*elevates the rock opera to perfection*

yes they are
their inclusion is the perfect pleb filter

It's not bad because it's popular. It's overall mediocre, and also happens to be extremely overrated.

cool Yea Forums meme fellow Yea Forums(el)er!
they're nice moments but the actual new musical ideas in them are so short (30s or so)

Except for all the musically meaningless tracks that only exist to further a narrative.

>muh narrative!!!
your /pol/ is showing
not every track has to introduce some grand new musical concept you adhd addled child
>the wall
>mediocre
>overrated
contrarian teen

>your /pol/ is showing
Except I'm talking about a narrative as a literary devise

Try again

crazy how a rock opera would have a branching narrative

it's also crazy that the unneeded elements of the narrative were left in, to the fault of the musical muscle of the album, and you still call it "perfect"

everything on the album has a reason to be there. in fact, during production a lot of content was cut that was indeed deemed unneeded.

>not every track has to introduce some grand new musical concept you adhd addled child
then don't complain when it brings an album down pleb

except it doesn't, kiddo

Attached: 1556063778365.jpg (128x127, 6K)

teenagers are the main demographic who listen to and praise this entry-level dadrock

Yea Forums is wall central desu
tear it down

>everything on the album has a reason to be there.
Then it's poorly written if the author cannot properly communicate his ideas elsewhere (read: imperfect)
>during production a lot of content was cut that was indeed deemed unneeded.
Since not enough was cut to give the album a musical significance, then it can not be perfect

this is the most asinine argument against an album i have ever seen. you're upset that it's an album and not a book or something? you're a fucking idiot.

Not him but that's completely bogus. My friend drives a school bus and once put on Pink Floyd. All the high school kids (who were predominantly white) said what the fuck is this shit. Teenagers today don't know who the fuck Pink Floyd is. They're still glorified by the people who grew up with them - actual boomers - and pretty much the next few generations who grew up on classic rock radio. That's everybody BUT teenagers. I know that doesn't help your narrative so I'm sure you'll just dismiss the idea being a location thing.

>dat lack of reading comprehension

>dat idiotic youtube meme
>dat awful fucking writing skill
grow up

Lifehouse > The Wall

>>dat idiotic youtube meme
What are you referencing here?
>>dat awful fucking writing skill
You mean on The Wall? I agree.

Also
>I love this album so that means it's perfect!
Who needs to grow up?

Lifehouse doesn't even exist/wasn't finished

>dat
seriously go back to whatever website you migrated here from. The Wall is a masterpiece, mo amount of your retarded nitpicking will change that.

It's still would have been better than the wall

>The Wall is a masterpiece
Except I just explained how it is not. The only retort you have are ad hominems and strawmen

you didnt explain shit. you made the asinine claim that it has filler even though this is obviously untrue. then you claimed its badly written because you didn't understand it.

>you didnt explain shit
Of course I did.
>you made the asinine claim that it has filler even though this is obviously untrue.
Have you researched it? This is a common complaint against the album. If you think I made this up, you are in denial
>then you claimed its badly written because you didn't understand it.
No, I understand it. It's simply poorly constructed if the narrative rests on insignificant filler tracks.

It's OK that you love it. but that doesn't make it perfect/a masterpiece. Once you reach your 20s, you might understand

>musical significance
What the fuck does this even mean? Quit making shit up, no one cares if you don't like it.

>this is a common complaint against the album
source: your ass
>insignificant filler tracks
name one.

>the wall
>perfection
choose one

favorite track is the third part of another brick in the wall

>What the fuck does this even mean?
Oh, do you know music theory?

If not, I'm not sure why you think you can accurately judge these the quality of this album.
>source: your ass
Look it up.
>name one
Happiest Days, One of My Turns, Don't Leave Me Now, Is There Anybody Out There, Bring The Boys back Home, Show Must Go on, Stop, etc.

nah, its not my job to back up YOUR argument. thats your job.
>Happiest Days, One of My Turns, Don't Leave Me Now, Is There Anybody Out There, Bring The Boys back Home, Show Must Go on, Stop, etc.
oh, so this was all just bait. ok, im not gonna reply anymore.

>nah, its not my job to back up YOUR argument. thats your job.
Fair enough. See
archive.rebeccablacktech.com/mu/search/text/wall filler/
>oh, so this was all just bait.
How so?

>in the flesh pt. 2
yep, im thinkin roger's based.

Attached: 1549552063530.png (249x249, 58K)

The most technically impressive release in their discography.

>the happiest days of our lives
>vera
Is this a joke

Based.

I don't know buddy, everybody at my school knew who pink floyd was. Granted it was probably just a better school system than yours

So they’re not filler and you’d be ok with them if they were part of other tracks?

The Who did it better

*is actually the perfect rock opera*

Attached: 5732131.jpg (600x600, 258K)