Christgau thinks these are all very overrated albums. Agree?
Christgau thinks these are all very overrated albums. Agree?
Caleb Kelly
Other urls found in this thread:
Nolan Peterson
wtf is that cover for Joshua Tree lmao
Brandon Ward
christgau doesn't think
Eli Wilson
wtf i love christgau now
Joshua Nelson
He's right except for White Album. White Album is the epitome of rock.
Chase Green
Pet Sounds and OK Computer are overrated, but quite good.
Gotta listen to the Van Morrison one again, might finally get into him.
Whenever I tried to listen to the entirety of Dark Side Of The Moon, I couldn't remember anything except "Money" and "Time". It's like a mindwipe.
Never heard the other two.
Mason Hall
And Christgau hates rock.
Jeremiah Rivera
>pet sounds
easy listening bossa nova
>van morrison
pseudo-spiritualism. basically new age music.
>dsotm
soft rock
>joshua tree
soft rock
>ok computer
soft rock
Aiden Smith
IIRC his problem with it is that it has too much Paul.
Cooper Morales
>two favorite albums of all time are New York Dolls S/T and The Clash S/T
Easton Russell
The Clash S/T is more reggae than rock tho.
Kevin Torres
Also critics hated Paul and loved John because he pandered to their counterculture delusions.
Justin Richardson
Pet Sounds Is the only one that’s not overrated, the rest, absolutely. Van morrison is pretty good though
James Butler
Nah. John wrote better songs.
Luke Jackson
nice meme my friend, pet sounds is nothing like bossa nova
Nolan Jenkins
>Q: You once did a list of the 100 greatest albums of 1967. Would you consider doing a similar list for 1968?
>A: I had not for a number of reasons, for example I've never cared much for The White Album (too much Paul) or Astral Weeks. As with a lot of other things, if someone paid me to make a list, I might do it but I have far too many other projects to take on.
Ryder Jackson
christgau sucks but he's right on this one
Alexander Gonzalez
That 1967 list was written in 77 to commemorate the 10th anniversary of the Summer of Love and I think some other guy wrote it with him.
Connor Perez
>van morrison
>pseudo-spiritualism. basically new age music.
Cuckgau really pretty much hates that kind of stuff so it's no surprise he doesn't like the album (he loves BYM though)
Julian Robinson
based
Mason Anderson
WTF I love Christgau now!
Mason Bailey
i hate cuckgau but he's right about this
Blake Foster
I hate Brown Eyed Girl. The guitar hook is irritating as fuck.
Brody Flores
Are you sure about that? youtube.com
Thomas Morris
No, yes, no, yes, yes, yes
Justin Morris
An alternative cover?
Owen Harris
You drink soi milk.
Owen Howard
Let's be honest... all his ratings are shit. He's only right when he says exile on main street is the greatest rock album ever
Sebastian Peterson
Sticky Fingers and Let it Bleed are both superior exile on meme street.
Carson Peterson
He was kind of right about the Eagles.
Brandon Wood