The great debate

Well, she's still with them, and her contributions to the band are palpable. So I'd give her a break.

She looks fine to me?

>Critics fucking DESTROYED their first album, and Souvlaki didn't do much better.

I thought they liked Just for a Day and hated Souvlaki because lulling dreampop became passé (was the narrative) (ah, music critics were always hiveminded).

based

Rachel is better looking (and has done a better job of taking care of herself meanwhile Bilinda's hair's always messy while her skin up close doesn't look great either, like get some skincare products you aren't poor)

Rachel's vocal melodies have far more character and range to them as well.

fpbp

I'm pretty sure they hated Just For A Day. Music critics have proven time and time again throughout history that they don't know anything about music lmao

retard

*second post

They know about music, it's just that it's not a science, and the vast majority are more concerned about social status than anything else. Like journalists in general.

yeah but maybe critics back then were not so intertwined with the industry and could recognize an industry plant, hence why they hated them. heck, they even had money to hire Eno to produce one track, I don't think they were doing that bad or had no money
Also, post said demos please
>(and has done a better job of taking care of herself meanwhile Bilinda's hair's always messy while her skin up close doesn't look great either, like get some skincare products you aren't poor)
Of course Bilinda and all of MBV looked like smelly homeless people because they are authentic punk rawk blue collar trash, meanwhile Slowdive were posh kids

youtu.be/g_PgyHngNM0
youtu.be/o1llonb0X8M
youtu.be/66v89y-xzXM
youtu.be/YdUzZ8x39zE
They have two demo tapes from 1989. If you like this sound, check out MBV's "Sunny Sundae Smile" from 1987.
youtu.be/s_dvN7lmZQ0

>authentic punk rawk blue collar trash

That's authentic punk? Could've fooled me. Why were the most acclaimed punks suburbanites LARPing as grimy white trash?

who are they?

uh, that's pretty fascinating, I didn't know they were in a band prior to Slowdive

imagine the smell

Prefer older Neil but still extremely based and redpilled

Attached: 0BD0538C-06C1-4718-9AA7-2E10EB44A1B4.jpg (725x517, 44K)

very based

if you dont know you probs shouldnt be allowed here

are they pop singers?

Bilinda's past doesn't seem too poor. Just more like she got involved with some shitty people through her own choices (e.g. choosing to squat with another dude who was always drugging and having a kid with him.)

his voice is so warm

For me, it's Miki

Attached: miki.jpg (500x725, 233K)

when it hits you ever crybaby twitter thot stole her style O_____O

In terms of music, Bilinda
In terms of qtness, Rachel, I'm not really into Slowdive but she's one of the most beautiful women I've ever seen

>she's one of the most beautiful women I've ever seen
even now?

youtube.com/watch?v=mkQyY7aq_ms

Attached: gettyimages-993324906-612x612.jpg (612x408, 33K)

Still looks good

I saw my bloody valentine once. Bilinda looked liked someone had a gun to her head to make her perform, it was pretty funny she didnt move one bit

So no then

RICH KIDS ON A DAY TRIP

Wow, people age, shocker
Try watching less porn and going outside a bit more

No shit they age. They also tend to lose the "most beautiful women I've ever seen" description unless they're Nigella Lawson

BTFO bilinda fags

isnt bilinda like 10 years older?

fuck off incel

based and triggerpilled

kevin>>>>