ITT: bands that are entirely composed of hacks except for one member

JPJ is the only talented person in Led Zep.

Attached: zep.jpg (1401x788, 208K)

Attached: bait.jpg (345x322, 11K)

No it's not.

>who was John Bonham

A hack.

pleb filtered

Liam Gallagher

JC: Are there bands that came from Cream’s influence you consider to be good, maybe Led Zeppelin?

GB: Jimmy’s [Page] a good player. I don’t think Led Zeppelin filled the void that Cream left, but they made a lot of money. I probably like about 5% of what they did – a couple of things were really cool. What I don’t like is the heavy bish-bash, jing-bap, jing-bash bullshit.

JC: What do you think of Zeppelin’s late drummer, John Bonham?

GB: Years ago, John said, “There are two drummers in rock and roll, Ginger Baker and me.” There’s no way John was anywhere near what I am. He wasn’t a musician. A lot of people don’t realize I studied. I can write music. I used to write big band parts in 1960, ‘61. I felt that if I was a drummer, I needed to learn to read drum music. I was so good at sight reading, a guy in one of the big bands told me to get two books. I studied them at the same time. One was about the rules of basic harmony, the other how to break them all [laughs].

Everyone knows ginger thought he was amazing
So what?

>fuck yeah throw on some Cream dude!
said nobody ever

Yeah what an asshole. Also Led Zeppelin is the shit. Robert Plant is a great vocalist to me. JPJ is a great bassist. Jimmy page is a great guitarist, even better before the H. And JB was a great drummer. For Led Zeppelin. They came together and made great music. You’re all just contrarian fags who like neutral milk hotel.

>You’re all just contrarian fags who like neutral milk hotel.
Cool strawman.

Graham Coxon in Blur
not a particularly great songwriter on his own but his more Fripp-like guitar-work on the band's stuff is amazing if you listen out for it

Cool autism

Robert Plant had a fantastic voice, at least for 4 years before he destroyed his voice in 1973

muse

Are you referring to the drummer or the bass player?

The Killers has always been a Brandon Flowers solo act since day one. They are just a band in name only.

A DUSTLAND FAIRYTALE ADVENTURE JUST ANOTHER WHITE TRASH COUNTY KID

Attached: 1560910952889.png (596x627, 381K)

Holy fuck what a tool. He sounds so triggered that a drunk buffoon who didn't know music theory was able to shit out classic drum beats while he was hungover and he never did anything original himself.

good try nigga but i know u know

Attached: C7C456BB-6820-453A-AE30-427321FA2FC6.jpg (750x987, 79K)

Hello there.

As a person diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome Disorder (ASD) of the Autism Spectrum Disorder, I find this highly offensive.

You assault someone simply because of what they say, and that is not OK.

Furthermore, you use "autism" as an insult, not even using it with a reason or knowing what the condition is.

It is also very disappointing that you either assumed that he had the condition or assumed that he did not and attacked him by providing false information.

He may be struggling, and all you did was attempt to make his day a bit worse.

Please be nice.

t. person diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome Disorder (ASD) of the Autism Spectrum Disorder

Attached: nirvana.jpg (970x500, 91K)

Attached: GettyImages-91061602.jpg (1800x1200, 377K)

yes and it was krist

Pink Floyd

That's why he fell into obscurity after Cobain's death?

stop sperging out dude no one cares

rog was the best

Attached: rog bite.jpg (254x254, 19K)

yep

That's Wright

Carl?

Based
Cringe

Cream has like 5 good songs.

fag

Has there ever been more asspain contained in one single quote?

Wright was no doubt the most talented member of Pink Floyd. David is/was a great guitar soloist though, to be fair.

Electric Light Orchestra: Lynne obviously

Alice Cooper: Michael Bruce wrote or co-wrote basically every good song Alice is known for. No surprise that Alice's solo career sucks and the one band album where Bruce didn't write much (School's Out) is hot garbage.

Beastie Boys: MCA was the linchpin, the other 2 would just be obnoxious without him to bounce off of.

Replacements: Nothing's ever convinced me the guys other than Westerberg were even remotely essential

Panic at the Disco: Ryan Ross

Velvet Underground: John Cale

CCR: duh

CSNY: God they fucking suck without Neil Young.

>Velvet Underground: John Cale
moronic post

HEY NOW

Attached: FDA50FB8-12FE-4C79-B385-3D29DAED7918.jpg (900x1200, 191K)

I like Zeppelin and Neutral Milk Hotel

Page ran the band, so of course you'll see it that way... Bonham wanted to play a double kick 7 Page vetoed it

nevermind i read that as JP

Why does such an accomplished and respected man have to be so bitter? He's consistently ranked among the best drummers of all time yet he still talks like he needs to prove himself to the world.

Probably because he knows he survives on reputation/mystique alone and people don't truly think about him on a deep level. Those "BEST DRUMMERS" lists and conversations are basically just people throwing out names just to do it; they can't actually describe anything about their musicianship on a meaningful level. No one, even people who were old enough during Cream's reign can even hum let alone name a Cream tune aside from Sunshine of Your Love, and that song sounds like ten others songs from the era.

His legacy is just absolutely "blah." I guarantee 99% of the people he meet just say something along the lines of, "Oh yeah, Cream. You guys could really play!"

wrong

TVU
The Smiths
Oasis
The Who

He took that bass to the bridge of the nose pretty hard

Entwisle right?

>The Who
wrong

Moz/Marr are essential. Both are great but neither functions alone (Moz got tons of help on his solo stuff).

>Who
Nah, Townshend is certainly the biggest factor but all 4 are essential to the whole personality

Ed O'Brien

based

I think Mike D is the most talented