is it a 10/10?
Is it a 10/10?
Cooper Martin
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtu.be
twitter.com
Nathan Williams
yes!
Justin Allen
Yes
Asher Richardson
yes!
Brayden Reyes
i'm so happy you agree :)
Adrian Watson
Unironically yes, I can see why it’s off putting to some but I think it’s incredible. I feel like if it was a Roger solo album it’d be thought of in a better light.
Aiden Cooper
that’s a yes from me, chief
Adam Torres
how could one thread be so based?
Aiden Allen
One of the most brilliant insights into the effects of war on family and the next generation. The people who make the "Daddy ded" memes don't understand the deep harrowing pain of losing a person in your family, let alone their father, to such a mindless cause.
Yes, it is a perfect album.
Owen Cox
i'm very pleased with these answers, thank you
Luke Cook
is it about syd? i havent listened to it but if its about syd then i will because that is the pink floyd i know and love haha
Joshua Rodriguez
im pretty sure it's more songs about the war/maggy/his dad, etc. from memory.
check this out.
youtube.com
Elijah Long
Yes
Matthew Barnes
Angel Reyes
No, but it's very good, probably 2nd or 3rd best PF album
Adam Brooks
>destroying fascism
>mindless cause
uhh, /pol/ is that way, incel
Landon Bennett
Waters' father died in WW1. Literally one of the most worthless wars in history.
Joseph Hall
Animals
Logan Jenkins
WWII fren
Camden Wood
>destroying fascism with more fascism
Logan Watson
Animals is overrated
Dylan Morris
It's their most overlooked one from the big 4
Aaron Wilson
The addition of When the Tigers Broke Free certainly improved it, but everything from Desert to the title track is weak
Liam Jackson
It's certainly very nice in its own way. But I think a lot of the guitar solos feel underdeveloped and flat.
I can see that, but the end of Southampton Dock was pretty good.imo.
William Walker
FUCK ALL THAT WE GOTTA GET ON WITH THESE
Leo Price
FUCK. ALL. THAT.
FUCK. ALL. THAT.
Alexander Lopez
Aye
Luke Phillips
> WAAAAH MY DAD DIED
> war bad
it's shit, in their bottom 3 for me. Even a momentary lapse of reason had more going on
Sebastian Clark
Dominic Jones
unironically a good album
don't listen to the contrarians
Parker Torres
It's shit
Carter Nguyen
Evan Rivera
ßumpin a worthwhile thread
Josiah Bell
daddy ded
Jordan Wright
>You put on your brave face and slip over the road for a jar
>fixing your grin as you casually lean on the bar
>laughing too loud at the rest of the world with the boys in the crowd
>you can hide hide hide behind petrified eyes
Evan Ward
Pretty good
Cooper Wright
It's a solid, a solid 5/10.
Blake Edwards
Uhhhh yeaaaaaah it’s about Sy~~~d
Tyler Fisher
Chase Hughes
4/10 at best Division Bell is better
Colton Long