Was it worth it, Indy? He could have retired a Colt, but noooooo, muh Luck

>set new record for TD passes in a season
>beat to hell, ready to go
Ok

>luck
>sets personal record for most TD passes in a season
>retires a season after
Peyton didn't last long in Denver anyway

Luck took 41 sacks his rookie year. That o-line in Indy was shit. Peyton would have died

Introducing the newest Denver Bronco for the 2022 season, Andrew Luck!

Attached: andrew luck.jpg (640x360, 85K)

Peyton did more in four years in Denver than Luck could ever dream of doing in Indy

No. And guess who was leading the charge to get Peyton out of town? A literal (((jew))) Bob Kravitz of the Indianapolis star.

I know you’re having a rough day, Clotsbro.

Attached: DB9CE590-35C5-4918-9EDD-E3032D51FF0F.jpg (770x595, 178K)

i'm a delusional broncos fan and diehard Peyton dickrider, but that is so wrong it hurts

Gets me to thinking, if they trade next year's first and second, maybe they could get Eli,

Attached: eli-manning-face-meme[1].jpg (2000x1434, 322K)

I would end this simulation before I saw Eli in any other jersey

Attached: 1506092867843.jpg (590x443, 37K)

Eli leads the colts to an owl as he beats Brady in the afc championship game

Attached: 9F9E210F-2A80-4C02-A5B1-67D1064EB2F7.jpg (643x569, 83K)

So Tom Brady has 6 Superbowl wins.
Peyton Manning has 2 Superbowl wins.
But some people consider Peyton Manning to be the GOAT QB?

WTF?

That kike is also responsible for starting deflategate. He really needs to be run out of Indy.

I don’t think anyone thinks this anymore. Tom Brady is solidly the GOAT. There is no comparison.

Honestly look at his performance in 2015, he was abysmal. He retired because he knew he didn't have it anymore.

Colts still have rights to his contract. Luck can never come out of retirement if he doesn't want to play for them.

Tom Brady isn't really among the top 10 QBs of all time. ESPN just crowns whoever the most recognizable QB is at the time that is still playing the GOAT QB.

Neither QB is the GOAT QB but Peyton can at least make the argument for top 5.

It also should be noted that Indy is a clownshow of an NFL team operated much like a second division football club or AAA baseball team.

Compared to the professionalism and history of teams like the Eagles, Packers, Bears, etc a team like the Indianapolis Colts are just not on the same level. Plus they are a team run by an actual lunatic so their owner is always working against their best interests.

Imagine Luck having the receivers that Manning got to throw to throughout his career. The guy would already have three owls by now

Manning would have been done after one year in Indy with the punishment Luck was taking

people are delusional and like regular season babby stats

This would be incredibly poetic.

If I had one game to play and I had to choose between Peyton Manning on his best day or Tom Brady on his best day, I would choose Peyton Manning every time.

How does this apply to XFL?

Attached: 86FBD39E-9BB7-400F-9064-B92BB2AFEB17.jpg (750x711, 359K)

Give up football, you fucking faggots

Seems like you got hit too much like Luck did and got CTE

Problem is that football is not just a one game thing and even if it is, TB12's best day surpass Manning's

When did Tom Brady throw seven touchdowns in a game?

SMART
HARD WORKER
DOES MORE WITH LESS TALENT

Attached: cowherd.jpg (1000x600, 110K)

brady got benched by his HC after throwing 6 TDs

peyton was always a stat-padder

youtube.com/watch?v=5jLh0dLgszs

He threw 466 yds and 505 yds in the biggest game of the year unlike Manning which is important

Has OJ commented yet?

They have a cool stadium tho.

Man, his arm was shot his last year. Yeah he could diagnose the defense but he just couldnt make the necessary throws downfield anymore

Attached: 0BB7B743-9AC8-4BA8-AD30-0C343F5D57DD.png (500x500, 362K)

>Peyton had some top tier years left in there too

No. Once he wasn't allowed to take his wife's HGH anymore he was finished. Did you not see his noodle arm in his last season?

Attached: (You) really think that.jpg (900x900, 50K)

>Plus they are a team run by an actual lunatic so their owner is always working against their best interests.
Fuck that whole family forever and ever.

>They have a cool stadium tho.
That stadium looks like a 19th century, coal-fired outhouse.

Attached: robert-irsay.jpg (666x777, 149K)

Delusional. Manning was mediocre in his final year. He sucked in the Super Bowl too.

There was a big difference between 2013 Manning and 2015 Manning. A lot can happen to an aging QB in two years.

That was his 4th year in Denver. 3 of them he was great.

Iorny because the Irsay's are jewish

Manning was only ever better than Brady in the regular season. Brady performs when it counts.
Good luck in the fucking Super Bowl.
Name 10 better quarterbacks than Brady.

The point being is that he fell off the cliff his final year and his corpse was carried to the Super Bowl by the defense. Peyton was done

Imagine my shock.

> Super Bowl 48
> Great
> Super Bowl 50
> Can't even mention

NFL players don't age well.

as long as elway is in our office, we’ll never get top-talent drafted qbs. i can only pray flacco and the defense can take us to an above .500 season

Attached: 4F3406D9-0E18-42C5-95E4-47B3D81D937F.jpg (400x400, 31K)

owl 48 was a curbstomping by the hawks and owl 50 was von Miller and the defense wrecking newtons shit

Ravens were stupid. Flacco is better than their RB who sometimes throws. Think the Chargers would beat them in the playoffs if they started Flacco?

Not even a Patsfag but only literal retards or people that despise them to the point of irrationality thought Peyton was better after 2014

Their real last name is Israel. No joke. Look it up. Jims dad changed it.

Have you looked into Peyton Manning's neck injuries?

It was dangerous for him to even play.

Who is the GOAT qb then, dumbshit?

>Ravens were stupid. Flacco is better than their RB who sometimes throws.

You are a racist.

>Luck lasted 3 years longer than Manning did.
>Luck didn't even play one of those 3 years
>Manning moved to another team and won an MVP, made 2 SBs, won one.
>Meanwhile Luck made one AFCCG and lost by 38 points
>Team still put up a banner to celebrate

JUST

It means he's the quarterback for the LA Furfags

>What is a team sport?
Peyton is the greatest individual player to ever play QB. He has the best stats and the best records, his only real competition is Brees. Brady is an all time top 10 for sure, but the reason eh won 6 super bowls isn't because of his individual talent, it's because he has the best coach in sports history and his team has always been elite tier at nearly every position with a consistent top 10 defense. The Colts usual have an average team.

If Manning was on the Patriots he'd have 8-10 super bowls easily

Is this true or am I being rused?

>after winning another Super Bowl
Did he or did he not set the new record for TD passes in a season, go to two more Super Bowls and win one AFTER he got chased out of ingrate Indy?

The SEETHE in this thread is unbelievable. Indy made maybe the biggest fuckup in League history since the Walker trade and the best you faggots can come up with is “ah Peyton didn’t last long in Denver anyway”. Your franchise is objectively garbage and are headed for 1-15 or worse. Go drink

he doesn't have the all-time stats. he has the best regular season stats and regular season records, most of which will get broken by brees and brady anyway

brady owns all the important all-time stats and records

we feel you.
>t. Cardinals fan

if Peyton had been with the Pats he would have crushed Brady's numbers. You have to also consider the environment they were in.

>an organisation that has required 6 (six) game-winning drives in their 6 (six) superbowl wins would have won even more rings from a perennial playoff choke artist

Attached: 1515956147773.png (900x729, 129K)

This is true. Any sane person would take prime Manning over prime Brady any day. The difference in individual talent is clear.

He played 31 games post Peyton retirement.

Attached: 1566417875973.jpg (258x245, 12K)

Manning
Marino
Montana
Rogers
Young
Moon
Unitas
McNabb
Namath
Bledsoe

I can't believe that we live in a world where the pats/Falcons superbowl happened and people STILL try to argue that TB12 isn't the goat

I thought he did retire a colt?

cold

he's right you know!

Attached: 1546808224380.jpg (1952x2048, 430K)

>Young
>Moon
>McNabb
>Namath
>Bledsoe

kidding right?

Steve Young is underrated as fuck.

>in the snow
holy based

You forget how shitty that Indy team was.
Peyton had a destroyed body. And the Indy team destroyed a healthy 23 year old Luck. If Peyton stuck with the Colts he might have become handicapped on that field.

Went from 10-6 with Peyton, to 2-14, then 11-5 with rookie Luck. Peyton just found a team that was good enough to win games with Tebow as its QB.

Ok..
But that team literally ended a young generational QB. This is truth. They got wins but look at how they got wins. Having Luck get his shit pushed in every week.
Peyton would have been wheelchaired

That was a discussion in like 2013 lol
Tom just shut the whole thing down