This thread is about updating the roll chart/making individual charts better
Metal roll chart thread v2
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
These are the 9 genres confirmed so far. We decided last thread to combine black metal with war metal. We also thought about having deathdoom as the 10th genre to take its place. Thoughts?
SLUDGE
holy fuck, how long can this go on for...why don't you try something new...like britpop?
FOLK
One of the main people helping with this keeps getting himself banned before we can finish
Fine do Death/Doom 1st cathedral album ink does Winter qualify?
TRADITIONAL
POWER
THANK YOU!
I will start posting in this thread now.
Black Metal
Death Metal
We still need to work on the Thrash Chart, Death/Doom Chart as well as the Technical/Brutal Death Metal Chart.
Only 3 are left!
Disembowelment
Thergothon
Incantation
Thorr's Hammer
Winter
1st paradise lost album?
Everyone PLEASE pay attention to this!
Im guessing we're not going with this chart then?
The dude who made it put on a bunch of good albums that i took off the folk chart that id like to put back on
Take a look at this.
YES!
Put those albums back on!
it's settled then. This is the reversed Folk chart with the black metal bands like summoning, satyricon and obsequiae. I did a quick skim to see if albums overlap with and it looks like it's just ulver with two albums on each
PIC IS UPDATED FOLK CHART
errr with one album on each but different albums*
We can replace Ulver with something better on the Black Metal Chart.
Which band should we replace them with?
2 goatmoon
2 graveland
2 ulver
2 Nokturnal Mortem
Looks like same bands on each list with different albums
Taake - Nattestid ser porten vid...
Bulldozer maybe?
and 2 batlords but i dont think anyone will complain about that
Yeah. Batlord has to stay.
Well I don't see Watain there
Which Waitan album is the best?
Also i have Venom on the trad chart if you want another slot
Lawless Darkness
Get rid of Venom.
They are a better fit for the Black Metal Chart.
We are the real chads here. Everyone else can stick to their containment general for now.
I got banned several times trying to make these charts. Did that stop me? No.
Alright. Ill replace it with Dokken
UPDATED TRAD
This is looking very good so far. I can't wait to see the end result.
It's pretty much just you and me working on the roll chart at this point. lmao.
Fuck it!
Would Armageddon work here
youtube.com
You could take off cathedrals forest of equilibrium & make it cozy on a doom/death chart
Am i working on the deathdoom chart? It could work
Who's working on the death/doom chart? I only know a few bands. I'll post the essentials:
Autopsy
Asphyx
Ceremonium
Cianide
Disembowelment
Goatlord
Winter
These bands NEED to be added!
YES!
Do it, please!
Best Asphyx
Best Cianide
Best Ceremonium
WE NEED THIS!
>no cirith ungol / king of the dead
dude
>lunchando por el metal
dude no
just fucking no
V8 sucks beyond measure, argentinian trad metal sucks and i'm saying this as a lifetime fan. We've only been good at thrash and black
Ill begin work sometime soon when i get in the mood
Its in the trad chart, same with alot of other classic power bands
Need an album to replace it with
Take your time, friend.
I'll probably get banned again, anyway. lul
Try to refrain from doing that until you get the BDM and thrash charts done lol
lmao i'll try
If you wanna keep it argie, you've got Thor / El Pacto (youtube.com
We went full trash and power metal as soon as the scene began. All the real gems of the early scene are in practically lost '84-'90 cassettes .
>thor
It's not known well enough to be included imo
>rata blanca
I like it but yeah its definitely more power metal
Maybe another well known album can replace V8's if you insist
I personally like Blessed are the Sick more than Altars of Madness.
Should we replace it?
youtube.com
Update
Death Metal
This is what i got so far for deathdoom
Looks fantastic so far.
One problem though:
Fleshcrawl is already on the death metal chart.
I might as well post the Thrash Chart.
Fuck it.
I'll post the Technical/Brutal Death Metal chart later.
We might be able to keep Fleshcrawls debut on the death/doom chart.
I can replace it with their second album on the Death Metal chart.
Cool. I left Fleshcrawl in then. I also noticed that Dream Death was on both charts so i replaced that one as well. There is alot of funeral doom in here i hope it counts
Roll.
Fuck it!
We have the best doom genres combined into one chart!
>tfw type o negative has no place in sludge or death doom
At least carnivore is going to be on the thrash chart, should we make ol' Pete the quads get instead of celtic frost since they will be represented on the BM chart?
YES!
Quads = Listen to Type O Negative
Great. Also the order of genres should be considered. My intial tohught is to have it evolve like it did in history. Trad > Power >Thrash > Grind > Death > Deathdoom > Sludge >BDM > Black > Folk. I might have the order wrong but something like that is what i have in mind
You want to put the early genres near the top of the chart and work your way down? That's a good idea.
yeah exactly
Rot - Cruel Face of Life
roll
Shit there is an album image missing in the folk chart
rol
Shit happens.
Fixed folk chart
Are the death/black charts ready to be labeled?
Not yet.
I'll let you know when they are ready.
Roll
This will probably be the final order they are in
We are getting very close to finishing. I'll post what the charts look like in a minute.
Roll
I got two charts finished. Get ready to label them.
Black Metal 1/2
Death Metal 2/2
Awesome. Now we just need BDM and Thrash and we are good to go
Exactly. I'm working on them now.
roll
rolling
maybe put these on there
Mortal sin - face of despair
youtube.com
Wargasm - why play around
youtube.com
Gammacide - victims of science
youtube.com
Warrant - the enforcer
youtube.com
Virus - force recon
youtube.com
Exumer - possessed by fire
youtube.com
Agressor never ending destiny
youtube.com
Cancer - death shall rise
youtube.com
what about swapping blessed are the sick for altars of madness
I'll roll, been in a depressing classical funk the past few days so need me some /meal/
I find that altars is overrated. That's why I put Blessed in there.
However, I might put it back since it's the most influential album.
Update
Replaced Blessed with Altars
That was my thinking as well,especially for a roll chart
Looks like the Thrash Chart is finished.
You may want to replace one of the albums for this one on the death/doom chart.
It looks pretty good.
check this out
Fuck it. Try replacing Fleshcrawl for it. It will look better imo.
Autopsy aren't death/doom
What makes you say that?
Album is too new i think, also Hell I is on the sludge chart
Oh shit! Nevermind.
Looks like i had nasty savage on the power chart. will replace with somethin else
Sweet
Roll.
>/meal/
also, roll
Uy
Technical/Brutal Death Metal
We need a few more albums added.
>vaginal penetration of an amelus with a musty carrot
what
Update
Removed duplicate album.
Roll
Bruh
Bump
Are you still here DoomAnon? I was taking a little break.
rolll
Charts finished! Tell me what you think!
rolllllllll tide
I'll keep bumping the thread with good albums until DoomAnon comes back!
DoomAnon! I'm finished!
The Roll Chart now up to you!
Make sure you label and post the separate charts first.
I am going to point out all the charts that are finished in this thread. Give me a moment!
There should be 10 replies to this! Count them!
I fucked up!
Ignore post The REAL chart is this one!
Take your time, DoomAnon. Make the chart look as great as you can!
Can everyone look over the charts I just quoted? We have to make sure all the albums are different.
h.
rollerino
rollin
Cut the Gothic Doom Metal or merge with something else and make a Power/Trad section.
rolling in shit
rippikoulu - musta seremonia
rollllllollollol
roll
give me something good at least
rolland
roll baby roll
roll
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE ROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
i'm not even a metal fan
...
roll
robl
Yo chartfren, i got some stuff to do tonight but ill being working on it soon
Take your time, dude! Make the chart look as best as you can!
roll
Everyone look at these chart posts.
These are the FINAL charts that have been posted.
If there is anything you want to say about them, I would suggest doing it now.
Ignore post
wtf no warsore? god damn infidels!
and get rid of anaal nakcrap, it's not grind at all it is black metal
actually never mind, there is too much non-grind on that chart anyway, it is beyond saving at this point
Thanks for your suggestion.
don't, have fun spotting the ones that don't belong on that chart and many other charts.
I will. Thank you.
Looks like we got some more work to do, DoomAnon. I'll let you decide if you want to update the chart or not.
bump
roll nigger
Roll
It’s too late so I’ll listen to it tomorrow
I'll keep the thread bumped until you are ready, DoomAnon. I can't wait to see the chart.
roll
...
rool
Technically it’s not traditional metal it’s heavy metal
>phenomenon instead of lights out
Please change, to lights out
You want to rename it to heavy metal?
Yes
Nice to see the thread still up. Im back for the next few hours. I guess the Grind chart needs to be redone? And we're calling trad metal heavy metal now?
added
The rest is up to you, DoomAnon. You are responsible for getting the Roll Chart completed. I don't know what else to do.
Literally perfect now
Thanks
Why am I getting all these digits lately?
roll
Roll.
I guess we just need to make sure the charts are up to meal standards now. Hopefully we can get some feedback in the next few hours. I'll create a new grind chart in the meantime
Rawl
I see. Hopefully we can actually get /meal/ to help us.
Otherwise, we will have to dump our charts on them.
Thankfully i think most of them are complete, the grind chart was the most outdated one
Meh. Just get the grind chart finished and we can safely say we're done.
roll
penis
Halfway done with the grind chart
rollin'
Turns out this user is a faggot- Anaal Nathrakh is grind and warsore is some literally who band
eee hard pass on ride the lighting. kill 'em all or blackened are way better albums.
lol
I'd call traditional heavy metal as anything speed/power/early 80s USA metal. I'm not sure if we can put NWBHM in the same chart as it, but for the sake of convenience, a join chart called heavy metal is a better idea
Most people like Ride the Lightning more.
Updated grind
You should add Necrobiosis. They are very good deathgrind.
lmao
just delete anything considered grind and add anything else with a blastbeat, be it black, death or fastcore the choice is yours, and the chart will be complete
The entire Earache Peel Sessions
donald trumpe
Rollercoaster
I agree with this.
funny they call it the "earache peel sessions" when earache had nothing to do with the peel sessions at all.
I like the look of this cover. You should add it.
The album's primary genre is Grindcore, not black, sorry man
Replaced C.S.S.O with this, hopefully the right album
Not nearly as popular as Noise-A-Go Go!!!
in that case you should replace all the non grind stuff with some grind instead, just sayin'.
lmao. I just like the look of the cover. It looks so simple.
Should Reek of Putrefaction be on there instead?
Im listening to the Anaal Nathrakh album now, and i have concede, im barely hearing any grind in it. Rate your music sucks balls wtf.
Please let me know what other albums are falsely attributed as grind and ill look for replacements
you will figure it out, good luck.
I wondered the same but it seems SoS is more well received
It might be.
However, Putrefaction is probably the most influential. It was the album that started it all.
Replaced a bunch of albums with more grinder albums, replaced SoS with Reeks, replaced Anaal Nathrakh with ACxDC
ROLL NIGGER
This is great, need an album on the chart to go to make room though
These are not really grindcore in any way, just because something has blast beats doesn't make it grindcore.
>ACxDC
>Bucket Full of Teeth
>Cattle Decapitation
>Cephalic Carnage
>Cloud Rat
>Combatwoundedveteran
>Dead in the Dirt
>Full of Hell
>Fuck on the Beach/bllleeaaaauuuurrggggh
>Gaza
Seriously whoever made this chart even know what grindcore actually sound like? There are even more out of place ones. You wouldn't put a bunch of heavy metal bands on a death metal chart now would you?
I used RYM, meal pastebin charts, and MA to fill up the chart, i'm listening to albums as i put them on. In other words, im a tourist who needs to be spoonfed for it to be accurate so thanks
Sounds like me in a nutshell. lmao
You seem very bothered by this. Please make the chart better.
Replaced:
>ACxDC with Hatred Surge
>Bucket Full of Teeth with Liberteer
>Cattle Decapitation with Gorerotted
>Cephalic Carnage with Mortician
>Cloud Rat with Exhumed
>Combatwoundedveteran with Machetazo
>Dead in the Dirt with Last Days of Humanity
>Full of Hell with Pathologist
>Fuck on the Beach/bllleeaaaauuuurrggggh with The County Medical Examiners
>Gaza with disgorge
Any more help would be appreciated based grindanon
metal is for losers
this
please help us
This might be considered grind
hm
Bad places to base your knowledge around grind, they are far from complete and are mostly based on what Earache says what grindcore is.
It is always like this when grind comes up, it is always the non grind for people who are not really into grind yet KNOW what grindcore is all about. I don't really have anything against any of those bands at all but they are not really grindcore and shouldn't be mistaken for grindcore.
I am trying but when someone rather put stuff like Nails, Combatwoundedveteran or The Locust instead of grindcore champs like Warsore, Lt. Dan or old deathgrinding classics like Disharmonic Orchestra. It just bums me out. Don't get me wrong there are lots of good grindcore releases on there but too much non-grind.
needs more waifus added
>Nails, Combatwoundedveteran or The Locust instead of grindcore champs like Warsore, Lt. Dan or old deathgrinding classics like Disharmonic Orchestra.
Looks like these bands have to get replaced.
>roll
Roll!
Back when Nuclear Blast actually released good stuff. This album fucking rips and is the old school of weird deathgrind which is in my opinion the best kind of deathgrind.
Keep them coming based GrindAnon.
Think of it this way.
This chart is for you! We are offering you a gift! Does it look good?
One of many furious Japanese grindcore bands.
Their first album might be more easy to get into considering pic is kinda noisy and raw.
But for anyone looking for mad screaming Jap grind other than Unholy Grave, this might be it.
Pic is from one side of a 7inch split (with Torture Incident), no one can handle more than 6 minutes of DxIxE anyway. They never released any albums either.
How does this one look grindbro
also im gonna take a break for a bit. Till next time. dont get banned chartanon
Papirmöllen fucking nailed it on this one, Norwegian riff grind.
please change Death or Glory to Stronger Than Evil and Heavy Metal Maniac for Unveiling the Wicked. Also if Deep Purple, Bang, Tygers Of Pan Tang, and Rainbow qualify then put Thunder And Lightning by Thin Lizzy on there.
maybe swap out Blue Blood with Art Of Life, drop Awaken The Guardian because its prog metal, swap Land Of The Free for Power Plant, drop Sabaton and Gloryhammer for not being good, add one of Twilight Force's albums and Brothers Of Metal's debut.
roll
Oops, forgot pic.
Better, but it looks like you just removed the emo and added gore/porn instead. Which is a lot better, but i don't know. It is kinda hard to rate grind by popularity when 99% of it is not meant to be popular or is in any way.
add Thundersteel by Riot and Sign of the Hammer by Manowar. Switch out the Lost Horizon album for their debut. Also add King Of Nordic Twilight by Luca Turilli
I'll try not to. You deserve a break.
Since you are the grind expert. Just tell us the best albums to put on the chart. We trust you.
That's another thing, there are not that many grindcore albums out there really. Not compared to tapes, splits and eps. Grind in general is much more suited for shorter bursts of a couple of minutes rather than a full album. Many bands were also only a grind band a short period of time like Napalm Death, Carcass, Rotting Christ or Xysma etc then went on to do other things.
It is also getting kinda late and i have to get up to work early so i will have to continue later.
Alright.
Maybe we can add demos, tapes, eps, etc. to the chart as well.
In the meantime, I'll keep the thread alive. Take care.
Roll
bump
I might post more grind recs in the meantime.
Here I go again
rollin'
roll
Jesus Christ is Lord
An user made an excellent bdm chart and I feel like combing it with mine.
Tell me which albums to pick from this chart to replace on mine. Only the best is allowed
The chart is here
Fuck Nile! I am getting rid of them!
Update
Technical/Brutal Death Metal Chart
Too be honest, I don't know what to replace. All these albums look good.
Everyone compare this chart with mine I am going to need help with this.
again
Update
roll
also where is scatman john
let's a go