Does Scaruffi have good taste in jazz?

Does Scaruffi have good taste in jazz?

Attached: file.png (954x795, 228K)

pretty basic bitch tier

No

No, none of these albums from Mingus, Coltrane, and Davis have a 10 from him despite all of them having at least a 10 in actuality

9.5 maybe

mingus is overrated as fuck by white people (who he hate by the way)

no

Not even Scaruffi’s ratings

Attached: C3B9E76C-9F4E-4EE8-B0C0-BBDA2EC8536F.jpg (390x431, 114K)

Whatever the analogue of rockist is to jazz, that's Scaruffi. He's more interested in the aesthetics than understanding the language. On the other hand, every art critic has that problem.

what's his end game?

I think he overrated Mingus and underrated Coletrane in several cases, but otherwise pretty accurate. He also missed Dark Magus, which is one of the best Miles albums.

That would depend on your own opinion OP you fag.

It's deeper than "I liked it" or "I didn't liked it".
His opinions are completely detached and formed in a vacuum. That's what bad taste is.

Mingus was half white you idiot

Attached: tenor.gif (498x278, 458K)

Considering pic related and his actual jazz list at least Black Saint and A Love Supreme should be 9.5 (and probably spiritual Unity too). Kind of Blue should be a 9. goofed it.

Attached: list.png (267x700, 35K)

>Mingus x5 5/10

lmao no

scruffi did the 7+ ratings himself

But why is it all noodly vampy bullshit?

Mingus, Coltrane, Davis, the list could go on...

It’s looks like it was made to stir controversy

Should've had more Mingus

5 more mingus' and it would have been a ten

if thats true than a a rainbow in curved air should be a nine, and fare forward should be fourth on his rock list (depending on if he includes the electronica or not)

this is outdated as fuck