One of the worst Pink Floyd albums. Truly brings Waters' pompousness and self importance into the limelight.
One of the worst Pink Floyd albums. Truly brings Waters' pompousness and self importance into the limelight
Leo Torres
Henry Young
If is bad then why is made out of the good noises?
Logan Lopez
Woke album.
Jonathan Anderson
stone
Luis Williams
Agreed. Don't really care for anything after Wish You Were Here honestly.
Lincoln Gonzalez
OFFICIAL PINK FLOYD POWER RANKINGS: REBIRTH EDITION
>NE PLUS ULTRA TIER (Gods among men)
-Saucerful of Secrets
-Ummagumma
-Pompeii
>CONNOISSEUR TIER (Elite)
-Relics
-Atom Heart Mother
-Meddled
-Masters of Rock Vol. 1
>ÜBERMENSCH TIER (A cut above the rest)
-Meddle
-Wish You Were Here
-BBC Archives 1970-1971
>TOURIST TIER (stop kidding yourself and just listen to a different band)
-Dark Side of the Moon
-The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
>UNTERMENSCH TIER (kill yourself)
- The Division Bell
- Obscured by Clouds
- More
- Momentary Lapse of Reason
- Animals
- The Wall
>ROGER WATERS IS A HACK TIER (kill Roger and then kill yourself)
-The Final Cut
Noah Peterson
why is this image in reverse?
Brayden Jackson
The Wall is a bit of a guilty pleasure of mine. Tracks vary from pretty good to laughably inane.
Brandon Long
How is Piper tourist tier? Piper redefined psychedelic music and is one of rock's masterpieces.
Pink Floyd made nothing that good after Saucerful besides Wish You Were Here.
Wyatt Clark
Sorry, when I say "that good" I just mean "pretty good" not "as good as Piper." Nothing in their discography even touches Piper.
Jayden Harris
The guitar solos on dogs are so fucking good tho.
John Wilson
Piper is just poor man's psychedelic pop. You'd have a better time listening to pretty much any other psych-pop band if you claim Piper as your #1. Being super novel (read: gimmicky) at the time of release doesn't give it longevity. Kaleidoscope, Strawberry Alarm Clock, Top Shelf, Zombies, the list literally goes on. You'd have a better time dropping the pretense and just listening to a late 60's garage psych singles comp.
Kevin Smith
>Truly brings Waters' pompousness and self importance into the limelight
you mean Final Cut?
>How is Piper tourist tier? Piper redefined psychedelic music and is one of rock's masterpieces.
sure kiddo. enjoy listening to Bike for the umpteenth time
Leo Sanders
Good list, except is agree with about Piper.
Robert Diaz
"Astronomy Domine" and "Interstellar Overdrive" are psychedelic pop? "Interstellar Overdrive" is one of the most metaphysical, abstract jams of psychedelic rock. Lots of rock at the time was gimmicky, but this album had substance to its gimmicks.
Hudson Walker
Astronomy Domine was done better on Ummagumma and Interstellar Overdrive is one good riff and one good drumroll with a whole lot of wank and gimmickry in between.
>dude it's like sonar pulses
I thought that was cool until I was 17.
Owen White
Julian Diaz
based and REDpilled
David Clark
>take meme made by pol
>put on red hat
this is the power of leftist intellectuals
Isaiah Williams
It’s really not, this album can get pretty boring.
Isaiah Watson
Songs longer than should be legally allowed. Gilmour plays some of his best guitar solos ever. Waters divvys up the human race into Pigs, Dogs and Sheep with a concept album loosely based on Orwell’s Animal Farm. All perfectly bookended by Pigs On The Wing I & II. The coldest trip ever put to music.
One of the few I’d give a 10/10 to.
OP eat a bag of dicks.
Isaac Edwards
They are mentally ill, what do you expect
Zachary Garcia
Commies and /ptg/ redditors fuck off back to your containment board.
Thomas Russell
Not really. The vast majority is dedicated to the music and not the lyricism. The lyrics themselves are fairly general and applicable and deviate from the heavy-handedness of Orwell's allegory.
Jason Foster
All their music is shite. Not one good song
Carter Jackson
Here is the attention you ordered.
Andrew Murphy
>Saucerful of Secrets
>gods among men
Aside from Jugband Blues, the best stuff on Saucerful is done way better on Ummagumma.
Leo Robinson
>being this big of a faggot
Kevin Russell
>Jugband Blues
Found the Sydfag
See Saw is a 100x better song
Carson Wood
Fuck off
Parker Gray
>Kaleidoscope, Strawberry Alarm Clock, Top Shelf, Zombies
Cringe
Aiden Hughes
the 3 bottom ones are the best. In the reverse order