Paul McCartney

Where does he rank

As a songwriter:
As a singer:
As a bassist:

?

Attached: paul-mccartney-9390850-1-402.jpg (1200x1200, 166K)

all low, just like the rest of his posee

not as good at wife beating as his bandmate john

Only musician I listen to

He is a cheater romance wise and an idiot. I wanna fuh yoouuuuu and not my fiancee jane asherrr!

Wrote some of the best songs of the 60s, fantastic voice, fantastic bassist - sure he declined massively as he got older but still an undeniable genius

>As a songwriter:
14th
>As a singer:
4038th
>As a bassist:
50386th

People who don't cheat are cucks. Imagine being loved by thousands of groupies and not taking advantage of it.

his latter bass work was surprisingly solid. nothing game changing or all that different from the norm, but he kept his stuff pretty interesting and varied

His only good song is Jerry temporary

Another thinly veiled /pol/ thread with no mods around to do their jobs.

Who are the top 13?

Faul is slightly better

>as a songwriter
Not very high. He wasnt as good as John, although he was better than George.
>as a singer
Very high. He's an incredibly talented singer, although John's voice pleases me more.
>as a bassist
Not very high. He's a solid bass player, but definitely not a virtuoso.

He wrote For No One so he's automatically the greatest songwriter of all time

Paul McCartney had no talent, the guy they brought in to replace him after he died in a car accident is one of the most talented song writers of all time

based

Attached: 1566334009057.jpg (480x468, 46K)

All of the above he is one of the most original musicians as modern music is shit.

I come here to escape /pol/ and I don't see it

brian wilsion
Michael Melchiondo
Aaron Freeman
all higher than paul

Here, There and Everywhere and For No One are in the top 10 of Beatles songs, arguably top 5. Not a bassist or singer so I can’t comment on that.

Lennon was a better songwriter.

incredibly based good shit

>Paul McCartney boasts he can't read music! How can you call yourself a musician then? John Lennon was the best musician in The Beatles by a country mile.

Attached: Ginger.jpg (1500x1184, 300K)

High on all three counts

Dubs checked.

Paul's gift is in keeping himself relevant. Not many musicians, in any genre, can have a 60-year career.

As a husbando:

Attached: 1560382854379.gif (500x321, 495K)

BASED

As a songwriter:top 50
As a singer:top 1000
As a bassist:top 50?