Swans Are Dead

Which is better, Yea Forums? This or Soundtracks for the Blind?

Attached: dead_grande.jpg (600x600, 31K)

Both god tier it’s impossible to pick

I like Swans more because I think it's slightly more engaging.
Also Feel Happiness & Blood Promise on the Black Disc? Literally the end of Post-Rock and music

Both are 10/10 records. For me it's probably SftB, but the Swans Are Dead version of Blood Promise is probably my favourite Swans track of all time.

Swans Are Dead without a doubt.The live versions of the songs are far more lively than the studio material.

This, plus the Black disc is literally the epitome of music

Young rich Swan I’m a seer

this

feel happiness is a good tier track tho

I like SAD but the tracklisting isn't good. The order seems a bit random and doesn't flow that well, and the transitions are often really abrupt and jarring.

blood promise and the sound are better on SAD, feel happiness deserves a studio recording

I find Swans Are Dead to be night and day in terms of enjoyment compared to SFTB, Soundtracks feels overpraised, underproduced, and inconsistent and there are moments which just make me want to turn it off out of lack of enjoyment more than any other Swans album
>implying SFTB has a more consistent tracklist
Also what the fuck is the deal with Blood Promise and people praising it? It's alright and imo Blood Promise on TGA is far better and more haunting.

Attached: 1558934418379.jpg (706x480, 32K)

I was agreeing with you till you mentioned Blood Promise.
Shit is transcendent in SAD bruh

Yes.

Have you listened to the original? I get what SAD's version is like and why it's good but I just don't get why it's better.
Does Gira screaming at the end really make it incredible?

it's a 100% song made into a 1000% song

Swans are dead are way better

So my friend and I are going through swans rn I've heard soundtracks twice so far and I'm on my 1st listen of SAD and it's really hard to choose since they are both perfect but I would choose SAD

Swans are Dead, but TGA is better than both.

This is wrong

How, exactly?
>muh experimentation
>muh spoken word
Yeah TGA's sounding kinda based in comparison

SFTB is a 10, whereas this is a very high 9 - but there's a fantastic argument for either.

why do you say SAD is a 9?

it's called the crescendo bro
shit is life altering

truth realer never been spat

TGA's version is dope and atmospheric but SAD's literally can break a man bruv