I think Black Parade has aged better. Idiot comes across as try hard.
Which is better?
Kevin Brown
Other urls found in this thread:
twitter.com
twitter.com
Christian James
Black Parade was always better and it's not even close, people just looked at you weird when you said you like MCR because of all the scene bullshit while Green Day was cool
Joshua Lee
From Under The Cork Tree
Aaron Bennett
>Of all people, Joe Jonas from the Jonas Brothers leaked that MCR are coming back this year
>During the Jonas Brothers' rehearsal, they saw MCR also rehearsing
What timeline is this?
Charles Collins
Both suck a fat one and are pedestrian 12-year-old tier, so who cares?
Nathan Butler
Post your 3 favourite albums
Jackson Torres
pop-punk as a whole is literally the worst genre of music in existence
Logan Morris
based and high IQ
Evan Hernandez
But user thats not your favorite genre
Christopher Bennett
t. listened to Simple Plan
Listen to Lifetime, Jawbreaker and Buzzcocks you Fantano drone
Xavier Phillips
or the ergs
William Smith
Green Day's the better band, The Black Parade is the better album
Tyler Campbell
Gargle my nuts retard. Anyone that listens to anything by either band other than Dookie is a mondo fag.
Xavier Cox
Source?
Anthony Gray
Henry Gray
Jason Gray
>power chord melodrama vs power chord melodrama
wow, difficult decision.
James Wilson
>Fantano drone
i don't regularly watch Fantano and only learned who he was like a month or two ago.
no, i've hated pop-punk for years. pop-punk was literally just birthed from trying to rip-off nirvana's nevermind and the grunge movement as a whole but combine it with boy bands.
Lucas Adams
buuuut, i will admit i've never listened to any of those specific bands you mentioned before. i'll probably give them a try just to see how i feel on them. most likely going with buzzcocks because i like that name.
Connor Smith
Fantano likes MCR and Green Day though.
Brayden Martinez
youre fucking retarded if you think pop punk sounds anything like grunge
Jace Mitchell
i can't stand to listen to either of those bands, especially not MCR. they're ear bleeding for me.
it's basically just grunge combined with boy bands. it takes the sadness and emotion and hurt of grunge but combines it with the pop of boy bands to make some unholy abomination frankenstein.
Jayden Brooks
>not post-grunge or adult contemporary
Zachary Butler
You're fucking retarded, pop punk goes back to the 1980's, arguably the 70's with the Ramones.
Jeremiah Gray
You're confusing pop punk with post-grunge or sad alternative rock. How the FUCK does something like In Too Deep sound even remotely grunge?
Zachary Russell
post-grunge and adult contemporary are also awful
i kinda lump pop-punk, post-grunge, and adult contemporary all together in my head though desu
they all just go in the 'unlistenable shit' category
Aiden Evans
i dont even know what in too deep is lol.
i think youre probably right though that im confusing pop-punk with post-grunge. the only pop-punk bands i know are like green day and blink-182.
i thought imagine dragons was pop-punk but apparently it isn't according to wikipedia??? even though the band sounds identical to fall out boy and wikipedia says that is pop-punk.
but yeah, apparently i'm retarded.
Jace Ward
black parade is its own thing, american idiot is literally just zen for gay retards
Jaxon Anderson
best in the genre comin through
Evan Ramirez
I've only listened to the singles but Welcome to the Black Parade the song sounds more tryhard than any of the singles off American Idiot, specifically the line about leading the beaten and the damned.