Character is universally hated by entire fandom

Because its not the entire fandom. I liked sam and im sure many others did too.

>Goth
>Main girl character

I'd have to wonder why you ask in the first place. Those alone is going to cause her to get the most fan art out of all the girls.

That question can be answered by knowing WHO hates her and WHO are making fanarts.

The goths I knew had clear cut personalities with a gender split. The guys were normally modestly dressed and cheerful, but the girls were very insecure and angry at the world.
My sister was a goth in middle school/high school, and I think it's because the girl oriented goth stuff is/was pretty fucking expensive. Hot Topic merchandise, hair dye, the constant hair maintanence, the cosmetics, and jewelry (is that the right word for a stainless finger claw thing?) is costly as singular items, but the whole kit was an initial investment of $250-300, plus the running expense of like $50-100 a week. The guys just wore black clothes from Kmart and, semi-expensive, military surplus gear.
So, it looked like (most of) the guys were having fun with it, but the girls were using the whole goth thing as a mask or a permission slip to be assholes. it was a weird, shitty scene that didn't match the media representation at all.

>the fanart in this thread
Bless the creator's soul

I wish more fan artists stayed loyal to the series art style instead of inserting their own shitty art style to it

I have lost at least 800 dollars in stealed jackets and hoodies.