Rate from best to worst

second famine when

Lampard > Scholes >>>>> Gerrard

Gerrard: 88.5
Scholes: 88.4
Lampard: 88.3

They were all very different types of players though with very different strong points.

Its:

Gerrard > Scholes > Lampard

Its very close though.

t.neutral fan

Lampard>Gerrard>Scholes

Surprised by people putting Lampard on top. Scholes was way more technically gifted while Gerrard was way more physically gifted.

This

I will never not be baffled by people overrating scholes. Lampard>scholes=gerrard and it's only like that because stevieg changed positions, thus getting bonus rate for versatility.

lampard > scholes > gerrard

also Premier League >>>> '''''''''champions''''''''' league

Lampard > Gerrard >>>>> Scoles

For someone played years in the top club Scholes record was really average. Especially the total assist, only 43, one point below Crouch.

>deflectpard better than either of the other two
embarrassing

Speaking as someone who doesn't give a shit about Man Utd, Liverpool or Chelsea: Scholes > Lampard > Gerrard.

Scholes was central to the way Man Utd played attacking, free flowing football during their dominant periods in the late 90s and 2008. He'd start every move, find space for himself, always find the right pass, and chip in with some goals too. Lampard wasn't as important to Chelsea but he was unselfish, underrated technically and scored about twenty goals a season six times from central midfield. Gerrard was the man for the big game, but apart from that, he didn't score as many as Lampard and was driven by selfishness and ego at the expense of his team, spraying passes and shots around non-stop so he'd be the one to take the glory and point to his captain's armband at the end.

The biggest example of Gerrard's ego and hold over Liverpool fans was his final season when they almost (and should have) won the league. They played him as defensive midfielder just to feed his ego and let him play a part, and although he did have good games, there were many more where having an old player trying to dash around to shield the defence was a detriment, and that was even before the slip against Chelsea.

Lampard was a penalty baby tho, unlike scoles. Scoles also played a little deeper so not as many goals and assists.

Scholes was the better short and long range passer and also dribbler, and you can't measure this with goals and assists.

As an overall player gerrard was superior to them both.

For Athleticism I give Gerrard an 8, Lampard a 7, Schols a 6.

For technical quality I give Gerrard an 8, Lampard 7, and schols 9.

Therefore:
-Gerrard = 8+8=16

-Lampard = 7+7 = 14

-Schols = 6+9 =15

So it goes:
1) Gerrard
2) Schools
3) Lampard

Thread/

Gerrard=Lampard>>>Scholes

What Lampard has going for him is that he sustained a very good level for longer than Gerrard, until Stevie G had that one swan song of a season in 2014, which ended tragically.

Gerrard had a better and more pronounced prime — he was arguably the best midfielder in the world from 2005 to 2009 and simply made Liverpool better, whereas Lampard's Chelsea was insanely stacked everywhere on the pitch.

As for Scholes, of course he was good, but nowhere near the peaks in individual performance as those two. Ferguson and the team around him elevated his game, and I don't think that if you put either Lamps or Gerrard in that Utd that they would have done a better job than Scholes did, but Scholes wouldn't have had the same impact they had if you put him in their teams.

Attached: images-18.jpg (550x557, 57K)

Assists were only recorded starting in like... 2006. They went back and covered a few seasons prior, but anything from the 90s is pretty unreliable. I just looked up another source stating Scholes had 55 assists.

laughing at the autistic aussie retard

Attached: 456.jpg (1920x1080, 81K)

For me, it's Lampard.

lampard not even close

Based. Not only did he /thread himself, he did it wrong.

Based

Lampard > Gerrard >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Scholes

Kill, kill, kill

reminder that Scholes has fewer Premier league assists than Peter Crouch, Danny Murphy, James Milner, Darren Anderton, Steed Malbranque, Kevin Davies, Jimmy Floyf Hasselbaink, Steve McManaman, Damien Duff, Stewart Downing, Nobby Solano, Andy Cole, Ashley Young and both of the far superior players you are comparing him to.

premierleague.com/stats/top/players/goal_assist?co=1&se=-1&co=1&cl=-1&iso=-1&po=-1?se=-1

Fucking overrated ginger fraud. Zoomers need to take there Scholes meme and fuck off

Look at Also just looking at stats alone is retarded if you watched all 3 of them play throughout their whole careers you'll know this ranking is correct

>Ability
Scholes
Lamard
Gerrard
>Trophies
Scholes
Lampard
Gerrard
>Attitude
Lampard
Gerrard
Scholes

Gerrard was obviously a good player but I don't see how anyone who isn't a Liverpool fan can put him up there with Lampard and scholes. He was also arguably the most overrated captains of all time

you cant really say lampard was better ability wise than gerrard, his higher stats can easily be because of the better team lampard had, they were really similar but gerrard was even better defensively

True I will admit Gerrard was the best defensively out of the 3

Imagine actually thinking Lampard and Gerrard were better than Scholes... I mean just imagine the level of sub human iq needed to produce that opinion.

Attached: 1563370833414.png (638x653, 758K)

youtube.com/watch?v=ln1H7JXIdL0
forlan talking about how underrated and good scholes was

>Assists were only recorded starting in like... 2006.

thats a complete lie. there's players on the list who stopped playing before that year

Attached: scholes vs lamps vs gerrard.jpg (1130x767, 105K)

Gerrard > Lampard > Scholes

1. Lampard
2. Gerrard
3. literally who?

Gerrard
Lampard
Scholes

The other way around in terms of success

Lampard = Gerrard > le get redcarded every other match red head

overall lampard>overally gerrard>>>>>>>>>overall scholes
peak gerrard>>>>peak lampard>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>peak scholes
gerrard fell off at the end of his career due to injuries and was nowhere near the player he was. lampard declined pretty slowly, contributed lots even at city when he was basically retired at chelsea. scholes is massively overrated now he retired, no work rate, poor defensively, couldn't play further forward like gerrard and lampard both did. gerrard was as good at the meme holywood passes as him

Lampard > Gerrard

> power gap

> scholes

Scholes is a literal who

Lampard > Slip = Scholes

Name of that kid? Albert Einstein

>couldn't play further forward
Are you taking the piss? Scholes spent the bulk of his first decade in football playing further forward.
Literally scored 20 goals in the early 2000's playing off RVN.

This is the post.

Scholes > Lampard > Gerard

Gerard was overrated and a mental midget

Scholes doesn't deserve to be rated next to them

clutch man>le occassional blooter man>le pass sideways man

Lampard=Gerrard>>>>>>>>>>>>>Scholes

A fucking leaf commenting on football

>drags shit tier team to CL final win, MOTM
>scores 30 yard blooter in FA cup final added time to force a draw in regulation time, and win on penalties
'mental midget'

Lampard was goals gifted

>’Would you say he is better than us Frankie?’ asked an emotional Steven Gerard when asked about Paul Scholes

>’Yes’. Said Lampard at once with a tear on his eye

stevie >> frank >> anybody else >> ginger fraud

I equally despise Manure, Lavorplel and that Russian Aluminum club

Lampard > Gerard >>> Scholes

Milan choked

Gerrard hit a lucky shot

>People unironically saying anyone other than Scholes

Dont make me pull out the quotes.

Scholes>Lampard>Gerrard

Not hating on Stevie, they all were great

Zoom zoom back to 9fag or r*ddit.

Scholes is lightyears above them. The only people who even doubt that are scousers or a zoomers like this retard:

all 3 are overrated english players that could only shine with foreign players alongside them. what did they accomplish for their country? fuck all is what

You're just jelly because France hasn't produced a native world class talent in decades

Attached: BIG Anglo.jpg (557x666, 45K)

I would sat scholes is the best, tecnically was the best of the three by far.
You can't really compare scholes to lampard and gerrard, they where different types of mid fielders.
Scholes is much more of a xavi and ineasta type of player, a technical player you can distribute the ball to his forwards and beat their marker of the dribble.

Gerrard and lampard where box to box mid fielders, kinda like veira or yaya, all around players who are a problem when the go forward.

Scholes > Vieira > Gerrard > Keane > Lampard
They watched every match from the 90s to make assists. There is even a story of how Opta employee borrowed the only vhs from Swindon with all goals because there was no other option.

Griezmann was a top 3 Ballon d'Or candidate twice in the last 4 years. When was the last time a British player archived that?

Hint: it was 2005, almost 15 years ago

Grismannen is from Uruguay.

Why did any combo of them never work well for the NT?

Lampard = Gerrard >>> Scholes

Scholes was just that shit

but when he retired lampard/gerrard without scholes on the wing did nothing either

sportbible.com/football/reactions-exposing-the-myth-twitter-users-paul-scholes-rant-goes-viral-20170704

the red pill

Attached: 1567441945714.jpg (1080x1350, 247K)

Gerrard>Lampard>>>>>Scholes

Scholes lmao

based

>scholes
Overrated meme player

why do people keep trying to sneak scholes into this debate? who next, jermaine jenas?

Lee Bowyer

He didn't drag them to the CL final win, Didi Hamman did.

Slips that cost them the league
Scholes: 0
Lamps: 0
Slippy G: 1
Scholes = Lamps > Gerrard

gibe englando pls

Scholes > Lampard > Gerrard

So i guess he just constantly hit lucky shots right? But all of lamps and scholes longshots were pure skill?

1. Lampard
2. Scholes
3. Gerrard

Attached: CjdQ3ckWsAEWCiv.jpg (533x401, 52K)

Honestly surprised by people putting Scholes on top. Scholes was a system baby who only thrived when Man Utd as a team did. Lampard and Gerrard so often put their teams on their back, helping them perform well beyond their level.

Don't me wrong, Scholes had talent. But he didn't have the mentality, intelligence or leadership that the other two had.

Scholes was the system, utds entire attack was built around him

Scholes was the attacking pivot that the most successful and dominant english football team ever was built around

Gerrard was the best big game player. Lampard was the most consistent player. Scholes was the best at passing sideways, I guess.

Scholes was probably the best but Lampard was very based. Definitely my favorite

>'Attacking pivot'
>Team rained in crosses on the likes of Cole and van Nistelrooy through their peak years
If anything the likes of Giggs and Becks were their 'attacking pivots'

>Gerrard was the best big game player

youtube.com/watch?v=Tg8ypOknFlY

Gerrard > lampard >>>>>>>>>>> scholars
Anything else is pure delusion

youtube.com/watch?v=rPvSCoAJIDo

>mistakes = not big game player
every player makes mistakes

Attached: ce8.png (621x702, 56K)

>english players
all trash

youtube.com/watch?v=AdyVzhJto_E

what big game player makes this many mistakes in big games?

>they played him as DM to feed his ego
They did it out of necessity because Hendo was suspended after the City game

Gerrard was the best defensively out of the three especially in his early years. He actually started off as a pure DM.

He just has the most goofy highlights because he actually HAD to play the most defense(out of necessity) out of the three.

He also carried his team the hardest and don't see how Lampard or Scholes could replicate the impact he had for Liverpool

Scholes>>Gerrard=Lamps
Every great SAF team was built around Scholes and then he came back and won another league just to prove how much they needed him

Scholes is a defensive midfielder.
Gerrard made an average team around him look top class
Lampard scored more goals than many strikers

fuck you, comparing them is absolutely retarded, they are all amazing

We can all agree Giggs was shit tho

Marry Scholes
Fuck Lampard
Kill Gerrard

Scholes>Gerrard>Lampard

>Majority of the flags saying Scholes was a meme/shit are of the UK variety
You can almost smell the scouse stench

Attached: Snookerboi.webm (1138x774, 676K)

Blooter
L
O
O
T
E
R

>only scouse scum watched scholes

no m8, you are probably underage. he was never world class at any point unlike the other 2

Best: Lampard
Worst: Scholes and Gerrard

Same

Gerrard is the best mid the prem has ever had

this. him viera and toure were the only true complete midfielders in the premier league era

>they played him as a dm just to feed his ego

Attached: 664.jpg (558x614, 18K)

>Griezmann
Sounds german. Do francs even exist?

>England NT
>working well
The nation is cursed with a weak mind since they lost their empire. Can’t even get the balls to leave the faggy EU

Possibly the most brainlet tier thing I have ever read

Now Beckham, thats an overrated player.

Based yank

>Scholes is a defensive midfielder

Attached: 1489503759264.jpg (545x543, 34K)

When you piss away possession with 10 retarded long shots a game occasionally one will go in.

> Gerrard
>intelligence

He's the player with the highest peaks and the best balance of technical and physical ability, but he was an idiot. A sort of rampaging chaos zone. Allowed his side to in theory beat anyone but in practice limited their points output across 38 games. Scholes, who was always trapped inside his physical limitations, never able to give an 11/10 performance, played deep far better than Gerrard because he didn't just forget his job halfway through a game. Lampard, who on paper is just Gerrard minor, ended up bettering him in league performance through consistency and playing the percentages.

tl:dr all these English players are about equal, and all of them were better than Ballack

childhood: gerrard > lampard > scholes

adolescence: scholes > gerrard > lampard

adulthood: lampard > scholes > gerrard

don't @ me

Attached: 1555451565405.jpg (404x462, 57K)

scholes talent
lamps hardwork and consistency
gerrard leadership

overall:
lampard > scholes > gerrard

Attached: 1566141591828.jpg (960x639, 122K)