Scaruffi is never wron-

i have never heard anal collective’s garbage but lmao @ this butthurt

person pitch deserves the 8

youtu.be/1TWbbrZDn9U
Really not that difficult to appreciate if your brain can handle experimental music

>MPP
>6/10
How?

Just compare it to their best work (early work) and it makes sense that he would consider it 6/10, or “buy it if you’re a fan”

Merriweather Post Pavilion (Domino, 2009) continued the trend towards a more conventional (and guitar-less) song format, packaged in a sleek, multi-layered production. The Syd Barrett-ian psychedelic lullaby In The Flowers explodes in a loud merry-go-round of keyboards and percussion: it is neither groundbreaking nor particularly memorable. My Girls is a charming take on minimalist repetition and house music, with raga-like fibrillation juxtaposed against ecstatic chants: neither particularly new nor particularly engaging. Lion in a Coma is an atmospheric and not very melodic song although drenched in a chaos of syncopated percussive sounds and of somewhat clownish electronic timbres. The album dwells in this limbo of fake uncreative creativity. Basically, it's nothing but Phil Spector's "wall of sound" updated to the age in which the studio can do a lot more than an army of musicians. Also Frightened wonders dangerously close to the Beatles of Sgt Pepper, and Bluish sounds like a parody of the Beach Boys. The Animal Collective's personal variation on that stereotype comes from the ritualistic element that is also the common denominator of all the songs.
The one moment of genius is Summertime Clothes, boasting a dislocated hard-rock riff and a panzer techno beat as its rhythmic foundation, and a vaudeville-like rigmarole with a soaring chorus as its leitmotiv. A close second is the jovial Latin-tingued dance of Brothersport that turns into a hypnotic game of vocal harmonies.
Dave Portner (aka Avey Tare) and Noah Lennox (aka Panda Bear) have never sounded more conventional. They have even become predictable. Only the bands of synth-pop have employed so many keyboard sounds to create such simple pop ditties.

MPP was their best work. It pushed popular music and experimental music.

Fucking based

hating Danse Manatee must be a meme at this point, I really don't see how its as bad as people say it is. How is it the same fags that love Spirit somehow hate on this album despite similar sounds and style.

this, its not any more abrasive or noisey than STGSTV, its just a more lush and foresty atmosphere compared to STGSTV's dreamy atmosphere. really the only issue with danse manatee is the vocals are mixed a little too low on some songs, but thats an issue for almost every early anco album

what the hell is his problem?

Attached: 68kw3u.png (642x258, 32K)

only gay white people care about this band or critic

>In The Aeroplane Over The Sea (7.5/10)
>The Glow Pt. 2 (6.5/10)
this fucker really hates phil

Attached: elverum.jpg (948x710, 268K)

>Mount Eerie (7.5/10)
it doesn't matter
he's right that Mount Eerie is better

fucking contrarian pleb

He's a contrarian

He’s actually right

Anyone else notice that he flavors women vocals a little bit?
If your read Scaruffi more you see that he has given lots of 7/10 and 6,5/10(which is above average) to bands you wouldn't even expect

Anyone else notice that he favors women vocals a little bit?
If your read Scaruffi more you see that he has given lots of 7/10 and 6,5/10(which is above average) to bands you wouldn't even expect

is original sin actually that good? he gave it an 8.5/10

Woah this is so cool

Eh, if you like pop opera/rock opera. I think it's another case where he gave it a high score because of he believes it was highly influential to its respective genre rather than the quality of the music itself.

-g, seriously stop worshipping this cuck, Fantano drones receive shit while scarfufi drones suck his cock on a daily basis and it's praised

Predictions
Painting With 5.5
Sleep Cycle 7
Buoys 5
Cows 6.5

>highest ranking is STGSTV
I'd give it a 10, but it's patrician for sure

Go listen to Meet The Light Child again you pleb-ass fool.
Feels doesn't deserve anything below a 6.5, by the way. It's got way too many masterpieces. I think Scaruffi just gave it a bit of a biased rating since it was their turning point into psychedelic indie pop.

Hell yeah, that's one of the goat pop albums. It's relentlessly enjoyable.

Scruffy probably didn't even listen to it.

>mpp pushed experimental music

Reminder that Scaruffi gave Avenged Sevenfold's debut a 7/10 because he's an out of touch geezer

Maybe anco should've made a rock opera.

Attached: Screenshot_2019-03-26-07-43-43~01.png (407x1385, 398K)

who are you quoting?

He's patrician tho

>hE's PaTrIcian thoo

Attached: 1550197216666.png (540x960, 897K)

oh my god i checked and it's true, what a fucking joke lmao

just listened to it, it's pretty good

>gives Royal Trux, Nick Cave, Husker Du, Bob Dylan, AND My Bloody Valentine a 9
>not objectively a patrician
Chvrches thread is two blocks down, homo

Attached: 6i5OadT.jpg (1024x576, 63K)

True, none of them should be higher than a 3.5

Yeah bro Animal Collective is overrated. Santa Claus doesn't exist either. Time to grow up kiddo.

Ride Pitchfork's dick harder

Royal Trux is awful

Twin Infinites is the last rock masterpiece. 40 years of rock and roll, industrial, blues, punk. It's all there. You must be totally ignorant of rock history to dismiss Royal Trux like you just did.

The Beatles' Revolver?
Yeah, a 5/10.

based and redpilled

feels should be higher but everything else seems right

He said it's actually a 6/10 but gave it a 5 to piss off Beatles fans even more.

kek

Attached: deep.png (638x308, 32K)

>not following him

Liking Spirit but not Danse is peak NPC

>mpp pushed popular music