Celeb thread

celeb thread

Attached: FromSun_-_Ariel_Winter_-_0042ZWinter.jpg (1280x1600, 369K)

Attached: 1549482875306.webm (640x1136, 1.88M)

Don't make a new thread when the other one is live you cunt

Attached: dove_cameron_with_sabrina_carpenter__by_goddessgg-dcg4ha1.jpg (736x920, 187K)

Attached: Heres another shot from the same.jpg (600x622, 26K)

Attached: {579EC309-C083-4151-BB52-CBFB1355A303}{5C4261E5-3B6D-41BA-B5E7-4B83E4E5E40E}.jpg (100x62, 2K)

some people come here to jerk off instead of chatting about bullshit

Post the hottest celeb feet, I want to rate and wank

Attached: {00202726-F7D2-42A2-AF8D-23512F320204}{3472E579-DF11-4778-B84D-705ADB1072C1}.jpg (74x100, 2K)

Attached: 9b5aa30.jpg (480x662, 93K)

Attached: {713018CE-0285-4E72-B450-88EBE7E201B5}{C9E0BE9F-B4B1-4322-AB1E-34C15991B969}.jpg (74x100, 2K)

Attached: {A97DC826-B34D-4CA4-B5C9-620159C1E68A}{53AFFF8F-B1A5-43A5-92BE-0DB05701C041}.jpg (80x59, 2K)

Attached: {AF84EAA1-F3A2-4B1E-B120-C1329459F3CC}{224FBEB1-D6DB-4B78-AE73-D107100C3177}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: 93211432_0-12.jpg (1920x2881, 635K)

That's why we´re here! To care for each other :)
But what about the wine?
:)

Attached: 947_1000.jpg (1000x703, 78K)

Attached: {C4826F54-CF69-4C81-A857-0E209685C9A9}{A4A578D0-22B7-47DB-B04D-2DC592B090D5}.jpg (125x78, 2K)

how dumb are you?

Attached: BS&frens6.jpg (1080x855, 96K)

other one hit the image limit
this is an image board
but sure whine about it and contribute nothing, thanks for that

Attached: Elizabeth Olsen - VS - Mag -.jpg (800x974, 47K)

Attached: {CABA9193-801E-40D6-A857-51A6D22B3CD1}{1CE89138-F3EA-480D-B475-D7CD59BF9F41}.jpg (59x80, 2K)

Attached: {D8E1EAC5-7899-4A62-B1BD-55C3A61D0CC0}{7BC85705-33BC-4BD8-859A-8F53E65CDEA6}.jpg (56x80, 1K)

Attached: 1535325920205.jpg (3840x5760, 1.08M)

Attached: {D577C3EF-CAAC-49EC-A8B8-374F47DC2DDD}{0CDF325F-6957-408A-AF4A-5D53CF72480C}.jpg (80x49, 1K)

Attached: 1492397444365.jpg (1930x3000, 718K)

Attached: {D505329F-A71F-4173-A51C-138D80CA47E4}{855A6EC1-4B7E-46A5-A6AB-236BEC388F0B}.jpg (100x74, 2K)

Brighton ?

Attached: {DF35A2FB-E2B0-4A03-88CC-6B9014027150}{53230158-4F8F-41E8-90AD-1C6CE0185772}.jpg (137x159, 3K)

That's why I'm here, nig

Attached: {EE5516DA-25DE-45D5-A843-3E32212A865B}{A934D7AC-B88D-4853-8642-B2C8DAD6EFA4}.jpg (80x59, 1K)

Attached: ariel-winter-sexy-dress-1.jpg (567x563, 27K)

Attached: {F1DAC4AE-F6DD-4990-87EB-13D07B3F6F7B}{91B04A4A-58A3-42FA-B9EF-68F3E422B462}.jpg (74x100, 3K)

Attached: POlBP2O.jpg (2257x3000, 954K)

Attached: {4B022260-28BE-4AE0-ABB1-47B054D6DF56}{6384E7A0-5976-4D26-9967-2722E8ADEE90}.jpg (125x78, 1K)

Attached: {712ED08E-3112-4006-A8F2-EEFDF3E9BFFB}{18BEBF3F-6983-4303-9C69-E1C6F72392EE}.jpg (70x125, 2K)

Maybe deal with the sad nonce posting dick pics...

Attached: {A4EB53CC-EC5E-4A95-B92C-3D4A2AB42874}{A3881E31-27D1-4514-9937-0B03CC8C1E95}.jpg (93x125, 1K)

ye ye my guy

Attached: BSwWS.jpg (1080x1267, 132K)

Attached: {96BF3C81-5FE1-4824-AF24-00BA314AC085}{1B3BDECA-5C2E-48DA-A9C0-CC3417146F02}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {78C0B73E-701A-4859-814A-47B62D0866C5}{C36DFD82-182B-4747-A07B-CB5448574804}.jpg (215x249, 3K)

Attached: {C7567885-291F-47AF-9A4A-5A7F17EEB639}{E17BDD0F-D246-4677-AC51-35132168A14F}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: Elizabeth Olsen from the New.jpg (600x616, 44K)

Attached: 1529307963793x.jpg (1092x1477, 359K)

Attached: {F74A798F-B466-4059-98E9-51FB7C7DEF27}{7B652BBA-F9CE-427A-AF0F-028AE2AB9F48}.jpg (125x93, 1K)

Attached: {3FBD81FA-93D6-4360-AE9E-F90CB1F06766}{46493FB9-5D6F-4A2C-8A1B-9D1FA0AF3F83}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {1E5CC960-66F7-4512-B707-A8101495F387}{E933F70E-89A4-429B-85F7-EE56310E95DF}.jpg (70x124, 1K)

Attached: chloe grace moretz d87ff3908133414.jpg (1417x1536, 804K)

Attached: {51F6E31F-788E-4C9F-8480-696BA6BA8257}{063C992D-EE66-4B17-BF27-422383C0797F}.jpg (124x117, 2K)

Attached: 89384442_awi-59.jpg (1080x1920, 181K)

Attached: {2B1D56B6-1E93-4B6D-B398-639E24CC3129}{95FD3BC4-0EF7-4F3B-B244-E7B2C5B19600}.jpg (93x125, 1K)

Attached: Elizabeth Olsen (i.imgur.com ) (2).jpg (2207x3000, 1.2M)

Attached: {4A2CEEC5-E0A9-4F78-B0A6-18D6C769D9C5}{A50F7FE5-82D3-4E44-B5F8-DCD919715B63}.jpg (70x124, 1K)

i need her and her tummy

Attached: {549123AA-4D38-426B-B119-21907108703E}{6A921505-8369-4579-B004-9153F5B33C94}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {D8B0917A-FF54-4FFB-A60F-107AA2684943}{7AA5121A-98F4-4730-BC32-05056EBDCEF3}.jpg (74x125, 2K)

Attached: {A911E35C-BB6C-4E58-BC49-850A989E2827}{BAB3667F-592C-487F-B650-3DDD483C858C}.jpg (95x125, 2K)

Attached: {B51E8C32-D674-4CC9-8A36-D693E3DAA951}{F251955D-7EBB-40D9-B13D-9A86FFC7F19F}.jpg (125x85, 1K)

Attached: Elizabeth Olsen (i.imgur.com ) (5).jpg (800x1200, 314K)

I told her to stop calling me coachella...

Attached: {BBEE4F6B-C6FA-44DD-8071-7A6320DF5AEC}{3CC843F7-2807-4AC9-8D2E-CD78C077EEB6}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

I guess, all things considered, deep down BD is a good guy. Reminding me why i don't come here that often anymore and everything

Attached: 52326578_255642652023650_2660919344213190142_n.jpg (640x1137, 59K)

Attached: {5AA4E69D-8CC7-4B0C-A6DC-ACDE6B7E8856}{0B98895D-19AE-425A-B45B-4342BA6C1997}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

Attached: {20AA41F2-48BB-40F9-9A7D-1F55CC34F394}{1DF778D6-A1F7-4DBE-A5C0-C7BBF5C55F09}.jpg (70x125, 2K)

Attached: {BECB196D-706E-453A-A585-95C2B8DDEDDE}{3B4A3062-1593-4AAD-8B43-E57B2FD6E1FB}.jpg (70x125, 2K)

Attached: {B7D2EDAF-1106-40A3-A0FE-FF740BC35EAD}{EB01024E-AF76-420A-85FF-E926DDD147D8}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {EEE2E4E4-E346-4C0A-B752-A34D5F8E863A}{21EE2ED2-EBD8-40A6-99BD-E43308CAEF59}.jpg (125x70, 1K)

Attached: {E92B0502-BA8A-45BD-B25C-DFD6BA0BCF0C}{10146DBB-8779-4A8F-BB7E-550C991D1682}.jpg (96x125, 2K)

Attached: {E42BE260-02FB-4652-9F0F-51157CDF58AF}{E1122E8E-B477-49AF-8FF2-B7692B704AF2}.jpg (64x125, 2K)

Attached: {C4D0C8DB-C4DD-4F85-AA26-0A08A36E0E51}{D0CFAE25-5BDE-47AC-A385-824B31AC5EEF}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

Srry user :(

Attached: 484744u474645.gif (202x206, 950K)

Attached: {FD6535B6-0F9A-4CB2-8D92-B38F8ACF13D3}{E450910D-18C6-4EA3-B35D-7CE6B8DACC39}.jpg (70x125, 1K)

Attached: {4B381A6D-5AF0-4944-ABB0-DAFB6FF12658}{C31B871E-DB3E-421B-AB9B-057293A9C561}.jpg (71x125, 2K)

we share those feels

Attached: BSbdf6.jpg (1080x1332, 145K)

Attached: {2BC607EF-B4B3-4E6B-A045-8970FD909B54}{C145CBAA-EEFE-420A-901D-C3CA1FBDA2BB}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {4407C4AA-D342-427E-A696-3B0918F5DCBD}{DAE67FC9-77BE-4495-8ACE-AB6A3E480BCF}.jpg (109x125, 2K)

Attached: britney spears cute.jpg (560x804, 68K)

Attached: {4064A9AD-0EFC-45FB-A387-3729ECB56769}{931454B1-F501-438F-8C09-E9E3E2969912}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: Dove+Cameron+Nickelodeon+2016+Kids+Choice+T4scot4CF2Jx.jpg (681x1024, 216K)

Attached: {0EABD700-2AC6-488C-B9FF-90DC8F79BF36}{7C8A4A5C-C4C2-4016-8000-76891A4094DF}.jpg (70x125, 2K)

Attached: {FEE44389-40C2-4675-9E94-10E20FA45028}{A2609696-5439-4851-90BE-C6607B1497B2}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

kek. noice

Attached: JJdatazzwalk.webm (404x720, 1.46M)

Attached: {37670EF7-6F6E-4168-BAC9-D9A74981B1C7}{FB4021F8-CBC8-446D-8F9F-7BCA42B0EAB3}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {5BDDE3DA-95FB-4A6E-A00E-827C0F7EE01D}{ABB0FAFD-580A-476C-8164-2BA8C9365197}.jpg (125x70, 1K)

Yeah, this is fucking ridiculous. Ill be back some other time. cya anons.

Attached: 2zbkrcvj8va21.jpg (1080x1349, 216K)

Attached: {31F80949-5005-4B7E-ABB0-E3C3061DC101}{4F56636A-CD75-4A77-A4A2-8F634E183EDB}.jpg (107x125, 2K)

Attached: {0708B485-270B-4193-8D91-8E2354AFF209}{743E94A5-2F22-4123-951B-AB49009A9C01}.jpg (125x88, 1K)

Attached: {DCD936F1-A200-402C-99CB-3C0691A364EA}{00641938-ED40-4E79-A591-6F43D35CFCD7}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

Attached: {D3087D15-2B1D-4982-AC36-2FA3B65B7303}{ED3C1FAF-A94B-4FE4-BA69-69791396A59E}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

Attached: {74CC41DF-09DC-4CF1-829B-B36960BB56B7}{BE692075-8AB2-4276-9940-2778DEF4EF03}.jpg (95x125, 2K)

Yes we do.

Attached: {DBF9DEAB-FCF1-49CC-B5DA-CF4C13FAD6F4}{21398E0A-6ECE-4AB9-B1CF-7434FF7B41D0}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

Attached: {592E97AA-D643-4B73-AA61-E184C5943827}{47FFFB8F-9415-4D2F-B706-BA2AD0B8F0D0}.jpg (62x125, 1K)

see you friend
;_;7

Attached: LRDsopurdy3.jpg (828x1470, 106K)

Attached: {E5A6A809-4FB3-42D3-A188-D9856198A72E}{3FEBF7AA-895B-413B-A006-186A87D9D28C}.jpg (62x125, 1K)

Attached: {3A902993-A909-495D-A282-9E51AEE2187D}{7ED1614C-B27D-4C98-A55C-69EA21337271}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

she sure is pretty huh

Attached: cameron diaz.jpg (1200x1692, 907K)

Attached: {546F58A8-D1F0-4370-9CA8-9D8656C6F9A2}{8FC39164-FCB5-48DE-8154-77A32EFE3444}.jpg (62x125, 1K)

Attached: {9506F40C-2E18-4F37-A1B9-4B67DDE2789F}{6428A643-0CD6-4514-816E-A819310A6536}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

Attached: {5075ACCC-4647-4D2B-ADB3-23DE1E9A4612}{C4087736-C883-42DC-B1BC-B6D56E82352F}.jpg (67x125, 2K)

*big hug*

Attached: BScomfyqt2.jpg (1080x810, 52K)

Attached: {4344F541-8004-4F03-B455-902B894FFC90}{3FDD7434-7C08-44A4-8C2A-946227B87200}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {26A90D8A-38CB-4E9B-A4D3-EF15C9853D1F}{70176F71-06FE-4785-A26A-EBD6A90B4891}.jpg (70x125, 1K)

Attached: {120D655E-E67F-401C-9ECD-AC1C8074757B}{F3ED41E2-98A8-4111-86FD-953BE4B7FCAD}.jpg (125x93, 1K)

Attached: {54E376F1-5976-4B50-9E84-299900E65569}{034304D7-9927-4909-86B7-F485784DCD9F}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {2A48542C-471E-4CA1-AD9F-E58BA1518641}{208FA16E-C2DF-4940-95E4-867322746ED3}.jpg (110x124, 2K)

Attached: {241A87A8-0CE4-4231-9068-F3BA989D34D2}{7804A6DA-D1FB-49DC-B8E0-9A3EAD3D8924}.jpg (70x125, 2K)

Attached: {D720D575-2C93-4004-863F-94F04983215D}{EBA8B2A2-BA55-48FE-9051-0B7D88A9B755}.jpg (125x125, 2K)

Attached: {617E47CD-4FFF-4E07-863A-E5812A124FBA}{FD7A455D-3412-4FBC-B8F3-E5BFF4E8A48E}.jpg (70x125, 2K)

Attached: {3E5811AB-8AC1-4145-8866-9BE87E9C4295}{6DEBE842-6F63-411E-9799-4B282094C374}.jpg (125x70, 2K)

Attached: emma dumont 1537387840608.jpg (1080x1140, 107K)

Attached: {3A892BAF-484A-4546-AA39-DCF7434387D1}{8F8C5959-DAF6-4086-8806-5AF52211820B}.jpg (70x125, 1K)

Attached: {05F883F2-11C4-462B-A3C2-66F60D5346F0}{2AB5FC8A-0C1A-4E3F-B0BE-299A7EB5B22C}.jpg (125x95, 2K)

Attached: {82B59018-563F-40CA-B9CE-F8837124C896}{05D01E5C-4EEC-4B0E-BAEC-09D69FD03341}.jpg (125x125, 2K)

new ass shot of miss winter the sexy slut

just an FYI, im 85% sure this is not brainless douche spamming now, it's discordkid

Attached: ¥.jpg (2560x1920, 834K)

Attached: {48F57D00-CB09-457A-85E7-218038989AE2}{050AF4B9-F952-4498-9165-69D64754AF31}.jpg (250x187, 6K)

Attached: {99DFC03B-A800-464B-BE1E-A91B7BE3683B}{4B8C9753-B8A0-4F72-B67A-A57CFFA2FB7B}.jpg (70x125, 2K)

Attached: {97B1F346-B6A3-4FAE-9195-6C1E27DFE481}{A6DDC536-66B9-49E1-82DC-AD28F1C5E36B}.jpg (70x125, 2K)

Attached: {CF08D3CE-BA07-496D-966A-84EEA75CF9A5}{ACD2F944-E4DF-4EA4-BFDB-999FBF984F5F}.jpg (70x124, 1K)

Attached: {91CAC030-5A62-4E85-A44C-C2A77EDFDB56}{911777A0-E82B-4F6B-9C77-7CAE9F098493}.jpg (83x125, 2K)

Attached: joanna krupa topless (1).jpg (933x1000, 84K)

I'd like to fuck her in that position tbh

Attached: 2F0.jpg (1080x1250, 304K)

Attached: {DA882C71-A101-4ACE-A88C-F6C7799AF213}{8AD1918F-5945-4AC3-A422-E0750E0C07B4}.jpg (90x125, 2K)

Attached: {917DCE0E-4431-4EA0-A283-4DC1EBE9402A}{31FE8536-95A4-4344-A612-381E6F8E3D14}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

Attached: {D853CC94-4850-4C60-8CED-BCB7301BE8E1}{A3127376-510A-4CD6-AC69-896333791E1A}.jpg (93x125, 1K)

Attached: {168A1157-6F4D-47B1-9E36-0129656A49EF}{6665F19C-5DCC-4FF8-832F-401027DAC4EC}.jpg (70x125, 1K)

Attached: {76FB8C92-495D-4701-BD68-0EB1BBD1F6F5}{3148EC6F-772B-4F91-BFA8-479EB3410167}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

Attached: {992AD62B-767B-42CD-A06F-C37711C25D47}{8A09A53A-6511-4187-9E56-6538572E2C23}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

Attached: {0ED73E47-6451-447F-9271-089FC113B04F}{87111EAB-88AB-49DA-808B-BDAFC743ACB6}.jpg (125x125, 2K)

Selling my private snapchat (daily nudes and videos).

$30/mo
$60/3 months
$100/lifetime

I also do video calls, $50/30 min

Add me for a preview @mandycross22

Attached: {9D56803B-6018-4026-B761-E0DA2F490BE8}{DC792DD2-0DF9-4315-A3E2-D18B6312F144}.jpg (97x124, 2K)

Did she got fat nice

Attached: {F309093A-7DE1-493C-BDC1-CA5830EA23E3}{1C7CE41D-636A-4803-B0D3-CEF24E23E917}.jpg (106x124, 2K)

Attached: {D26F7A33-F3D8-4158-AFE6-D3705E35408C}{9B6A769D-18D5-4277-A568-E6880528AE20}.jpg (86x125, 1K)

Attached: {A0AAA8DB-A3BF-46E6-926F-3A43608F6D4A}{D1815ED3-B41E-4F47-84B6-B28723ED435A}.jpg (125x93, 1K)

Attached: {4060F2BE-D966-4430-AF81-0E6B3FE7A66F}{DF0C2B02-780A-45FD-A800-43D245FDB14D}.jpg (107x125, 2K)

Attached: {F35F059F-317B-40C5-92FC-7BA11153DC99}{4869EC87-7EE6-4E0D-9681-7FE86D99A9CA}.jpg (125x122, 3K)

Attached: rowan 1530418781604.jpg (2835x4252, 1.74M)

Attached: {ADB4C2F5-84D9-4D87-AEA6-872DA66709EA}{C9775C4F-7474-4177-A0F0-72B149E6176D}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {81D2C588-8D26-47EC-9BBF-65BE2CC32B8B}{D07B552D-7F53-4791-BD9B-422755ECECE9}.jpg (125x101, 2K)

Attached: {4E13FA5C-D4DC-4BAB-A342-ECB0807E346C}{35F4C893-6CFD-436E-8A79-788D8FF7D870}.jpg (125x108, 2K)

Attached: {221ADA86-E38B-4673-B722-3CA788D50A10}{7DA72D45-9417-4304-8B29-52FA5435A559}.jpg (125x93, 1K)

Attached: {687BB379-469F-408F-987E-A566A73960C3}{A5FFC8C0-B0FF-4FD2-992E-91DAB7EA9EF7}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {6D7AED31-3EC9-4544-81D4-19B035BB8E7B}{969A30CC-668B-4E8B-8E03-1FAB934E3C0D}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {93BA4C20-3DD8-4ACD-8B3B-C448688ABD9B}{5AE2E040-7A61-49DE-9679-ACF3A8F9004D}.jpg (125x122, 2K)

Attached: {AE91DB7C-82A5-41AF-86EF-A5433C76888F}{44679208-65F7-4889-8F02-110A5B59DF19}.jpg (51x124, 1K)

called it :)

Attached: £.jpg (2000x3000, 642K)

Attached: {624D1CDC-4420-4179-999B-8C44FD87CC53}{54F4EC1B-6474-47CE-BDFE-E6D24EE8EF53}.jpg (70x125, 1K)

Attached: {8A4152FD-43F1-41CA-961E-9F6A7D272714}{4BC67D62-2B29-472C-8EB3-93963463A591}.jpg (93x125, 1K)

Attached: {E485E9FC-ADC1-4419-9342-070FE612BB24}{320AED88-DFB1-461A-8F8B-5BCE0D33EA1E}.jpg (89x125, 1K)

Attached: {258A2C23-8E97-441D-8F05-7642C148B0D8}{757394D0-2E2D-450D-B26C-EE9E6C884039}.jpg (250x187, 4K)

Attached: {5579C7C8-3B8A-4B1B-8C63-16F2093AC35B}{91E99AC2-98F6-42F1-B10F-BA8E892734FB}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {E93A1590-C3B9-49E2-8A33-DC340B36DF83}{C4A6DA9C-A6E6-4497-9E6F-933DA36599C4}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

Attached: {91286289-4E25-4A86-BAFD-EE6F7DDBC25F}{C2567540-7BE7-4100-9550-ED1575749610}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: {CD005181-17AA-4004-98C7-89A96A7BF92B}{075B460B-0C84-424E-AA2F-B409443210CC}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: sabrina carpenter_BjVn52uAc0t.jpg (1080x1350, 773K)

Attached: {A18D92EA-CF77-4E0F-845E-6D03188D652E}{D00BFB9A-D909-4311-9EA3-E98469C2F93F}.jpg (125x67, 1K)

Weirdo...

Attached: {EF9D568A-111D-4036-8B8B-2443C8B9DF00}{FFE4170A-4F5E-40E9-B191-275A7FD2A0E8}.jpg (76x125, 2K)

Attached: {5B3869CA-F698-41F9-BD59-B2B45CB7931B}{1F0B4BB2-BB24-4AD7-B93F-B631A2F08CB1}.jpg (125x93, 2K)

Attached: kendall jenner.jpg (1365x2048, 314K)

Attached: {24660018-5551-4CDB-A9B9-5456458BFE17}{851213A6-92AA-4770-8087-FA95B106F6E4}.jpg (85x124, 2K)

Attached: {20C86437-11C7-42F3-8032-E297F06B7889}{AD10BC5C-7A2B-44D7-A706-B998C766CB69}.jpg (70x125, 1K)

Attached: {67630BB5-0AF1-459C-AEB3-031882B57C0D}{4B21D98D-885D-48A2-95DD-6C8528E29468}.jpg (70x125, 2K)

Fuck you man with the 2kb pics

Attached: {947A63D3-29DD-4A7C-A97C-31ED3D3CBB58}{D1C9CE22-ED98-4185-856E-6109ABF66385}.jpg (125x98, 3K)

Attached: {39C636BA-7666-40AF-A898-061B76A58CD0}{6C653A20-A17C-4438-885A-BE83741CD639}.jpg (93x125, 2K)

did you fail a job interview again my retarded friend?

Attached: €.jpg (2100x3150, 914K)

kek

Who is this supposed to be?