Charles Manson VS John Lennon

Lets compare these 2 songs

youtu.be/8_gZ2a3l2ck

youtu.be/vIYRbbHMesg

>voice
John Cant sing properly it's weak unprotected he has bad technique

Manson not Pavarotti but quite good nice strong tone, attention to detail, colour e.t.c

>lyrics
John has cringy pop lyrics that are all cliche and we know he doesn't mean it in depth

Manson had short but profound and poetic words

>rhythm
John has baby rhythm its laughably simple, theres nothing to really say about it

Manson had quite skillfull syncopation and tasty rhythms

>harmony
John has again basic harmony that any kid could write

Manson has very nice harmony inspired hy more complex genres some interesting chords

>melody
John's melody is shit, its repetitive baby stuff

Manson has an actual proper melody in comparison

>artistic
John's piece is boring flat abd worse of all unartistic, its cliche guitar song that sounds like anyone could write. It's in pleb taste

Manson's song only 1/4 of the length had much more poetic and musical substance and more importantly is more artistic in its structure


This isn't to mean Manson is the greatest songwriter of all time just to show how overrated the Beatles are(and most pop music)

Attached: Manson1968.jpg (768x960, 80K)

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=hobkFHJTut4
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

Bump high iq

>This isn't to mean Manson is the greatest songwriter of all time
i was with you until you said that. don't disrespect charlie

Well hes not Mozart but for solo pop music his stuff was good

you're right, he's not mozart. he's better. FUCK MOZART. MOZART MORE LIKE MO-FART

Manson would have respected Mozart

yes but he would've known he was better..

Thread is rife with zoomer trolling.

john lemon:
>beat wife
>made boring music
chadlie manson
>never actually killed anyone
>made lie: the love and terror cult

also, john's song literally sounds like me when I practice switching random chords on guitar

lol

No he would have known he had talent but wasnt a great
He said in an interview he just sings not seriously it's just something small

Damn this John Lennon song is amazing. Thanks for showing me, OP

that's my favorite john lennon song

Way to choose some shitty song from his solo career.

youtube.com/watch?v=hobkFHJTut4

Far better lyrics, chord progression, melody and a fairly unconventional rhythm when compared to Manson's. The only thing you may have is the vocals but John still had a far more engaging character and tone to his voice.

The Manson recordings are nice for what they are but people overstate his talent just due to how unexpected it is. You can tell he was just cheaply imitating the mega popular sunny folk-pop shit that LA was obsessed with at the time.

Pleb taste

That's even worse kek

Indeed they're just standard guitar chords

>pleb taste
Nah. It's pretty good

Well just coming from classical music and finer arts it sounds atrocious

Manson's though a humble pop song is more elegant and genius, a better crafter

>Well just coming from classical music and finer arts it sounds atrocious
Me too, friend, and I really enjoy his song.

John Lennon beat his wife, that much is true

Charles Manson was responsible for peoples deaths but he never killed anyone himself. He was a cult leader and got people to kill a bunch of rich white people and make people think black people were doing it and start a race war.

Nice cherry picking, faggot.

Pick another Lennon song if you want
That he performs with just acoustic guitar

Agreed

Is that stuff really true? I heard his followers just got into drug related spat and the FBI put it on him

GARBAGE DUMP OH GARBAGE DUMP WHY ARE YOU A GARBAGE DUMP

Yes, that's why he always gets jumbled with Jeffrey Dahmer, Ted Bundy, John Wayne Gacy etc. Because he was responsible for the murder of innocent people even though he didn't do them himself.

If you really wanted to get your point across, you shouldn't have posted a video of John Lennon playing a depression era blues song. You should've posted him playing one of his own originals.

Of course Manson as a musician/songwriter is highly underrated. I mean look at how many people covered his songs, and the one band that literally STOLE one of his songs, changed the lyrics, added a bridge, and gave him NO credit, nor royalties for his troubles.

No wonder he was so angry that he went on a killing spree.

>Fun fact, did you know that when he went to Sharon Tate's house, he was actually looking for Terry Melcher, who was the previous owner? (He was The Beach Boys producer at the time)

he also wrote a beach boys song but they didn't credit him and he got pissed.

just freak out minion

that is one of his own songs. it's like his spin on a blues song. he wrote all the lyrics and everything

bumping for charlie

Manson's my boy. Cults are based.