So what’s the official Yea Forums consensus?

Attached: CD17E62F-5C15-4ADF-AFE5-982E25678DF8.jpg (220x220, 14K)

truth

Another 4-5 years once its not quite as well known itll become essential Yea Forumscore

alright, they tried to be The Who

I'm okay with people praising it, but it annoys me how upset people get that I don't like it. I just find it, and everything they did after it, annoying. I like everything they did before it, from their early indie records to Warning.

boring teen pop

Their 90s stuff was better because they weren't trying to make projects beyond their scope. As soon as they started thinking they could make political rock operas as if they're pink floyd, it all started going downhill.

literal 10/10.
boomers need not apply. this was the zeitgeist for the 00s. imagine the beatles/teenage fanclub/sex pistols combined for a power pop masterpiece.
if you can't listen to jesus of suburbia, WMUWSE, whatersname and realize how important and special this album was to people you're a literal brainlet and should stop listening to music.

Attached: 1549051993740.jpg (500x529, 37K)

I bought the CD when I was 12 too but it's still trash. It was only the zeitgeist of the 00's for people who were teens at the time, you are simply assuming your personal nostalgia is representative of that whole time period.

amazing
still like dookie better tho

>HURRRR DURRRRRRR YOU'RE NOSTALGIC ABOUT MUSIC I PERSONALLY DON'T ENJOY XDDDDD THEREFORE IT'S OBJECTIVELY BAD XDDDDD
Kill yourself.

Jesus of Suburbia is a masterpiece, Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Wake Me Up When September Ends are great, but there's just so much filler. I like Homecoming, too, but it's more of a guilty pleasure

Based
There's no filler

>holiday
>whatsername
>give me novacaine
>filler

Attached: 1550816486170.gif (280x211, 1.92M)

based so based
kerplunk is one the best

4/10 wasn't even that good back in the day. I remember being one of those "dude I miss 90s green day remember real music" fags back when I was 10 in 2006 and American Idiot was still cool.

In retrospect not that good because it marks Green Day's shift from poppy skater punk to guyliner hot topic core.

>DUDE CATCHER IN THE RYE BUT WITH MILLENIALS
Fuck off, no one wants to hear a 9 minute song, especially a 9 minute song with a pop punk level of musicianship

Listened to it twice a day when I was 12-15.

Went back and tried to listen to it at 26

Couldn't stand it

Attached: that face.jpg (448x352, 11K)

green day's 90s shit wasnt even that good though desu
they weren't as good as the offspring or blink

OK, get the fuck out of here. That take is horse shit. Blink could never match Dookie. For The Offspring, they turned to shit after Smash. Green Day had Dookie, Insomniac, Nimrod, Warning all great albums.

Attached: PeacefulHollowBaldeagle-max-1mb.gif (500x450, 150K)

Homecoming is unironically better than Jesus of Suburbia.

loved it when I was 12 in 2005 but let's be real it's like 60% as good as dookie and even dookie is only like an 8/10.

>Green Day's shift from poppy skater punk to guyliner hot topic core.
That wasn't Green Day's shift, it was more like a ubiquitous cultural shift.

good

>HURRRR DURRRRRRR YOU'RE NOT NOSTALGIC ABOUT MUSIC I PERSONALLY ENJOY XDDDDD THEREFORE IT'S OBJECTIVELY GOOD XDDDDD
Kill yourself.

cringe

theres only like 5 good songs on it but its still one of the best albums from that generation

The boomers need to shut up. They'll never understand what this album meant when it came out. You really had to be there.