Scaruffi's best songs 1955-1979

>Scaruffi's best songs 1955-1979

>no Comus whatsoever
>ITCOTCK instead of Starless
>Voice of the Turtle instead of Thus Krishna on the Battlefield
>No Beatles or Beach Boys
>Alifib instead of Little Red Riding Hood
>Sister Ray

WTF?

Attached: bestsongs.png (264x680, 40K)

Also:

>no Yes

And:

>no Black Sabbath

These are all basically right.

SUCKIN ON A DING DONG

Where is the Beefheart?

>Sister Ray

I don't understand what he likes so much about Saucerful oft Secrets, can anyone explain?

>that list
this guy's a fucking idiot

>
That album and Trout Mask Replica are what got him into rock music.

yeah, he's not a slave to the opinions of sheep. that's why he's an interesting critic, he has his own genuine opinions that aren't dictated by pr campaigns and publicists paying for BNM like pitchfork. and that's not a 'conspiracy'. friend of mine got BNM once and told me straight up that he didn't want it because somebody paid for it

is there any proof out there that suggests someone has paid for bnm?
i really wanna know if this is true bc that's one more reason to be anti-pitchfork

honestly not a band list for a critic. I mean check any other

War sucks isn't even the best red krayola song. Hurricane fighter plane is better from that album.

i like war sucks because the drums are really hypnotic and intense. almost reminds me of suicide in some weird way
hurricane fighter plane is also amazing though

Third best of all time after A Day in the Life and Like a Rolling Stone

>best of 1955-1979
>28. Sisters of Mercy: Temple of Love (1983)
what a dumb motherfucker

I think Italians on Yea Forums once said that Scaruffi is really nothing special from Italian perspective because most Italian critics and magazines list the same albums as him in their best ever. I noticed that if you filter RYM votes by Italians only there was a suspicious number of Scaruffi's album in top 100 that didn't appear in other countries' lists and Italians said it's not because of Scaruffi, but that it is more evident of what Italians generally like. (and why they like those albums - it's again because some early music magazines promoted them heavily, especially TMR and Beefheart)

>1955-1979
>28. Sisters Of Mercy: Temple Of Love (1983)

It's a fine list but it bothers me how he presents all of his rankings as objective truth.

>Chrome: Zombie Warfare
>not You've Been Duplicated

>I think Italians on Yea Forums once said that Scaruffi is really nothing special from Italian perspective because most Italian critics and magazines list the same albums as him in their best ever. I noticed that if you filter RYM votes by Italians only there was a suspicious number of Scaruffi's album in top 100 that didn't appear in other countries' lists and Italians said it's not because of Scaruffi, but that it is more evident of what Italians generally like. (and why they like those albums - it's again because some early music magazines promoted them heavily, especially TMR and Beefheart)
Do you have any links? Definitely not as fun as thinking of him as some objective minded Patricia .

>I think Italians on Yea Forums once said that Scaruffi is really nothing special from Italian perspective because most Italian critics and magazines list the same albums as him in their best ever. I noticed that if you filter RYM votes by Italians only there was a suspicious number of Scaruffi's album in top 100 that didn't appear in other countries' lists and Italians said it's not because of Scaruffi, but that it is more evident of what Italians generally like. (and why they like those albums - it's again because some early music magazines promoted them heavily, especially TMR and Beefheart)
Interesting, Do you have any links? Definitely not as fun as thinking of him as some objective minded patrician.

>Alifib instead of Little Red Riding Hood
Which one are you talking about? Even though I think they’re both far better than Alifib, one is still superior