Getting back in the saddle after multiple years away lads.
Is there a consensus best version or should I just go with latest?
Henry Howard
fm12
Oliver Parker
14
Zachary Gray
They all kind of suck, but it's never really nice to go back to a previous versions since while they all have their kinks, they have some other shit ironed out. Although the new scouting and training modules are absolutely heinous.
Carson Reed
I think most people in /trb/ consider fm12, fm14, and fm19 the best as of now
Ethan Anderson
I quite liked 13, putting aside all the "he certainly didn't mean that" nonsense I guess I'm a deviant though
Nicholas Collins
13 is a lot better than 14
Daniel Scott
Maybe that's just some of the more contrarian posters saying they prefer 14 then, I owned 12 and didn't buy a newer one until 17
Jason Mitchell
>fullback fails to adapt game toward getting forwards at every possibility
Tell me why I shouldn't just replace all my homegrown players for pacey Ngubus and have a token 2 1/2 star local lad BBM
Even better: >Sell key player for loadsamoney >Buy a high quality replacement >Waiting for work permit >Decision date is always right after a key fixture or just before so you can't appeal work permits in time
Fuck the Home Office or whoever deals with that shit, faggots won't let be buy Serbian children
Luke Myers
I'm so tempted to make myself Brazil manager so all my work permit-less players get caps, then a work permit, then I quit.
Nolan Jackson
Getting permits isn't too hard for me if the players do have decent potential, problem is you can't get the homegrown status because of the loans.
Not that it's not annoying as fuck when you've got 10 WP signs on your first team squad
Evan Myers
I just want to add more women to my staff but Thai russian bitch won't join my Sports Science team
>4-1 up against team 2 leagues below us >fatal error of complimenting the team at half time >they equalise, go ballistic at end of game >no goal aet >go to penalties, get this scoreline
30 year old striker just got back from a 6 month injury with 2 points missing from his pace and acceleration. I put him in as a Mezzala because he's not going to get that pace back. Just got his 399th and 400th goal for the club. I'm so proud.
What pisses me off it the amount of worldies other teams score. Winning 1-0 with 60% possession and 15 shots on target, they get a corner from their first shot of the game, the corner is cleared and then a DM who as scored 1 goal in his career sticks it top bins from 30 yards while being charged down
Nicholas Howard
Same situation I'm having but I'm playing 4-4-2 with a LM/RM. All my goals seem to come from my left mid deciding to become prime John Barnes to dribble past the entire team and stick one in the corner
Has anyone got a solution for high shots but low amounts of goals every game? AI just plays goofball until they score 20 yarders whilst my team gets 3-4 one v ones every game which the miss every fucking time
William Richardson
>tfw backup keeper get injurefor 6-8 months feelsgoodman, now he cant complain over 0 playtime
Michael Hughes
Yes the solution is stop playing because that's been an issue for me since I started playing and I'm going to imagine that's the story for everyone.
Luke Rivera
if you work out the answer to that you'll never lose again
Jose Stewart
Not these rules. scroll down for the Brexit rules.
Ryan Collins
It does seem like total shit that the AI csn pull of worldies or your centre backs go walkabout despite having tight marking set and concede regularly, yet my winger with 18 crossing can't beat the first man with the ball and my strikers can't find space despite their off the ball being high
Jayden Harris
I thought >wingers were better than inside forwards or wide midfielders in a 442. Fix my tiktak lads, I've been thinking of putting full-backs on support even though their crossing is shite just so they don't get pinned back constantly by wide players who never have to track back.
oh right, here they are. though there are a couple of threads saying this might be a bug? i understand the brexit rules in this situation, i just dont know how to go about applying for a work permit for this player on loan (this is his 3rd season on loan with us)
There's nothing blatantly wrong with it, you just need to organize a shit load of friendlies to tweak it while watching. I prefer BBM to CM(S) to add a bit more activity to the midfield, as well as FB(S).
Jackson Bell
>main penalty taker injured >back up penalty taker is rated 15 at penalty taking >0/3 in PKs this season
>not restarting every time your penalty taker misses even if you're winning 5-0 You're small time. I've done it dozens of times, even if I go on to lose, I'm not having my penalty taker with 16+, 16+ Finishing and 16+ composure miss against a guy with 11 One on Ones, 14 Reflexes and 12 Handling.
>wild cross from a corner about to curve out of bounds >my idiot defender decides to head it into the center of the box instead of just letting it go out for a goal kick
Jonathan Hernandez
>your Defender heads corner clear >Falls to your own unmarked midfielder on edge of area >Midfielder heads the ball away to the opposition's centre back instead of controlling it
>be me >bored of my shitty unemployed game as it's essentially impossible to do well starting with shit signings >bored of my undefeated run in Argentina >bored of my pre-update Oxford game because I managed to sign several world class regens on Day 1 >start a game to make Deportivo de La Coruña Great Again >Sign Berbatov on a free >He does this B A S A D O.
>yfw no matter what tactics you use, no matter what players you sign, you will continually concede goals after the 80th minute
Tyler Hall
I always like a BWM in any formation
Christian Mitchell
>mfw designed a tictac that only scores after the 70th minute or before the 20th
Jayden Brown
make that 0/4
Jordan Peterson
What's his finishing and composure? It's often better to have a guy with 14 finishing, 14 composure and 14 penalty taking than it is to have a guy with 13 finishing, 13 composure and 15 penalty taking. Remember, Finishing is the skill to put the ball in a part of the net that the GK cannot reach, remember, Composure is the ability to not fluff the shot and kick it at the GK or wide. Penalty taking just takes these values and works on them into a quality value.
annnnnd game came up with a save error again, so gotta redo it anyway.
Jacob Wilson
Looks like a comfortable win to me.
Jack Jenkins
I hear you, he is the 2nd most unintelligent player I have ever had, behind Junior Toillett in fm 13
Aiden Sanchez
Already had a training facility upgrade underway after a request, now the board commissioned one themselves scheduled to complete two months later.
Does it just reset and do the same upgrade, or does it to two tiers in one go now?
Adrian White
What is your favourite role in football manager? For me, it's the Inside Forward
Sebastian Stewart
The Scott Parker role
Ryder Diaz
AMC Advanced Playmaker/Trequartista, but mainly Poacher for FW's.
John Anderson
I currently play 14. It has a nice mix - the modern big money clubs are all already in place and the ai is pretty good. Also it has all the roles you need to make pretty much any modern tactic work.
Bentley Sanders
What would happen in a Champions League group if every team drew 0-0 in every single match?
Brody Perez
>team is good last year >no significant changes >team is somehow terrible this year
How the fuck does this happen, /trb/?
Grayson Ramirez
>sign Bilial or w/e his name is on a free >he's been consistently mediocre for U19 side Reeeee.
I much prefer attacking mids to adv playmakers desu
David Martin
>wanting your midfielder stealing goals from your 18 year old striker you wanna sell Pleb.
Carson Moore
Lads, I need some help with my Deportivo de La Coruña game. I'm constantly racking up 15+ shots on target but never more than half are on target. I'm winning but I dunno what to do. I've literally had some games where I've kept the enemy far away from my goal, not even a single shot on target and bar before it crashed during saving, was best I had managed in coming close to no shots in total. Berbatov is scoring enough to save me, but I'm playing a meme formation which I don't think is working any more where I have a SS behind Berbatov who is playing as DLS. I could play another striker but nobody good enough to really do it.
Adam Nguyen
Sorry, 15+ shots in total but never more than 50% on target.
Alexander Moore
Gonna drop my SS after he's done 5 games now and has a terrible average rating. He can play as a FW but have a feeling he won't be any better there. I think I might have to since Berbatov can pass well. I'll try him as AF, if he doesn't do better I'll put another guy in as AM.
Levi Rogers
Just give the ball to BerbaGod and let him figure out.
Jason Reyes
He keeps fucking up though. He scores but still shoots a lot. 67% shot accuracy.
Isaac Turner
I play fm19 and strikers are broken so I need my attacking mid to score
Grayson White
>tfw I just found out about how good wide-midfielders are compared to >wingers
Robert Howard
>first game with him as a AF >BerbaGod does an amazing 20 yard pass and he scores B A S E D.
Isaac Rodriguez
>scores another Well I did slag him off before the match say he better do better. Probably my fault for playing him there.
Carter Stewart
>my DM who cant go more than 45' without being 'jaded and in need of a rest'
So he smashed the record for goals in the CL with 23 goals, and all he needs is an average performance to cement the best average rating in the history of the cup.
He burps up a 5.9. He misses 3 CCCs in extra time, including a missed penalty. He then misses the first penalty in the shootout. Somehow we win. I've never seen a player shit the bed this hard in a final. I've gotta fine him when we just won the CL.
"The Tempo Skin FM18 April 2018". I use it because you can autoplay matches, and let the Assman take over.
John Hernandez
For some reason, a player who misses a penalty not only takes a hit to his rating, but tends to go go through the rest of the game like a ghost. It's only seconded by a player making a mistake leading to a goal: those still hurt, but it's VERY relatively easier to recover from.
Thomas Morris
Last chance for my golden age of Turkish players to win the world cup. They beat Japan 5-1, Ghana 5-0, and Ukraine 2-0, so they're looking pretty good.
In other news, Italy and France fail to get out of the group. And in the worst group of all time, Portugal, Chile, and Saudi Arabia finish level on 2 points (all 2 draws and a loss to Holland). Chile fail to get out of the group with the best player on the planet.
CAM ON AMERICA I was thinking they were being carried by their Bayern winger who won the Ballon D'or 2 years previous, but he retired from the national team the previous year. It's like Sweden without Zlatan.
>Brexit will impose a limit on foreign players at clubs
My starting 11 has 3 British players, how fucked am I?
Samuel Williams
I swear by shouting "show some passion" and "demand more" at my players whenever I can and that alone got me promoted from the National League North to the Premier League in eight years
Nathan Hall
Why teach a player a ppm for a simple instruction that almost every fullback role comes with by default?
Luke Gutierrez
wingers on support fullbacks on support
Andrew Gray
RMD-A
Blake King
>Everyone gets an English passport Who cares?
Christopher Baker
>reinstall fm after months of absence >all custom views somehow still there >mfw the /game/ knew i'll be back one day and saved me the effort
absolutely gutted lads, my Azerbaijan save crash dumps in Jan. 8, 2032. No way around it. It was going so well, it was only a matter of time before we won the CL...
>tfw the board doesn't want to increase the number of coaches available despite me asking twenty times time to resign, i guess
William Clark
CL money is insane for any league outside the top 10, my club survives on that money and player sales every season
Luis Stewart
F
Joshua Cruz
Sorry to hear that mate.
Jace Wright
DM me on steam if you need any comfort in this trying time
James Hall
>try to into 2019 after having only played 2016 last >2D blobs mode now 3D rendered >text blurs on windowed mode >infinite bloat
Why do they have to fuck shit up? Fuck Miles and SI
Lincoln Cooper
Does anyone have a suggestion for a Croatian team to try that isn't Dinamo, Hajduk or Rijeka? I'm thinking of trying out Sesvete since it's in Zagreb and might be good for youth players but I'm looking for any team with good youth systems that isn't a top 6 side
Luke Price
I had a save with NK Novigrad that was a lot of fun dunno if they're still playable with the vanilla DB
Nicholas James
NK Zagreb used to be a medium-sized club and they even won it all once. Now they're in the 3rd or 4th tier. It could be fun to bring them back.
>talent I don't really think the things you do in the game convert over to the real world all that much, although i have heard stories of pro teams using the game for tactics analysis to some success.
Brandon Bailey
>Two key players ask to leave to go play in Germany >Reject their request >Team meeting soon after because the whole team thinks they should go >Decide to sell them anyway to I can invest in younger players to fill their roles >Sell both >Team meeting to discuss the lack of depth in the club
Why are players so fucking dumb in this game. Life as a team in a feeder league is a nightmare
>literally the only semi-pro team in a league full of pro teams >ask board for pro status >they say no What do I have to do lads, and what am I even missing out on.
Camden Ward
why are strikers so broken
Ryder Rodriguez
generally speaking i do think that in football there is probably a reason most teams use a striker
Matthew Cruz
you need money and rep
Nathaniel Morales
Or to resign. Then lo and behold: His (ex-)club will become pro in a moment's notice.
Joseph Myers
you playing fm19? Just use a dlf(s) or cf(s) and have your inside forwards and attacking mids score the gols
Zachary Anderson
God bless AI managed chairmen. Last time I left a top club they did a firesale on my players and signed midtable english talent for £50m a pop.
Robert Rogers
My Make Deportivo de La Coruña Great Again game is going great. Berbatov is banging them in.
Grayson Lopez
Forgot to say, I got Park The Tank Achievement as well. That's how good it's been. I know Deportivo de La Coruña were a relegated team but this is lel.
Adam Evans
Is it just my computer getting old or did load times increase dramatically since FM17?
Adam Evans
What's a good way to get a replay up, saw the lelest OG. Guy from outside his own box passes back to the GK, GK steps forward and the ball slowly trickles over the line.
Ayden Long
use shadowplay/relive then convert using webm for retards
Jeremiah Hernandez
>guy is playing like shit >sub him off >highlight ends up with him scoring >follow sub anyway >sub scores two goals despite being orange level competence To play or not to play now. Guess I'll try.
Eli Adams
when I have a sub lined up it always seems to be the player about to get subbed that scores
Nathaniel Reed
Both.
Christian Smith
I just want to get 30 fucking consecutive games without conceding so I can do this achievement. But it's requiring me to save scum. I hate it. I don't care if I win, just I don't concede. All I can think of doing is loading up some dogshit team and editing defenders and GK to be world class.
Xavier Diaz
That goes against of the point of being an achievement.
Andrew Thompson
Except when you do it for 17 games and concede due to some ME bullshit you rage. Or I do anyway. It was so much easier in earlier editions.
Grayson Wilson
I dunno, defending always was kinda fucked in FM.
Brandon Rivera
The problem is situations like this.
1. Box scramble 2. Balls richochet around 3. Ball hits your defender 4. It's starts slowly dribbling towards the net 5. GK is paralysed and shepards it in because the game doesn't allow back-passes and the AI doesn't run to kick it 6. Goal
or
1. Defender with acres of space heads a long ball towards a pacey striker when he could have let it bounce or chested it and they score
or
1. Set piece shit fucks up and they score a freekick with 11 freekick stat
I hate it. I hate it. Every time I've conceded this run (which is only twice so far) it's been from some fuck up with the ME. Not a case of a well placed pass or anything. It does my nut. If the ME was 'fair' I would be OK.
He'll be GOAT by the time he's 18 then if you're putting him in Day 1. I usually put 16 year olds for a year in the youth team, abuse the 'training' there, then take them to first team which boosts it even further. He could be a bit faster but he'll be fucking great by 18. I can see 16+ Finishing, Composure, Off the Ball, Work Rate, Decisions and Anticipation and possibly Technique. Dribbling and First Touch are a bit iffy but they might be 16. Technique would also be good. Need 16/16 Speed, sadly. He probably won't get that. He might get 16-17/15.
Jackson Green
14 or even 16 isn't that big of a leap, just some parts of the interface moved sideways
Jose Lopez
I only recently changed from FM15 to 18 because I accidentally Shift+deleted my save game folder
Luke Campbell
>Accidentally two keys far from each other with no backup What were you even trying to do in the first place.
Gabriel Reed
Shift deleting one of the other folders in the user folder because I'm an idiot.
I still think back to those players I deleted. I'm so sorry lads
Cameron Ortiz
I'm not figuring out how to make this formation work anytime soon.
My favorite role? Now that would be the double mezzala. Also known as the base of 'Tungstissimo' or 'Tungstenball' for English people.
I support Ten Hag though as he is from my area and I have supported him aince his GAE days.
Samuel Nelson
I'm unfamiliar with the scouting in FM19. How do I tell my scouts to only scout QT regens?
Tyler Turner
post it
Liam Bailey
My guess is 'Look for young talent' in the usually suspect areas (that you can scout). Or just download a program and find regens, saves time. doesn't mean they'll be good or work. if you mean cute generated faces; not possible iirc.
Ian Jenkins
Oh yeah just found that. Should I target Brazil/Argentina? I'm playing with the Brexit rules so I don't know if I'll be able to snap up as many nubiles from there, otherwise I guess I can focus on the UK
I can't say I've played with many English teams exactly for that. But I would recommend South America and UK. Eastern Europe is also a good idea.
Jason Watson
Yes? Why not. It's a fucking game, saves time. I don't care if people want to cheat or not. He might be OK with using a program and I am OK with it. But if he doesn't, I gave him the proper way to do it.
>Rotor is about Khimki What? Khimki has better GD. Russian rules different?
Jaxon Scott
>Games Won >Results Between Teams >Goal Difference >Goals Scored >Away Goals Scored
In that order.
Hunter Morris
Huh. Neato. Never actually done Russia.
Ian Evans
Neither had I, but it's my journeyman save and I'm able to take a wealthy relegated team straight back up and playing in the Russian top flight will do wonders for my reputation. Currently most of my players are unhappy about not leaving following the relegation, but they're good enough that they can underperform and still walk the league.
Dominic Lewis
>signed Belal for my team >didn't actually check on him until now >those physical stats Oh dear. Well, hopefully he'll win fouls when somebody sneezes at him.
are there any hidden chemistry bonuses for racial hegemony? always wondered that
Alexander Hill
The thread is still alive!
I really want my toothpaste flag back..
Jason Hughes
Already had a training facility upgrade underway after a request, now the board commissioned one themselves scheduled to complete two months later.
Does it just reset and do the same upgrade, or does it to two tiers in one go now?
Grayson Garcia
Wide midfielders > wingers
Noah Williams
Thoughts on wide AP's chief?
Adam Campbell
Weak mind >getting bullied by football manager simulating autists
Landon Collins
Fucking Juventus lowballing my players and making them unhappy that I reject the offers.
Adrian Wood
Pure shite
Ian Wood
Brehs I don't want to leave my current Liverpool side. I'm so proud of them because they literally never give up and fight for every inch but it's getting out of hand. My players and tactic are just too strong brehs. Pep guardiola AND Mourinho are both managing in the prem against me and man city have a great squad and incredible defense with Rafa B... but still we just keep winning.
I thought this would be a rebuilding season because I've finally moved on from relying on Club legend and captain Joao Moutinho as my holding midfielder and sold a few of my young starlets when PSG and Tycoon-stoke came in with absurd bids. I was going to play the kids and come back to earth in terms of results. Not so far.
Poor Man City even had an invincible season and we still squeaked them on goal difference. The disappointment of this loss crashed them back to earth a bit the next season but my side repeated the same record twice more on the bounce and won two trebles. I've never built a side so relentless.
I fucking hate how often shots hit the post in this game. I sweat SI have made shooting shit to compensate for how shit they code defenders
Tyler Long
My sixth month demo for fm2019 just finished last night. Might end up buying the full version now. Though for scouting is it really you have to pay for packages and can't like just go scout individual countries or micro scout? Or maybe is that just a thing because for the demo I was coaching a 3. Bundesliga Team?
Samuel Myers
you can do both. getting packages increases your knowledge of players (I think) and increases the number of those players scouts will find on their own. bear in mind that fully scouting a player you have zero knowledge of, especially if they're not a starter or play in an unloaded league, can take months
Sebastian Rodriguez
Thanks that is good to know. Though was I just not finding the option to do that? Because I could only find the packages and not the individual ones. Is it not there because I am in the 3rd division or maybe it is somewhere else because I am still trying to get used to the new layout
Wyatt Torres
individual scouting should be available from a player's page, go to reports-->get scout report scouting a country is on the scouting-->assignments (f7)-->create new assignment page you're right that your club's stature probably means you can't scout outside of germany or maybe central europe. nevertheless, those options should still be there, just limited to players based in your region.
Lucas Mitchell
Thanks for your help user. I guess I am trying to still get used to the new layout on top of me not having played FM in a fews years and I am trying to get back into it again
Michael Lewis
yeah, they've shuffled things around compared to previous versions. most of the old options are still there (except sliders...) but sometimes you need to dig for them.
Brayden Smith
>up 1-0 over Man City >match engine decides its had enough of this bullshit >city scores, one of my players gets a red, city scores again, all in the space of 5 minutes
Zachary Nelson
>DoF gets you exactly the type of player you needed on a cheap loan from a country your club has limited scouting knowledge of tyb batigol
>Play guy as SS behind Berbatov >He doesn't score >Put him as AF(not natural) and his first game he scores 2 >Great >He then goes 10 hours without scoring >About to switch him out >Accidentally play with him in >Arg.jpg >He scores two He's not great though. He should be doing better. What do I do now? Keep playing him? Berbatov has slowed down too. He's on 12 in 13 with 3 assists, he was originally like 10 in 8.
Jason Ortiz
nice to know i can always depend on the match engine to score on my at '45 and '90 because of >muh concentration