Overrated albums thread. I'll start with the basic ones

Overrated albums thread. I'll start with the basic ones.

Attached: topsters2 - 2019-05-23T170534.312.png (1662x1575, 1.2M)

Igor

give me one reason loveless is overrated

Nice chart background faggot did your mom make it for you?

Yes no yes no no

Yes yes no eh eh eh
Eh no no no yes yes

Attached: 77C31651-30C1-4E88-B9F1-3091236E9513.jpg (3199x1569, 356K)

No| yes| no | yes|yes
Yes| wtf| no |no| no| no
no |no. | yes| yes| yes| no

OP here, I found it too abrasive. No one could ever actually an album that’s so offputting, you’re all posers

It's considered one of the greatest records of all time yet all it has going for it is the production. It is nearly 50 minutes of stale, poorly composed, soulless alternative rock and pop music. The catch is the guitarists and engineers spent more time tweaking the timbre (which is dated by todays standards) instead of paying any attention to the songwriting or talent of the musicians.

>Dummy
>Overrated

Dummy may be the most kino album I’ve heard in my life.

>I found it too abrasive
If you think Loveless is too abrasive, you haven't even heard an abrasive album before.

Attached: abrasive.jpg (320x320, 20K)

>madvillainy
>overrated

nevermind is the only real contender for the most overrated, but i could see how you'd think these are super overrated
pic is what i thought, cercle means i haven't heard it
also, How isn't Sgt Peppers up there?

Attached: overrated.png (1662x1575, 3.23M)

Sgt Pepper's deserves a good amount of the acclaim. Not the greatest record ever, but it certainly changed the face of popular music as we know it and stuff like Day in the Life are huge influencers production wise.

how is spiderland overrated

Does not deserve to be among the highest rated hip hop releases of all time. It may have influence under its sleeve, but in terms of content it's lackluster and quite boring.

There are only three good albums on this chart

>poorly composed
how

>Anything Talking Heads
>Overrated

I dont like this,
Debyt is better

Attached: 1551657227138.jpg (1920x1080, 1.11M)

>Forever Changes

Faggot. FAGGOT.

Came here to post this and I think it's a 10 lol fpbp

No love

>this thread

Attached: 1516207564140.jpg (250x241, 13K)

If you think daughters are abrasive etc

How is Forever Changes overrated?

neither have you

The melodies on Loveless are great, and some of the songs would still be quite good if you remove the distortion, like Sometimes. Go look at some acoustic loveless covers, there are good songs underneath the effects.

I've heard many acoustic loveless covers. They have a good amount of passion to them but thats from the covering artists. The songs themselves are very very bland and boring, taking away the distortion makes it even more uninteresting since that's the whole reason why this record is so famous.

How is Nevermind overrated? Name 5 better rock albums

Amnesiac is actually underrated desu

yes, yes, yes, no, yes
no, yes, no, yes, no, no
no, yes, yes, no, yes, no
Illinois is more underrated now that Carrie and Lowell is out

Who cares?

Of all the albums on this list that’s the one you pick to shitpost on?

Not him, but this is where we disagree. The songs themselves are fantastic, the use of open tunnings, chord progressions and melodies are all ridiculously memorable and hypnotic by themselves.

Also, how the fuck is Kind of Blue, Remain In Light and Liquid Swords overrated?

Kind of Blue, Pet Sounds, and Master of Puppets should be removed from this chart.

Because it's posted on this fucking board 24/7, you mongoloid.

Attached: CurfzMi.jpg (4000x5500, 3.11M)

No. No. Yes. Yes. Yes.
No. Yes. No. No. No. No.
Yes. No. No. No. Yes. No.

Replace amnesiac with kid a.

>the guitaristS and engineers
>instead of blah blah musicians
This sounds like someone who knows nothing about the album and listened to the first 3 tracks once. Tell me how I know you’re a pseud pleb.

uhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

I guess the summerfags are back

hi guys havent been on this board in awhile i finally listened to this album after seeing it around for years and its great, you guys got any reccomendations for stuff like it? i'm into the happy mondays and other madchester stuff too but this album specifically has such a unique sound

Attached: stone.jpg (550x550, 194K)

oh fuck i meant to make my own thread sorry fellas

They've been for a while

>spiderland>inrainbows>dummy>liquidswordz
cringe

snoozecore

Forgetting some p obvious ones senpai:
This Heat - Deceit
Can - Tago Mago
Slint - Spiderland
The Pop Group - Ys
Galaxie 500 - On Fire
Pretty much banal middle of the road shite albums that gets praised by entry level plebeians