I'll start
*deletes Chocolate Girl*
ITT: You turn good albums into 10/10s by deleting or adding songs
Zachary Smith
Joshua Perez
WTF that's the second best song
Julian Reed
delet providence
Now its perfect
Brody Morris
*shortens my old man by about a minute*
Already a 10/10 album but now it’s a 11
Nathaniel Parker
I know you’re just posting an obviously wrong and contrarian opinion to solicit copious (You)s in an attempt to replicate the feeling of having friends but still, eat my ass.
Lincoln Brown
*ITT: You turn shit albums into 10/10s by adding a 1
David Thompson
providence is a true pleb filter
Brandon Smith
King Crimson fags like to pride themselves on their intelligence and *liking the only true Progressive prog band* yet shit themselves when an 8 minute improvisation pops up
pic related, delete Cactus
Angel James
*deletes Volcano*
yes I know i’m a pleb but the reversing drum pattern is annoying.
Zachary Wright
that's an easy one:
take out "It ain't easy" and put in "all the young dudes".
u know you wanna
Kayden Rogers
Add Title Track as opener.
Cut 75% of the stupid ambient and earrape sounds.
11/10
Lucas Scott
*deletes Turd On The Run*
Gabriel Perry
WTF that's the best song
John Kelly
Michael Flores
Prove It
Hunter Young
Its objectively bad it kills the mood of the songs just like electioneering did in ok computer, its just off
Plus is fucking bad and it goes to nowhere
Jack Richardson
Delete Rock 'n' Roll with Me. then Diamond Dogs is pretty much 8 or 9 at worst
this.
Dominic Wilson
Best post on Yea Forums right now tbqh.
Camden Ramirez
If that's what you don't like about SFTB instead of the many other problems, you don't deserve your Yea Forums card
Charles Brooks
what would you say are the other problems? for the record, I hated listening to this album but couldn't process why
Carter Wood
Brody Phillips
>Removes Candy Store Rock
Bentley Phillips
Worst post I've read this entire month
Chocolate Girl is probably their single greatest song
Aaron Cox
>replaces Doctor Faggot and George's sandnigger bullshit with Rain and Paperback Writer
Its at least an 8/10 now.
Zachary Lewis
Really bad post
Colton Hill
*deletes Hate Paste*
Connor Ramirez
How is it a 10 if you want to shorten it? If it was perfect, you wouldn't want to.
Andrew Scott
*deletes I Need Somebody*
Yep. The perfect rock album
No. It's Stop Beaking Down
Fuck off. It's a perfect album
But this isn't even a 7/10 album
>being this pleb
I'd replace Good Day Sunshine for Paperback Writer and delete Yellow Submarine
Nathaniel Wood
do i get to keep my Yea Forums card if i think sftb is perfect in every way
Connor Ramirez
no.
Jayden Harris
Volcano is such a great "...wtf" moment on the record tho
Michael Wilson
nigga you dumb
Thomas Allen
>Delete Kid A , add Pyramid Song
Zachary Wilson
>Remove When Im 64, Good Morning, Lovely Rita, add I am The Walrus, Penny Lane, and Strawberry Fields
Aaron Carter
>Penny Lane over Lovely Rita
yeah fuck off
Parker Williams
>Deletes a guitar and a heart
Perfect
Camden Carter
lol
Dominic Reed
Nope. Although I'll accept trading it for The Talking Drum.
Definitely nope. I'd cut both Red Velvet tracks and maybe Animus and How They Suffer though.
Yeah, pretty much.
I can get behind this. I think Like Spinning Plates would fit nicely on Kid A too somewhere.
I like Good Morning, but I can't deny that track listing would be top tier.
Brandon Young
>deletes I Love a Magician
Ah, perfect
Owen Morales
no
Jose Hall
>Animus and How They Suffer
literally some of the best tracks pleb
David Richardson
Fuck it guys, I’m going to rearrange an entire album to make it perfect~
SIDE A
1. Don’t Go Near the Water
2. Long Promised Road
3. A Day In the Life Of A Tree
4. Disney Girls (1957)
5. (Wouldn’t It Be Nice To) Live Again
SIDE B
6. Surf’s Up
7. Feel Flows
8. Lookin’ At Tomorrow (A Welfare Song)
9. 4th Of July
10. ‘Til I Die
Added Dennis’ songs from the era and deleted the two worst tracks “Take Care of Your Feet” (just meh) and “Student Demonstration Time” (fuck you Mike) and the rest is just rearranged
Zachary Gonzalez
What the fuck? Why? That drumming in the last minute is orgasmic.
Why not delete the unnecessary and ear-shattering Everybody Whistling?
Easton Anderson
based
Jose Long
please post a selfie, I want to know how do someone who hates Chocolate Girl looks like
Connor Bell
Tyler Taylor
I got an easy one
*deletes house of cards*
*adds go slowly*
Angel Allen
Sam???
Jaxon Smith
*Deletes everything but Spirits they’re gone and Untitled track
Asher Butler
Imagine wanting a Yea Forumscard. I genuinely enjoy material that is "accepted" by this board, but I couldn't imagine building my taste around it after having discovered that it isn't going to click.
*switches the studio version of Out of It with the '17 single*
Brody Gomez
Delete 21st schizo man.
Jordan Bell
Joshua Nelson
It's not bait, I skip the song every album listen.
Christian Scott
>remove side b
>remove side c
Eli Perry
pic related but also shorten Just Abandoned Myself to the Japanese version
Jackson Young
>sandnigger bullshit
get back to your containment board
>>>
Benjamin Wilson
>remove side you
Mason Mitchell
Wow, THIS is fucking based. High quality post.
Dylan Nguyen
Chocolate Girl is the best song on the album, get your ears and brain checked you piece of shit.
Luke Bennett
>Disliking Sloop John B
Noah Scott
Thanks, I didn't even had to type it.
Angel Wright
i do agree with adding dennis songs back in but i would switch around the sequencing of the tracks, i think the original sequencing is based and works perfectly (especially with the last three being day in the life of a tree, til i die, surf's up)
surf's up is the perfect closer
Brandon Rogers
Jaxon Rogers
Push Th' Little Daisies
Eli Watson
based
that song is weak
Alexander Walker
no idea why its so popular
Leo Wilson
jesus christ
Thomas King
That song is good but overrated. Mourning glory should have been the chart topper
Daniel Gomez
Revolver is so short you can just add in Rain and Paperback Writer to make a 40 minute album
Josiah Collins
Wow, being this retarded
Ethan Jenkins
Disgusting language, get away from here
Nicholas Murphy
Remove "A Dream that cannot be" album is god tier without that song.
Josiah Morris
Adding Pyramid Song, sure. But deleting Kid A? Instead of Optimistic or even Morning Bell?
Asher Edwards
Real answer is deleting second half of Moonchild. Now, it's 10.5/10 album
Mason Cruz
>any weezer album
>delete everything
Ayden Martinez
Pinkerton is unironically better than your favorite album.
Tyler Wright
favorite album off all time
I can see that change, but I would prefer Last flowers
Levi Wilson
Pinkerton is boring musically. Take away the lyrics and you have a forgettable altrock album. Even with the lyrics it is trash. Not a single half decent riff on that shit heap
Benjamin Peterson
you forgot to also delete Shine A Light and Soul Survivor
Nathan Clark
listen to the alternative version of candidate, its very good and a completely different song
Benjamin Cox
get rid of rebel rebel while you're at it
it should've been a single, it feels so simple and out of place after the beautiful suite
Justin Carter
close but swap side b with peking o.
they're not even bad songs but they're not really on par
Cameron Bell
the least offensive track to the normies.
Isaac Morgan
got em
Ayden Flores
>Identifying retardation
Kayden Perez
>deletes heresy
Perfection.
Jordan Sanchez
Wtf? You are invited is by far the worst song. It makes bowling for soup sound like free jazz
Bentley Roberts
fuck you for not liking Morning Bell
Luis Johnson
>add Sappy
>add Moist Vagina
>add I Hate Myself & Want To Die
Kevin Gonzalez
t. christcuck
Angel Cooper
oh no no no no
Michael Green
*deletes Operation Lifesaver*
Adrian Rodriguez
fuck you
Kayden Collins
>deletes entire album
Jackson Ramirez
based
Logan Thompson
Good picks, some of my favorite Nirvana b-sides.
Michael Moore
*deletes the last 6 minutes of European Son*
Justin Long
For me it's delete Faust Arp and add Go Slowly
Joshua Davis
how is moist vagina good?
how is kurt screaming ‘marijuana’ 50 yikes good?
Nicholas Jackson
>telling people to go back to /pol/ because they said nigger
get back to your containment website >>>/reddit/
Daniel Turner
awful take lmao
Chase Bailey
moist vagina is great
it isn't a super serious song or anything, user, but kurt's voice sounds unique and interesting on it and it's kinda funny
i like that song quite a bit
Eli Thomas
>deletes rising sun
>deletes exchange but keeps the instrumental version
Justin Walker
european son and black angel's death song both probably should've been on white light/white heat instead of nico
and then put here she comes now from white light/white heat on to nico
Ryder Myers
>removes riot van
Hudson Smith
needs more changes than that
Andrew Howard
providence is better than starless pleb
Ryder Mitchell
First off wtf how could anyone not like faust arp I love faust arp and I've never got the dislike
Same with house of cards
I cant pick a song to kick off the album. Just add laat flowers in there and 4 minute warning. Videotape at the beginnig.
Kayden Johnson
>Removes D'yer Mak'er
>Replaces it with Black Country Woman
perfect
no
Eli Long
>deletes long distance drunk
Michael Wood
Based
Easton Fisher
That’s the best song bitch
Connor Scott
Fuck off
That’s the best song next to what do you want me to say
Grayson Sanchez
What the fuck is wrong with you?
Connor Rogers
you are the only person who has ever had this opinion
Jose Gray
>deletes long season
>replaces it with Party Rock Anthem by LMFAO
ahh, now it's perfect
Hudson Powell
peking o is one of the best can tracks
Jason Powell
Keep Holocaust, Nightime and Kangaroo Roo
Add Lovely Day Demo, Femme Fatale Demo, Downs Demo, Take Care Demo and the Alt version of For You
Add the Fry “rough mix” of Blue Moon and Big Black Car Demo #3, Take 2
Perfection
Sebastian Baker
*removes A Love Like Sunset Pt. I & II*
Blake Wood
what in the everliving fuck are you talking about?
Carson Gomez
Based
Isaiah Sanders
embarrassing
Aaron Hall
*deletes All I Need*
Brody Reed
are you being sarcastic
Eli Campbell
>removes The Secret Life of Arabia
much better
Bentley Morgan
>deletes whole album
Xavier Peterson
>Removes Within You Without You
Ahhhhh, perfection.
Adrian Smith
Keep all the tracks and add Cat Food after ITTTW
Tyler Stewart
when you sleep and i only said
Juan Ortiz
Terrible take. Just move it to the A side
Caleb Thompson
that's what I was thinking but I don't know where it would fit on the first side. but as it is it sounds so out of place after the ambient pieces
Brody Hernandez
Juan Diaz
bad take
remove flying high
Grayson Foster
>remove Honey Pie
>replace Revolution 1 with single version
we’re not touching Revolution 9
Anthony Lewis
>deletes miss fortune
perfect
Jason Bennett
>removes everything after X.Y.U.
And now we've also got a great closer.
Kevin Campbell
*deletes frontier psychiatrist*
Carter Diaz
Fuck off
Noah Myers
Blue album>>>>>>>>scaruffi top 10>>>>>>>>>>your top 10 albums
Luke Baker
Delete Frankie Sinatra. What a terrible choice for a first single, should've been Sunshine.
Benjamin Morgan
>add Beans
now it's a 10/10
Isaiah Carter
new track list for Nevermind (anything on the original album but now removed is now a B-side)
>Smells Like Teen Spirit
>In Bloom
>Come As You Are
>Breed
>Sliver
>Lithium
>Polly
>Dive
>Drain You
>Lounge Act
>Stay Away
>Aneurysm (Incesticide version)
>Something in the Way
>Endless, Nameless
also maybe add been a son somewhere in there
Aiden Hall
perhaps been a son instead of stay away???
Mason Lopez
Take out around the last 20 minutes, they always feel a bit like filler, everything up to Lateralus is amazing tho
Levi King
Remove the final track: See it on your side.
Otherwise, this album is a masterpiece
Benjamin Reed
They only have 4 albums you can fuck off with removing any of it got it bud?
Christopher Jackson
>Remove Pennyroyal Tea entirely, or replace it with a hypothetical studio version of the demo version which is infinitely better.
>Possibly remove Francis Farmer
>Add Sappy, add Verse Chorus Verse
Masterpiece
Hunter Allen
I do what I want bud
Caleb Russell
Volcano is literally the second or third best song on the album and I was always disappointed that they never did an EP or album based on it.
Ethan Adams
nigga there are a lot more problems than just that.
For one thing delete Loving Cup and use the superior alternate take instead.
William Nelson
*guy picciotto does all lead vocals*
10/10
fair
Nathan Lewis
You should also have the album just end with with the powerful1984 fading out instead of the lame disco psych outro that is Chant of the Ever Circling Skeletal Family.
replace Motion Picture Soundtrack with Pyramid Song and add Packt Like Sardines on the album, that way Amnesiac doesn't even need to exist
Daniel Nelson
Bad take, though I would instead add I'm Only Sleeping, Dr. Robert, And Your Bird Can Sing, (for Americans) and delete yellow submarine.
Sebastian Garcia
fun fact: Fripp himself deleted Moonchild off the album on a CD rerelease because it was filler. And guess what the album is way better off without it.
Elijah Wilson
>deletes decatur psalm
>deletes extraterrestrial
>deletes the second elevators
woah it's the best hip hop album of all time
Luis Garcia
forgot to add pic related
Brody Peterson
Decent takes
100% great take
>Possibly remove Francis Farmer
You're gonna have to possibly remove my foot from your ass, numbnuts.
>pic related
Replace the album version of Tainted Love with the full version that directly goes into Where Did Our Love Go?
Replace Youth with Memorabilia
Nolan Carter
the only changes that In Utero needs are replacing the songs with the original Albini versions.
Kayden Rivera
Literally cut your tongue out you geek that is the best song on the album and of the band's career.
John Scott
truth
Easton Moore
i like this user's changes better:
Josiah Bell
the albini version of heart-shaped box is shit
Isaiah Gonzalez
Yeah let's just ruin the progression of the album and make it have 2 openers...
Jayden Barnes
Literally fuck you, the Albini version is infinitely superior for the vocals alone. Producers forcing the multi tracked fake chorus vocals ruined so many In Utero songs that would have been beautiful otherwise. Cobain's voice deserved better than being overridden with shoddy effects.
Alexander Rivera
Not even. Tired of Sex has a super hooky riff that kicks ass and Getchoo has my favorite distortion effects ever.
Brayden Rivera
i like most of the scott litt mixes better personally. the only one that sounds like shit is the pennyroyal single version
Nolan Ward
>Producers forcing the multi tracked fake chorus vocals ruined so many In Utero songs that would have been beautiful otherwise
seriously. Compare THIS
youtube.com
to THIS
youtube.com
Listen to how much better his voice sounds when they don't compress it to shit and add that reverb.
Gabriel Thomas
So, like only two songs?
>Producers forcing the multi tracked fake chorus vocals ruined so many In Utero songs
Confirmed for retard
No btw
Evan Nelson
the albini mix is okay, but i like the scott litt mix more, i think.
Jeremiah Garcia
but verse chorus verse is from the nevermind sessions, not the in utero sessions.
Jacob Sanders
The Albini mix sounds a bit lacking what the song deserves. The production doesn't fit the song.
It was recorded during both sessions.
Jonathan Hill
it's also unfinished!
Noah Sanchez
This is amazing.
Removing Aumgn would go a long way
Eli Hall
do you mean sappy?
i thought you meant verse chorus verse as in this:
youtube.com
Angel Baker
Oh I see. Sappy was later retitled as Verse Chorus Verse, hence the confusion.
Verse Chorus Verse AND Sappy was recorded during the Nevermind sessions. Additionally, the officially released version of Sappy (now titled Verse Chorus Verse) was a new version recorded during the In Utero Sessions.
There were also two more early versions of Sappy, recorded with jack Endino and later during the Sheep Sessions
Joshua Garcia
>deleting tool's best song
lmao
Justin Hall
new track list for Bleach (anything on the original album but now removed is now a B-side):
>Blew
>Floyd the Barber
>Spank Thru
>About a Girl
>School
>Love Buzz
>Blandest
>Paper Cuts
>Negative Creep
>Scoff
>Swap Meet
>Mr. Moustache
>If You Must
Cameron Clark
yeah, i've heard the alternate versions of sappy.
it's sad they never did anything with the other verse chorus verse; that song could've been pretty good, i think.
Connor Brown
Eh, it's OK.
There's a better studio version out there than the WTLO studio version
James Robinson
also maybe add beans as a hidden track
iirc, i think that is something kurt cobain actually wanted to do for bleach
Jonathan Thompson
link to this other studio version?
Josiah Torres
i don't mind skeletal family, it's short, and that loop at the end is one of his most underrated moments though that just might be my autism
the only problem i have with it is there's a fucking high pitched frequency that reminds me of my tinnitus in the first ten seconds of the track
Daniel Powell
Bleach singles:
>Love Buzz
>About a Girl
>School
Nevermind singles:
>Sliver
>Smells Like Teen Spirit
>Come As You Are
>Aneurysm
>Lithium
>In Bloom
In Utero singles:
>Heart-Shaped Box
>Rape Me
>All Apologies
>Dumb
>Sappy
Owen Perez
also have drain you as a single for nevermind
William Turner
10/10 albums aren't necessarily perfect
Charles Scott
not only is this post, dare I say, based and redpilled, but you also got DUBS!!
Incredible, I tip my hat to you gentlesir
Ian Davis
Can't seem to find it. the length is 3:24, as opposed to the 3:19 version
Jace Collins
it doesn't fit into the rest of the album. Stop stanning the most dreary uninteresting songs on albums as "pleb filters" you contrarian ass
Jacob Nelson
thats the best song wtf
Julian Ward
no.
Hunter Hill
That song is unbelievably corny
Oliver Nguyen
No, YOU'RE unbelievably corny. Queer.
Asher Allen
based
Jayden Gray
Never listened to this album, is it any good?
Easton White
>>Blandest
Isaiah Cox
(exchange) is disposable but risingson is fucking great, what are you on about
Matthew Ross
no
David Clark
Thought so.
Isaac Jenkins
Fucking this
Jackson Rodriguez
Bad taste
>w-wtf why do the pumpkins do sad soft music i just want mad yelling :(
That album had their best closer period
I bet you think Take me Down wasn't a good end to the first half
Daniel Gomez
no, vampires is the only song i may consider removing to a perfect album.
Blake Moore
based
Lucas Jackson
>The Talking Drum
filtered
Ryder Powell
>deletes pulk/pull revolving doors
Now this is a 10/10.
Jordan Phillips
You just posted cringe bro haha
Brandon Richardson
Very epic good sir!
Connor Murphy
You suck man.
Noah Mitchell
>removing when I’m 64
Go ahead and commit seppuku
Cameron Jones
terrible
I'd cut Trucker's Atlas in half and just let it be instrumental
Josiah Myers
Replace Untilted with Oh Sister. Or shorten Oh Comely
Aiden Murphy
Austin Scott
>deletes buggin
Ethan Perry
God tier sample work on this one though
Jack Garcia
thats my favorite song on the album
Elijah Jenkins
Awful opinion
Nolan Cooper
Rifflet detected
Levi Brooks
no u
Joshua Evans
>Delete Kid A
fucking christ
>You are invited
I should snipe your mother
Owen Clark
based opinion
muh drum machine
Jonathan Torres
blandest is actually a good track and it was originally going to be the B-side to the love buzz single
the B-side they went with instead, big cheese, is vastly inferior to blandest imo
Cooper Gonzalez
>blandest is actually a good track
It's actually crappy. So crappy the band taped over the mastertape.
Benjamin Gutierrez
holy shit until i clicked the image to see it bigger, i thought that was a kid who lost his face and had it stapled back on and the red around it was his blood and flesh underneath his face
what does this say about me as a person if my immediate thought was this?
Owen Turner
i like the song but alright
John Ross
why would you delete the best track? (or second best if mps is #1)
Connor Fisher
shit take
Luke Jones
i think the majority of it is shit desu
Logan Kelly
Terrible opinion. Oh comely should be longer if anything.
Sebastian Wood
*deletes the diamond sea*
ahhh, perfect
Elijah Brooks
Checked and rekt
Adam Wright
Lincoln Robinson
Hey Man is the only
John Roberts
>Replace Matte Kudasai with this but with Adrian's vocals youtube.com
Perfect album, all of the omitted Fripp solos were fucking GODLIKE
>Add Engine (Ferris Wheel Version) into Communist Daughter
>Keep the rest of the tracks
Now it's a 10/10 album
Cooper Harris
based yes
Justin Johnson
>Replace Untilted with Oh Sister
How would that even work
Mason Turner
>not going to colorado to unload your head
>not going to new york city (which is in new york, friends)
>not goin' up goin' over to montana
plen detected
Nathaniel Martin
I SWARE TO GOD...... LOOK! HEARS SOMETHEBG U NEVAR HERD BEFOAR DIS....... YOU BETTAR TAKE A GOOD LOOK AT YOURE MIND FUCKARRRR!!!!!!1
Lucas Thompson
GOOD
BAD
Nolan Jones
>TPAB
>The entire album
Wyatt Foster
*deletes Barry Bonds*
*deletes Drunk and Hot Girls*
Instantly Kanyes indisputable magnum opus.
William Howard
You forgot
>deletes Stronger
>deletes I Wonder
>deletes Homecoming
>deletes Big Brother
>Goes from his 2nd worst album to his 7th best
Elijah Carter
As much as I do like this album, its my least favorite by Ye. Out of curiosity, what do you consider his worst?
Jaxson Hughes
>I like it so that means it's not shit
Not how it works
Christian Sullivan
>music taste is objective, and has been boiled down to a science.
Brayden Jackson
Music is literally math and science. Are you retard?
Daniel Cook
vampires is the worst song on this fantastic album (and its not close)
> he wants to remove riot van
confirmed yank
Wyatt Cook
you realise without pulk/pull it still has hunting bears?
Easton Nguyen
Ye
Then grad then yeezus, probably
Blake Torres
*deletes King of Carrot Flowers, Parts 2 & 3*
there we go, much better
Jonathan Murphy
tried to sound like Joy Division, huh? well, they sure succeeded... they sound just as fucking boring
>*deletes The Overload*