The worst review I've seen

The worst review I've seen

Attached: notmusic.png (796x256, 22K)

Other urls found in this thread:

rateyourmusic.com/collection/smmessner/r5.0
rateyourmusic.com/collection/serialjune/reviews
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

he's right, incel

all sounds can be music if you only want them to be, stop posting on this board

Attached: greatreview.png (817x326, 40K)

if the recordings are unedited and raw, then it's clearly not music
but if they are dubbed over each other or manipulated in any other way then it's music
the more famous nature / field recording albums feature some sort of ambient or spoken word added

Recording the sounds and curating them for an album means they were edited

jesus fuck i want to punch him. most of these are used without looking at their connotations, like he literally just used a thesaurus.

“god i wish i were christgau”

He is completely right

Post modernist freaks are fucking degenerate idiots

Anything contestably called “music” can, depending on what it is going for, be better or worse for being either unedited and raw or for being dubbed/manipulated/etc. This distinction is arbitrary in a universal lens, depending on the context one of these things may be better while in a different context the other thing may be better.

I listened to a minute of one song of this thing in the OP and I could be wrong but it sounds like the latter of what you’re talking about, albeit in a very gradual spontaneous way