RANK THEN

RANK THEN

Attached: Smashing-Pumpkins-Albums.jpg (1600x1087, 482K)

Siamese > Melon Collie > Gish > Adore >>> Rest

>elder god tier
Siamese Dream
>god tier
Gish
Mellon Collie
Adore
>top tier
Pisces Escariot
>mid tier
Machina I
Oceania
>poor tier
Machina II
Shiny and oh so Bright
Zeitgeist
>shit tier
Monuments to an Elegy

how about you inhale the rank smell of my ass

Mellon collie>>diet loveless+Nevermind>everything else

/thread

Bleed < Rest of their discography

If you were truly Billypilled, you would know that ranking their releases is an entirely pointless exercise.

MC>sd>gish>Pisces>machina>a turd>a mountain of garbage>adore>all the other garbage

this

Based

Siamese sounds literally nothing like loveless, the vocals are presented a lot more cleanly and is heaps less psychedelic and more grungy.

Billy Corgan also actually knows how to write a song.

this

mellon collie and siamese are equals imo, siamese is more consistent but about half the songs on mellon collie blow anything on siamese out of the water

>Okay tier
Siamese Dream
>Okay but mostly cringe tier
Gish and Mellon Collie
>Dogshit tier
Everything else

Attached: 1562436792824.jpg (932x1200, 358K)

shut up peter griffin from family guy mellon collie is better than gish

Mashed Potatoes boxset>Everything else.

1. Siamese Dream
2. Adore
3. Melon
[3.1. Pisces]
4. Gish
Everything else goes from mediocre to painfully bad

He was extremely good for pop songwriting since day one, but became a good lyricist until Adore.

1. Siamese Dream
2. Gish
3. Mellon Collie
4. Machina
5. Adore
EVERYTHING ELSE = SUCKS

move elegy to poor and oceania up to >good tier

Zeitgeist would have been mid-top tier if it wasn't mixed like dog shit. Would be cool if someone reached out to Billy for a remastered reissue, but he always responds with some nonsensical asshole answer

this is the true answer