aspect of this plot line.
Nathan Rodriguez
what's wrong with Garnett?
>linking other people's opinions instead of defending yourself like a normal person
Logan Rogers
It was good but the Idiot was better
Joshua Sanchez
Some materialist retard.
Tyler Garcia
A good 200 pages could have been chopped off and nothing would have been lost. Too many pointless subplots. Reads like a Dickens novel, and that's not a compliment.
Owen Ramirez
Must be a man of taste, since it is easily Dosto's worst work
Luis Davis
A contrarian retard. Even a normie could find enjoyment out of it.
Hudson Powell
Other than the above two URLs do you have a good account to refer to for Tolstoy/Dost/Gogol translations and their stylistic differences?
Nicholas Collins
C&P is one of the ten best novels ever written.
>hasn't read The Idiot
BK and Demons are both great but C&P is just so iconic.
Oliver Taylor
> Boring waifu characters
> Forced happy ending for everyone
> Nonsense villain in like three scenes who kills himself
> Bland philosophy
I can see why Yanks love it, but it's easily one of his weaker books.
James Edwards
risk of pregnancy
James Sanders
>" "
Josiah Phillips
>commentarymagazine.com
fuck I hadn't seen this before I'm mad
have had to read p&v crime and punishment + notes from underground for school and looks like I got the butchered version