1. Five Years

1. Five Years
>9/10
2. Soul Love
>8/10
3. Moonage Dream
>9/10
4. Starman
>10/10
5. It Ain't Easy
>7/10
6. Lady Stardust
>6/10
7. Star
>7/10
8. Hang Onto Yourself
>9/10
9. Ziggy Stardust
>8/10
10. Suffragette City
>9/10
11. Rock 'N' Roll Suicide
>9/10
12. John, I'm Only Dancing
>10/10
13. Velvet Goldmine
>8/10
14. Sweet Head
>7/10
15. Ziggy Stardust (Acoustic Ver.)
>9/10
16. Lady Stardust (Piano Ver.)
>7/10

Attached: 91WJORzpHML._SL1500_.jpg (1500x1500, 379K)

>rock n roll suicide isnt a 10
Get the fuck out of here

>It Ain't Easy 7/10
Cringe. At least a 9

Yeah I pretty much agree, would probably boost RnRS and drop It Aint Easy a point or two.

Here, I'll do one too.

>Blackstar
10/10
>Tis a Pity
>9/10
>Lazarus
10/10
>Sue
8/10
>Girl Loves Me
7/10
>Dollar Days
9/10
>I Can't Give Everything Away
10/10

Attached: Blackstar_album_cover.jpg (500x500, 22K)

15 Step
>7/10
Bodysnatchers
>7/10
Nude
>9/10
Weird Fishes
>8/10
All I Need
>5/10
Faust Arp
>4/10
Reckoner
>8/10
House of Cards
>3/10
Jigsaw Falling
>7/10
Videotape
>6/10

Attached: 908C3609-4157-4082-A0E4-0D3B6291A8AA.jpg (1000x1000, 258K)

>House of Cards 3/10
how do people come to such objectively wrong conclusions?

It doesn't go anywhere over the course of its 5 minute run time and the lyrics are cringe. Not saying you can't write about trying to start an affair or whatever but have some tact when you do. It's like being stuck in traffic.

15 Step is a 9

>It doesn't go anywhere over the course of its 5 minute run time
It doesn't have to. Some songs work specifically through repetition, and House of Cards is one of them.
>the lyrics are cringe
Lol what? First off cringe as a criticism is lazy. Second off I don't even kind of agree. It's a beautiful song.

>Forget about your house of cards
>And I'll do mine
>Fall off the table
>Get swept under
>Denial
>Your ears should be burning
The opening line is especially gorgeous.
>I don't want to be your friend, I just want to be your lover
Hell I'm not even an In Rainbows fag, but House of Cards is probably my favorite song from that album, maybe tied with Jigsaw or Bodysnatchers.

Why are you rating the bonus tracks as if they're part of the album?

>Lady Stardust
>6/10
lol shut the FUCK up

Tired of sex
>9/10
Getchoo
>8/10
No Other one
>9/10
Why Bother
>9/10
Across the Sea
>10/10
The good life
>10/10
El Scorcho
>8/10
Pink Triangle
>9/10
Falling for You
>9/10
Butterfly
>9/10

overall 10/10 easy

Attached: pinky-ten.jpg (220x215, 13K)

would step up Bodysnatchers and Jigsaw
would drop each song a little bit except for El Scorcho and would drop Getchoo farther

Peaches en regalia
>10/10
Willie the Pimp
>9/10
Son of Mr. Green Genes
>10/10
Little Umbrellas
>8/10
The Gumbo Variations
>9/10
It Must Be a Camel
>9/10

shit forgot image

Attached: MI0002011144.jpg (500x491, 52K)

shit bait

>See No Evil
9/10
>Venus
10/10
>Friction
9/10
>Marquee Moon
10/10
>Elevation
10/10
>Guiding Light
9/10
>Prove It
9/10
>Tom Curtain
10/10

Holy shit dudes, how did they do it?

Attached: 20180512_195256.png (720x698, 670K)

Correct IR ratings:

>15 Step
9/10
>Bodysnatchers
10/10
>Nude
10/10
>Weird Fishes
10/10
>All I Need
8/10
>Faust Arp
7/10
>Reckoner
10/10
>House of Cards
8/10
>Jigsaw
9/10
>Videotape
7/10

Attached: inrainbows.jpg (220x220, 33K)

We Invent You
>8/10
Look A Ghost
>9/10
December
>9/10
Treachery
>10/10
Terminus
>10/10
Demons Sing Love Songs
>10/10
Off This Century
>10/10
One Lick Less
>7/10
Scarlett
>8/10
October All Over
>8/10
Summer Freeze
>10/10
Radio Gra
>10/10
Below The Salt
>10/10
Who Cares
>7/10

Attached: 20180401_203258.png (720x718, 57K)

Untitled
>9/10
Obstacle 1
>10/10
NYC
>9/10
PDA
>10/10
Say Hello To The Angels
>10/10
Hands Away
>8/10
Obstacle 2
>9/10
Stella
>10/10
Roland
>9/10
The New
>10/10
Leif Erikson
>8/10

underrated 10/10 record

Attached: totbl.png (1300x1300, 352K)

Deduct everything after PDA by 3 points and this is my rating.
Seriously this album really drags in the second half.

>Changes
9/10
>Oh You Pretty Things
10/10
>Eight Line Poem
7/10
>Life on Mars
10/10
>Kooks
8/10
>Quicksand
8/10
>Fill your Heart
8/10
>Andy Warhol
10/10
>Song for Bob Dylan
9/10
>Queen Bitch
8/10
>Bewlay Brothers
9/10

Attached: 61bwfUBW5gL.jpg (499x500, 80K)

>el scorcho 8/10 and pink triangle 9/10
incorrect both 10/10

Attached: 1552426700862.jpg (511x540, 22K)

based and redpilled

lady stardust is definitely a 9 or a 10 idiot

This, idk what that guy was thinking giving it a 7

Five Years
>10/10
Soul Love
>9/10
Moonage Daydream
>9/10
Starman
>9/10
It Ain't Easy
>7/10
Lady Stardust
>9/10
Star
>8/10
Hang Onto Yourself
>7/10
Ziggy Stardust
>8/10
Suffragette City
>9/10
Rock 'N' Roll Suicide
>10/10

That makes an 8.6/10. I'd give it a 9/10 and classic status

15 Step
>8/10
Bodysnatchers
>10/10
Nude
>8/10
Weird Fishes/ Arpeggi
>10/10
All I Need
>7/10
Faust Arp
>9/10
Reckoner
>10/10
House of Cards
>7/10
Jigsaw Falling Into Place
>10/10
Videotape
>8/10

That makes an 8.7/10... a light 9 seems fair, amazing set of songs but lacks the dynamism of a true classic

Changes
>9/10
Oh You Pretty Things
>8/10
Eight Line Poem
>6/10
Life On Mars
>10/10
Kooks
>7/10
Quicksand
>10/10
Fill Your Heart
>8/10
Andy Warhol
>8/10
Song for Bob Dylan
>7/10
Queen Bitch
>7/10
Bewlay Brother
>9/10

makes an 8.1, seems about right

based and redalbumpilled

Hello fellow industrial kids

>Lady Stardust
>6/10
Bitch.

Candy Says
>10/10
What Goes On
>9/10
Some Kinda Love
>11/10
Pale Blue Eyes
>10/10
Jesus
>6/10
Beginning to See the Light
>7/10
I'm Set Free
>8/10
That's the Story of My Life
>7/10
The Murder Mystery
>5/10
After Hours
>8/10, 10 with Lou on vocals.

All in all the album loses some steam on its B side that that first half is untouchable.

Attached: VU.jpg (1200x1200, 97K)

It needed to be longer

Song for Soon to Be Sailor
> 10/10
1st Imaginary Symphony by Vacuum Cleaner
> 8/10
Song of the Nomad Lost
> 10/10
"Pulled Out to Sea..."
> 9/10
March of The Father Fists
> 10/10
Nomad Tell Us
> 10/10
Aliens
> 10/10
Song of 100 Castles
> 9/10
What the Single Made the Needle Sing
> 10/10
The Clapping HAnds
> 10/10
Sea's Song for Sailor
> 9/10
The Television Tells Us
> 10/10
An Orchestration's Overture
> 9/10
Song for the Death of Parents
> 10/10
A Warning!
> 9/10
Fanfare for Speeding Bullet
> 10/10
Wishing Well at Capers End
> 10/10

10/10 record, wish it was more well known

Attached: 10_700_700_mrg158.jpg (700x700, 121K)