How fucking autistic is Scaruffi

web.archive.org/web/19991113115603/http://www.scaruffi.com/music/best100.html
wew

Why hasn't he rated any of her albums though

(not true, by the way)

>Daydream Nation that high
>Nevermind in top 50
based

>Beatles at very bottom

good critics get it right the first time

>This website does NOT use cookies. Period.
How can you not love this man?

Attached: file.png (256x211, 48K)

I’m happy I’m not the only one who noticed this lol

he's the greatest man who ever lived

>Look What You Made Me Do (not written by Martin), off Reputation (2017), mostly composed by Martin, Shellback (Johan Schuster) and Jack Antonoff, and Me (by Joel Little) were not particularly more tedious and banal than the previous ones, just the public had moved on to other pop stars.

>The prolific Cardiacs never quite produced a great album
Later
>Sing to God, 7.5/10, genre: genius
What did he mean by this

He's a pleb like the other meme critics this site worships, A Little Man is a great album.

absolutely based

he contradicts himself all the time this is nothing special

>opinions dont change

And here I thought it wasn’t possible to have worse taste than Fantano

>he says dylan invented the talking blues
>he says metallica invented speed metal

Your tastes adjust the older you get

he's 63, he was relistening to Nirvana albums in his 40s lmao

>relistening
more like listening for the first time

bleach score should be lower and in utero score should be higher

are you fucking retarded? also he had Nevermind in his best albums list dating back to the 90's or earlier

make your own shitty website and score them yourself

nah Bleach is the best album, he even says In Utero is the weakest

>It had been announced as a brutal and harsh work - yet another Seattle-style marketing scoop - as if Nirvana should refuse their modern pop star status. As a matter of fact the new album was absolutely in line with both their image and sound. But it also showed their leader's limits, as well as their limit as a group. Their idea of rock music can not be delivered in more than a couple of ways, so they are forced to repeat in Rape Me the substance of Teen Spirit and in Radio Friendly Unit Shifter the essence of Negative Creep. In Pennyroyal Tea, Heart-Shaped Box and Serve The Servants an endless sequence of grunge surgery is performed upon the Beatles' somatic features. However, Cheap Trick had already tried that in an humbler way and, if nothing else, with self-irony. In a word, this is the weakest among Nirvana's records, the one in which the formula starts to falter.

That's what RYM is for

Based or cringe?

Attached: 53BDBAAA-3DB3-4ECB-BD3C-186E4FA9CCA0.jpg (1113x1894, 1.04M)

absolutely based and wholesome if you hate this you're a 17 year old who's embarrassed of his own shadow

It's the fucking physical wall of fame that gets me

Attached: l3q58avzp5w21.jpg (1200x540, 109K)

has anyone emailed him about seeing the physical wall of fame?

>you will never be on here

Attached: file.png (500x490, 41K)

It would be based if he named it something like "Piero's Friends" instead of fucking "HALL OF FAME" like what the fuck

"You have become my friend, what an accomplishment you have obtained, congratulations"
"Piero what the fuck, we're just chilling in my house-"
"HALL OF FAME PIERO'S FRIENDS PHYSICAL HALL OF FAME ALSO IN MY HOUSE"

This is not wholesome, it's egotistical and retarded

Yeah, I think his review of Abbey Road is overwhelmingly positive, but he gave it a 7/10 and still hates the band and claims they've never done anything worthwhile.

I did something similar to this in high school for my senior block where I tried fitting as many names I could on it. I forgot to give it a title though.

it's endearing dude

7/10 is a good score to scruffles

If you actually think Fantano has better taste than Scaruffi you should probably stop listening to music.

Seems he's always right the first time.

>7/10 is a good score to scruffles
He still says they've done nothing worthwhile.
>"Rock critics are often totally ignorant of the rock music of the past, they barely know the best sellers. No wonder they will think that the Beatles did anything worthy of being saved."

I recall him saying he only listened to A Little Man and earlier.