Is he right Yea Forums?
Is he right Yea Forums?
Robert Williams
Eli Ortiz
uh. yeah.
Michael Reyes
He's just coping Jordan Peele.
Logan Edwards
PARTLY —A COMPLETE WORK OF ARTIFICE SHOULD BE COMPREHENDED WITH NO EXTRA EXPLANATION FROM THE AUTHOR, BUT DAVID LYNCH'S RELUCTANCE TO COMMENT RE HIS WORKS IS MORE DUE TO HIS INCOHERENCE, AND LACK OF COMPREHENSION, THAN DUE TO PRINCIPLE OF INTEGRITY.
Brandon Foster
That's total fucking bullshit.
Ian Cooper
LYNCHED
Jason Sullivan
You're not quirky, interesting and above all, will never be a woman; filtered
Hudson Hill
Brandon Hall
Jackson Anderson
BUT RÆVSSQANDVS DEPENDENCE ON HIS WRITING AESTHETIC IS MORE DUE TO ATTENTION WHORING, AND LACK OF DECENCY, THAN DUE TO PRINCIPLE OF STYLE.
William Barnes
Pleb filtered hard.
Cope.
Adrian Miller
there is a dialogue between you and a work of art that is not in language, you risk losing things when you put it into words
tHIS IS a little bit true, one notices in the language he uses that the ideas are talked of as separate from him, and that they come from some mysterious place - this is how he retains purity of self-expression that also transcends himself, and it becomes more than the sum of its parts. He is nearly the perfect embodiment of the artist type psychologically.
Jaxon Morris
LYNCHED
Isaac Watson
What's the fun in having every little thing explained to you? Besides, the fun of surrealism is taking some things completely at face value.
Nathan Brown
I don't say this often, but LYNCHED.
Daniel Flores
He's a shaman
Sebastian Richardson
Of course.
Owen Fisher
If you want to hear the director to explain the movie to you why even bother watching? The wonderful about art is the meaning that you can take from it, not what somebody says to you what it means.
Stop being cucks.
Austin Young
No truer words have ever been spoken, and as expected truth is rejected by fools. Pitiful.
Ian Nguyen
INTUITION, AND REASON, ARE NOT MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE; ONE CAN BE ABLE TO PERCEIVE SPIRITUAL INFORMATION, AND ALSO BE ABLE TO RENDER IT INTO CONCEPTS, AND ARTICULATE IT WITH VERB.
Austin Carter
Absolutely. Even corporate schlock gives you some look into the minds of the people in charge of it.
Alexander Brown
It just reminds me of how the directors of the Avengers movies talked about all kinds of off screen details after that last one came out and it's like shut the fuck up, this shit doesn't matter and is actually fucking lame
Chase Ward
Yes, but not everyone is endowed with qualities in equal proportions in themselves. Yes, one can, but *should* the artist? The work would be drastically different, a recipe for bad art.
Art isn't meant to be directly reasonable.
Asher Bailey
Does a dream mean anything to those beyond the one that dreamt it?
Tyler Bennett
I miss old Yea Forums so fucking much
Sebastian Williams
I love lynch but Inland Empire is just too much
Lost highway > Mullholand > Blue velvet > Dune> Eraserhead > fire walks with me > other movies> shit >>>>>>> Inland Empire
Twin peaks s1 was kino as fuck, never cared to watch S2, how is s3?
Nicholas Martinez
>SHOULD BE COMPREHENDED
question is: by who? everyone? not possible
Juan Rogers
It doesn't miss you, faggot.
Leo Long
It's fairly obvious as to what he meant by that.
No you don't. Old Yea Forums was lame as fuck. You just miss that time when you're young, dumb, and without any bills or responsibilities.
Kayden Cruz
>Yes, one can, but *should* the artist?
YES, THE ARTIST SHOULD BE ABLE TO RATIONALIZE HIS/HER AFFECTIVE PERCEPTIONS, AS MUCH AS THE PHILOSOPHER; MERE INTUITION, WITH NO REASON, RESULTS IN VAGUE IDEAS, AND, SEQUENTLY, IN DEFICIENT DEPICTION —THIS IS THE CASE WITH DAVID LYNCH.
AN EXCELLENT ARTIST NECESSARILY COMPREHENDS THE ESSENCE OF HIS/HER SUBJECT; COMPREHENSION ENTAILS UNDERSTANDING; UNDERSTANDING CAN ONLY BE ACCOMPLISHED VIA REASON.
Camden Cox
disagree strongly. artists don't need to be able to explain their works. making art and being a critic are two different skills. and although you seem to think the rational is a higher plane than the irrational and that all art needs to pass the test of being explainable on that level, i would say that in some cases "rationalizing" the art diminishes it and drags it down to a *lower* plane. the artist creates aesthetic experiences. that is, he creates beauty. that's his only job. demanding the artist also be a critic is arbitrary.
Hunter Martinez
>Twin peaks s1 was kino as fuck, never cared to watch S2, how is s3?
It kind of drags on through the middle, but you missed the best series finale of all time.
Jason Turner
>mfw a woman starts talking me about a lynch film
Caleb Myers
what an alpha
Landon Myers
you will never be a real artist
Gabriel Bailey
Lynch often makes up and changes things in his film on the fly, he doesn't even necessarily know what it means. Movies are moving paintings to him, its all about aesthetics and what looks cool. You can see this in the behind the scenes for Inland Empire and Twin Peaks The Return.
Aaron Ramirez
Makes sense.
Like there's this, lazyness, in movie making and viewing. And it's like those teachers textbooks almost. Why work through the problem yourself when you can skip to the back of the book. And just because of the state of film making or people in general, lots of directors comply to this. Here's what I meant, here's what this means. Don't guess, don't think, don't even bother with watching the movie, I and hundreds of critics and god only knows how many online movie review articles are going to tell you what you should think and how you should feel about this movie. And not to say the director shouldn't be interviewed and people shouldn't give their opinion but people, the audience, those that want to see a movie or are curious about a movie should be willing to search out there own experience with it. And maybe after they've watched it and thought about it then find out how there answer, compares to others.
Ayden Peterson
Liam Anderson
Carter Clark
There are parts of me tempted to agree with this, but maybe the times have passed for such an approach... I'm not sure.
It seems to me if an artist has their own house in order too well, it might be sterile whatever comes out.
I know Lynch also disagrees with the notion of the suffering artist, but I think thats because of what I mentioned in my first post.
There's the story of when he sought out a psychologist, this is before he started meditating, and he asked if this could interfere with his work, and the psychologist said it was very possible, and he said thank you and left.
Austin Ramirez
Matthew Ortiz
their
I always fuck up their and there. It's not like I don't know better.
Angel Brooks
Yeah, no artist should be forced to explain their work.
Jace Lee
wtf does that pic even mean?
Nolan Rivera
GET REAL
Brody Ramirez
People want to be spoonfed what a movies themes and meanings are, despite the movie already telling them to you
Isaac Scott
Yeah, he is.
Elijah Adams
SHUT YOUR IGNORANT MOUTH REI
WHEN YOU EXPLAIN SOMETHING YOU LIMIT IT, YOU KILL THE MAGIC
Blake Gray
>NOOOOOOOOOOOO THIS ISN'T THE NEWEST LYNCHIAN, GENRE-REDEFINING, TROPE-SUBVERTING, ATMOSPHERIC, DARK AND EERIE, SURREALISTIC, MACABRE, NIGHTMARISH, EMOTIONALLY DRAINING, GUT WRENCHING, AESTHETICALLY HEAVY CRAFT BY POST-HORROR AUTEUR WITH AN ARTHOUSE EDGE, DREAD-INDUCING, SUSPENSEFUL BUILD UP WITH STRONG CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT AND GRADUAL FEELING OF ESCALATION, BONE-CHILLING SLOW BURN WITH “SAY MORE WITH LESS” APPROACH AND SOUL-SHAKING, BLOOD-CURDLING, SKIN-CRAWLING AND NERVE-WRACKING EXERCISE IN PERSISTENTLY LOOMING DREAD WHERE TENSION AND ANXIETY PERMEATES EVERY FRAME AS MOVIE REACHES ITS NAIL-BITING, JAW-CLENCHING AND PARANOIA-INDUCING FINAL CLIMAX, FREE OF ANY CHEAP GORE, CARTOONISH CGI OR INFANTILE JUMPSCARES HORROR FILM AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!
Asher Foster
Kys retard
Jace King
I refer this one.
Jaxon Johnson
Stay mad.
Sebastian Perez
Camden Rivera
just to add a little extra thought i had is that anything excellent must take the subterranean route today, and express itself coyly and subtly, if the artist is directly aware of it, he wouldn't be promoted by the system but actually repressed. Assuming here that we are little bit on the same page as to what excellence means.
that may not be ideal to some, but it is the way it is.
Michael Davis
biggest pseud magnet in all film
Liam Lopez
go back to bed Adam
Aiden Hall
This guy is a cringy fag but this post is accurate
Josiah Morris
Ian Green
Maybe, but he's legit.
Brayden Butler
which one are you trying to be, film crit hulk or zodiak motherfucker? either way you'd be better off on twitter
Camden Young
Based Lynch btfoing the pathetic psychic yet again.
Landon Richardson
I can smell your newfaggotry through my monitor.
Isaac Davis
>DO YOU THINK IT MATTERS HOW MANY PEOPLE SOMEONE HAS SLEPT WITH?
>NO AND IT PARTICULARLY BOTHERS ME THAT WOMEN ARE HELD TO A DIFFERENT STANDARD ON THIS THAN MEN
>ALSO ITS SUCH A WEIRD THING TO CARE ABOUT. LIKE IMAGINE IF I STARTED EATING CHEERIOS FOR BREAKFAST, WOULD YOU BE LIKE, "I'M THE 48TH CEREAL YOUVE TRIED EATING?! I DONT FEEL SPECIAL!"
>WELL THEN SCREW YOU, CHEERIOS, I CANT GO INTO THE PAST AND UN-EAT ALL THOSE CEREALS, BUT THAT DOESN'T MEAN I DON'T GENUINELY ENJOY YOUR WHOLE-GRAIN CRUNCH.
John Wright
lol
Charles Torres
>Old Yea Forums was lame as fuck.
Sebastian Stewart
Bang, bang, bang. You’re like a fucking machine. Go dreamy for once, pal...
Thomas Morris
Is there an edit with "panties in my mouth"?
Jordan Myers
Daily reminder
Brody Sanders
david lunch lol
Connor Robinson
Jose Johnson
Kino
Oliver Moore
We have to somehow preserve David Lynch's brain after his death and keep it artificially alive, like inside a robot or something.
Cameron Thompson
the angriest brain in the world
Levi White
Eli Thomas
Elaborate on that
Oliver Harris
Yeah. Film makers should never talk about their film. Ruins interpretation.
John Perry
Chase Wilson
No.
Henry Green
bump
Tyler Thomas
This is true to a certain extent but you're so fucking cringey I don't even care. Tripfuck
Camden Foster
why is it bad that an idea is vague
why is it important that the audience, if one is found, is able to comprehend exactly what the artist is saying
why is the artist obligated to their audience
self expression through art is just that. you don't owe anyone anything. if you wanna have a conversation with your audience, start a podcast. go be a mathematician. run for congress. you're not gonna make compelling art.
Xavier Harris
feh. any man who parrots Green on this is lying through his teeth.
Jaxson Moore
>agrees to do an interview
>has his agent schedule the interview
>sits in a make-up chair and prepares himself for an interview
>starts the interview
>'uhh... I don't like interviews'
What a pretentious twat. You don't see Malick parading himself like an attention-starved bitchboi
Jack Miller
No.
Hack-fraud directors that didn't flesh out their narratives say that.
Jace Moore
Cooper Jackson
woah who is this qt
Charles Cooper
It’s like you people can’t read. He’s not saying that artists should explain their work, he actually said the contrary in his first post (it’s first fucking thing he said). He’s saying that artists should understand it, and be able to explain it, so that they can better represent what they intend in their work.
Aiden Ross
Why did I read this in his Cole voice?
Robert Parker
Because you’re a dummy who believes capital lettering equals yelling.
Jeremiah Perez
That's fucking crazy man.
Carter Carter
>will never be a woman
lolwut
Bentley Hall
I THINK I'M HIGH
Mason Hernandez
>What did he mean by this?
>lol figure it out yourself idiot
Absolutely based
Brody Williams
>a legend is incoherent and lacks comprehension
>in the same breath that cites the intentional fallacy
So not partly, wholly--just like how much of a faggot you are.
John Jackson
>intentionally make your movies and shows retarded and nonsensical
>wtf retards dont expect me to explain shit
some artists just have their heads up their own ass, Lynch is ok, but he did too much TM and his brains all fucked up from it
Jace Rivera
I mean i know what I think he means but what does he actually mean and what do you think it means i hope you think the same thing as me.
Alexander Richardson
Matthew Brooks
Well what else could it be? Its literally the written equivalent of yelling
Easton Parker
No, it isn’t. Yelling is represented in text by the admiration sign, regardless of capitalization.
Elijah Allen
Obviously. Also, he likes making films. Getting murdered over politics is not a priority for our beloved artist.