No, you see, it's genius because it's SUPPOSED to sound like shit!

>no, you see, it's genius because it's SUPPOSED to sound like shit!

Attached: 220px-Trout_Mask_Replica[1].png (220x220, 94K)

hey op just curious, post your top 10 albums

You just have shit ears

This

>I can't refute OP so instead I'm going to ask a completely different question, laugh at him no matter what his answer is, and accordingly declare the original claim incorrect by association

post yours first (;

Attached: chr.png (896x672, 1.02M)

Strawmen don't need refuting

>I can't refute either so I'm going to assume OP is right because of "I don't like thing, therefore is objectively bad on purpose and everyone is pretending to like thing" fallacy

>his taste is this bad
you're only proving OP right
>I can't refute OP so instead I'm going to call it a strawman and then congratulate myself on immediately winning by default
>I can't refute OP so instead I'm going to project

yikes

People actually try to defend this album

Attached: 31079d0a.jpg (320x320, 37K)

You never win arguing with idiots. You win by enjoying whatever you like, especially if doing that annoys idiots.

Why do you even fucking bother making a chart if it’s all Yea Forums essentials??? Is this fucking bait???

>I still can't refute so I'm going to mirror the same argument in a way to win automatically, even though I have no idea why the album is bad
I can keep going.

it's fun and manic

Hey man, some people just like hearing lots of notes in quick succession with odd time signatures with a gravely, vaguely redneck voice over top. To each their own

correct, but the OP most likely isn't an idiot, so this is an argument with normal people. your rules for arguing with idiots doesn't apply here
>I'm going to accuse user of being a copycat even though he was the one who first started posting using the "I can't refute OP so" template, making me the copycat
>I don't agree with user, so he obviously doesn't know what he's talking about, nor does he have the brain power to articulate why he dislikes what I like, since if he did have any idea what he was talking about, he would obviously agree with me, never mind that he hasn't been asked to articulate why he dislikes the thing in question in the first place
>I can keep going

veteran's day poppy is conventionally pretty, both of these albums have unique and pretty parts

t..pleb

Attached: 1054BCF7-6DA8-4876-BFD9-6C25EC4D9ED2.jpg (640x1009, 303K)

>Facebook

Then it is the perfect party album. Be sure to play that at the next party you are at and watch everyone cheer you on for having such fun taste in music.

the magic band are tight as fuck

Yeah but it sounds like shit in a really complicated and skilled way

"manic" doesn't exactly scream party music

>they're

I am so god damn tired of the “MUH skills” argument.

Yes, there is some credit due, and something to be said about the Magic Bands technical ability when it comes to transcribing Beefhearts dreadful music, and rehearsing it proficiently.

But everyone seems to pretend the captain beefheart knew shit about music theory and this was all some epic 8D chess musical shitpost by Captain Beefheart, when in reality, the fucker had no idea how to play piano or shit about music theory or music in general outside of the blues.

He played totally random shit that was meaningless and made the band members learn it, made more random unintelligible lyrics, and everyone thinks he’s some genius.

He’s just some psychopath that was trying to emulate (poorly) his best friend in Highschool. Frank Zappa.

Don Van Vliet was a spoiled rotten child and it shows through your his whole life.

basèd

Well at least he wasn't boring like Zappa.

the lyrics are great though, one of the highlights