The Great Debate

Pet Sounds. The Beatles were a great band but completely incapable of putting out a perfect album whereas The Beach Boys have several.

Pet sounds obviously. It's just so damn gud.

dude india vs dude surfrock

yeah nah i'll pass

>dude india vs dude surfrock

Have you listened to either of these albums?

LARP. Brazilians don't have a good enough vocabulary to use words like 'eons'

yeah and that is what they are. now shoo shoo

name one Beach Boys album you consider perfect and why.

>1 Indian influenced song
>0 surf rock songs

brilliant.

Indian influenced song
are you stupid

I never understood the appeal of Sgt. Pepper's. Is it remembered solely for it's influence? Pet Sounds all the way desu

Pet Sounds for the complex compositions and emotional, self-conscious lyrical themes.

Proto Pet Sounds was pretty good too

Attached: The Ronettes - Front.jpg (1535x1535, 2.49M)

>Sloop John B
>emotional, self conscious

Yeah I agree with this one

Fred Durst shits on both you pleyboys.

Attached: 1554432961923s.jpg (125x125, 2K)

pet sounds hands down. It doesnt have any weak tracks where as sgt has a few

>time to log on and debate about 60s pop music for teen girls

Attached: 1532521991582.jpg (820x884, 70K)

Surf's Up

A cover song in the middle of the album centered around the line "I want to go home" not long after Brian quit touring due to a severe mental illness.

one is like having anal with no condom and the other one is like anal but without lube

Sometimes I want to strangle you stupid zoomers.
>60s pop music for teen girls
Does not describe The Beatles or The Beach Boys at all. Remove yourself from the gene pool.

Attached: E694E7D2-FBB3-402C-B856-D5685C7F9ABB.jpg (471x560, 40K)

The Beach Boys and The Kinks were way better than The Beatles

Sgt Pepper is like the 4th best beatles album.

Smile > Revolver > Pet Sounds > Pepper

Pet sounds

Lol

doesn't matter because surf's up shits on both of those

YLYL thread?

Attached: 1471018005706.gif (500x500, 15K)

The Beatles were really dumb not placing strawberry fields and penny lane on the album

Pet Sounds is the greatest piece of American music ever made. I feel proud to say it came from my country.

Beach Boys and Kinks didn't released half of the masterpiece Beatles did so no they are not even close.

Better a burger than a bong

>surfrock

>im proud about something that I wasn't involved at all
Based

its cool thing that they have strong singles outside of the albuns

Hey Jude are also an non single album

I feel Sgt. Peppers incorporates other instruments and other styles of music but not as impressively as Pet Sounds. She's Leaving Home is the baroque song and Within You Without You is the India song. Pet Sounds blended a huge number of instruments including stuff like the theremin and made it sound rather original, not like it's just delving into different already established sounds.

ITT: plebs

Sgt. Pepper sounded like it was trying too hard to be interesting. Pet Sounds was still trying to be a likable album as opposed to a 40 minute wankfest with single padding

agreers

Pepper isn't even the Beatles' best album. It tries to be all over the place but achieves nothing. The leap from rubber soul to revolver was great, the leap from sgt to white album eas also great, but sgt is just repeating revolver but with little more orchestration. Yes, there may be great ideas, but the way they were put into songs is poor. I do appreciate eclecticism of Beatles, but in this case the songs are just bad both if you consider them as pop songs and if you consider them as progressively sounding stuff (tomorrow never knows, I'm only sleeping, strawberry fields, revolution 9 were probably rather progressive)
And on the other side we have pet sounds, which came out before any other artist even tried to do something progressive and conceptual. Before face to face, before freak out, before revolver etc. It sounds as a complex work both musically and lyrically. It was composed and arranged entirely by one guy, it sounds copmlex, but it remains a good sounding record. It just flows and you don't pay attention to random gimmicks but it still sounds much greater than everything else. Probably true that beach boys didn't do any other great albums like this, but again, the leap from everything before to pet sounds is just giant.

Sgt Pepper's all the way

Pet Sounds is great though

OH CAROLIIIIIIIIIIIINE NOOOOOOOO

Except it does you tard boomer,the shitles are tweeny pop music no matter how hard they tried to appear artsy in the most shallow possible ways to appeal to idiots of your caliber

this is better than both

Attached: London Calling.jpg (355x353, 22K)

>"I feel so broke up, I wanna go home"
>"Why don't you leave me alone, yeah yeah"

Sgt pepper is far from their best shit. I’ve played every Beatles bass line. Go to abbey road.

who cares??