Is this a solid list?

Is this a solid list?

Attached: EAC_9ugXYAAou3k.jpg (750x1334, 82K)

>Romo
>Palmer
>Romo
>Smith
>Romo
>Simms
>Romo

why is Rodgers so low in that list?

>Troy Aikman ahead of Steve Young

Fuck outta here, pleb.

Manning over Montana LOL

Manning had the best retirement story of any North American athlete ever.
>wins Super Bowl with the Colts, cementing himself as a legend
>gets statue built of himself
>watches his brother BTFO the patriots the very next season
>gets traded to the Broncos
>bitchslaps Tom Brady THREE TIMES
>final game ever is Super Bowl fucking 50, where he upsets the 15-1 panthers
No NFL player will ever retire the way Manning did. Even if Brady retired after winning another owl it will be some shit like Super Bowl 57 that no one will remember. Manning retired after cementing himself as a 2 team legend and winning the god damn 50.

Attached: F84B325F-C338-4644-B7C7-DC58A75CCCA6.jpg (828x412, 166K)

A Super Bowl where his team won despite him

>7. JOE NAMATH

yikes

list has no consistency to it. it just gives emphasis to modern stat inflation but makes a really half ass attempt to put a few old people in there

really stupid list but being retarded creates controversy and sells so whatever. if it was better you'd never knew the list existed

>alex smith was a better quarterback than donovan mcnabb

Attached: 1467839868700.jpg (625x415, 38K)

the way this list is ordered makes me think one smoothbrain just did this in 10 mins because it goes on runs of current players, then old, etc. that indicates little actual thought being put into it

Top 3 QBs ever no order? Payton Manning Brett Favre Phillip Rivers

phoners are garbage
fuck you homo

its clickbait

It’s a shopped image, retards. Reverse image search turns up nothing.

Because he's not goat material

>romo even on this list
HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
No wait...
>Romo on this list
HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Fuck no

>Tony Romo
>Carson Palmer

LMFAO

>brady retires after 7th superbowl
>this is somehow not as good as hobbling through superbowl 50 for a second ring

Where's /ourguy/ Michael Vick?

>/ourguy/
uh...Yea Forums is a perro board