5 STARS
Seethe Reelins BTFO!
Based Mox.
Night 5
>Archer vs. KENTA: 3.5
>EVIL vs. SANADA: 4.25
>Fale vs. Okada: 2.75
>Sabre vs. Tanahashi: 4.5
>Ibushi vs. Ospreay: 5
Night 6
>Taichi vs. Takagi: 4
>Cobb vs. Robinson: 3.5
>White vs. Yano: 2.5
>Goto vs. Naito: 3.75
>Ishii vs. Moxley: 5
Night 7
>Fale vs. Sabre: 2.5
>Archer vs. Tanahashi: 3.5
>EVIL vs. KENTA: 4
>ibushi vs. SANADA: 4.5
>Okada vs. Ospreay: 5.75
Night 8
>Robinson vs. Yano: 2
>Goto vs. Taichi: 2.75
>Moxley vs. Takagi: 4.25
>Cobb vs. White: 1.75
>Ishii vs. Naito: 4.5
4.25 at most. It was good by Moxley standards but below average for an Ishii singles match
A P O L O G I Z E
>4.25 at most
for you, faggot
according to big dick meltz it was the full 5
seethe with it.
holy fucking based
I still won't watch a single match of his so I don't care LMAO!
This will from now on be called the "Kenny Omega syndrome"
Fighting better workers in Japan to get better star ratings from big dick dave
Seth was a better wrestler than dean. This proves if Tyler black went to njpw he'd prob get 6 stars.
All this proves is go to Japan get higher ratings
Worked lmao
Unironically probably my favorite match from this G1, Ishii and Mox basically do the same shit so they meshed fucking perfectly.
ALL THIS E-DRONE COPE
Yummy
SEETHING AND COPING HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
>Has a better match average after 3 months in the outlaws than Seth has managed in 5 years in WWE
Kek
>Archer vs. Tanahashi: 3.5
>EVIL vs. KENTA: 4
Did this faggot not listen to the crowd. they loved everything Archer and Tanahashi did and didn't give a fuck about Kenta match
Why does Dave hate Taichi so much?
Taichi is into nazi memorabilia and is very racist
Nazi memorabilia is a big thing in japan
You legit all said dean was the worse shield member. If he can get 5 stars because he's in Japan you just validated what we already know.
Roman is far better than dean. He would prob get 6 stars with okada easily.
EVIL vs KENTA was a very good match and everyone saytng otherwise is probably a purofaggot seething at Kenta permanently
Seth is a spot monkey. I've been saying for a while that around his feud with Miz/Ziggler, he entered an incredibly routine like mindset. When he goes in to spot monkey mode it's incredibly obvious and it's hard to unsee, really ruins his matches and he thinks this is beneficial even though he's getting slated for it online.
Both were good. You weren't paying attention in that KENTA match, he was getting a negative reaction and feeding off it if anything. It's sorta perfect heading into the Okada match desu. He has the aura of an outsider.
He was the worst in the ring because wwmeme is a pussyfied fed for little kids with autism and down syndrome like you where all wrestlers wrestle one pussy style. Now in AEW and NJPW He can finally brawl and throw shit around like always wanted and is best at
Deans wacky clothesline was the same shit. He did the most matches in 2016 for that reason alone.
I didn't think it was possible, but you Kike Meltzer redditors have made this board worse
Miss me with ALL DIS COPE
Exactly and if Roman or Seth went to Japan he'd be allowed to be better. Same with Hogan.
C O P E
C O P E
Dean improved from 2017, Seth has deteriorated
Ambrose was actually trained as a real wrestler, Seth had some of the worst ring psychology in wrestling as Tyler Black and it hasn't gotten any better in WWE. He would have decent matches, but not a single one would be as memorable or as good as Mox/Ishii.
BASED, E-Drones btfo
EVIL vs KENTA was good, but it was good because of EVIL. KENTA is getting hard carried through this G1.
Cope why? I'm going off what happened.
No he didn't. Seth regressed because muh knee because he's trying to stay healthy.
Mox was literally a spot monkey czw reject
Yep they turned this place into /wew/.
God you faggots are really in a permanent seethe state at him,
>Okay it was good, but it wasnt good because of him!
How does that matter in this star rating shit? It doesn't, both wrestlers get one rating based on what they did together. Now fuck off back to twitter
You haven't even seen his best match
Mox used to do 60 minute matches calling everything in the ring. He knows wrestling better than Seff ever will.
Better than /wwe/.
>Mox is a bad wrestler in 2019 because he was a spot monkey in 2011
???
>vanilla midget fan
Ok you redditors aren't even hiding anymore kys
Everything someone does in a WWE ring is because that's what they are told to do. Seth is shit now, and Dean was even worse shit in WWE.
If Moxley can be as good as he is with freedom, then Seth, who was better while they were both in the same environment before, would also be better in NJPW than Moxley. That's his reasoning.
>SC userbase
>~500k users
>Yea Forums userbase
>like 100 people probably
Know your place you filthy trash
Not enough tarps for ya?
>R-reddit! Reddit!
Oh no no no no no
You didn't say this when he was in wwe. You all said he was the worst of the 3. Stop lying because he made aew relevant.
He was a spot monkey in 2016
Have sex
BUT MUH REDDIT
AHAHAHAHA
>All this seething
Good job on using past tense.
>H-have s-sex
PFFT AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA, THIS NIGGA BOILIN!!!
unironically boiling
Keep up brainlet
Dean < Seth < mox
>Yea Forumsie seething cause big dimes reddit is here to save the day with good threads
not enough e-drone circlejerking for ya?
>no counter argument
>No counter argument
What's the counter argument to "Haa..ve! S..ex!"
>gets BTFO
>r...Reddit
Lmao
this isn't fuckin' CNN dork, we're not debating.
>wojak
Having sex
>Look mom I said it again so it's true!!
Worked
>Ospreay vs Ibushi 5 stars
Dave has lost it. It was a worse match than the Dome one and he didnt rated that one 5 stars.
Fuck that, this board is for shitposts about wrestling. Doesn't matter who or what its for or against. You people come here with your essays and unironic discussions on fucking ratings and ruin the entire purpose of the place for the pre existing community.
>for the pre existing community
The pre-existing community would kindly want you wrestlefaggots to fuck off
Tyler Black was cringe and always will be cringe.
Based skatechad
Based
Meltzer's bias is nauseating. WWE has better matches than that on fucking Smackdown.
Neither Ishii or Mox have a discernible gimmick, the match had no fucking story, and barely anyone was there to see it.
But oh sure, 5 stars. Gotcha.
go ride a bike, bitch
S E E T H I N G
L M A O
Can you guys stop. Not all aew fans are like this. You're just false flagging to make us look bad.
i was gonna go line by line and explain why you are wrong. But you don't fucking know what korakuen hall is. it's like top 5 famous wrestling arenas. fucking state of you mate
Im all for using stars as a way to shitpost but you niggers really dont value that kikes opinion that much, do you?
I am pronjpw but that top 5 shit is factually wrong. Why dont you tell me the other four and maybe i will give you the hall as 5.
Please niggas, tell me what the hell happened in a couple of months? I haven't watched any wrestling since kofi became champ. What should I catch up with?
So what, Taichi hates kikes?
They do. They worship that faggot and need him to tell them what they should or shouldn't like
>Cobb vs. White: 1.75
OH NO NO NO
Thank you Ishii for hiding the fact that i'm a mediocre wrestler with the agility of a tree
>Ishii vs. Naito: 4.5
>Ishii vs. Moxley: 5
AEW BONUS
Seethe Rollins on suicide watch
He should stay in NJPW, going AEW up against AEW shitters will just be embarrassing
i loved it
jasethy gonna be seething seeing mox got a 5 star before him
>full 5
>when he rates out of 7
basically the guy saying it was 4.25 is actually closer to what it would be if we're using the 5 star system
If Roman and Seth wanted to be better they would fucking leave, but they don't. So there's no point here. Dean's better simply because he took the risk to do it and you can hypothesize all you want but in the end Roman and Seth will still be fucking around in months long programs with the same old opponents with the same old storylines the same old bullshit, and the same old tarps (or curtains). If that's what they want to do good on them but they'll never be doing hype shit like the G1.
The Jew fears the samourai.
What gets me is the Okada Ospreay, 5.75? I really liked the match and Okada is my favorite but come on.
If Moxley vs Ishii was 5 stars Okada vs Ospreay deserved 6 at least,fuck that dunce.
moxley carried ishii ya simp
based chair battle
>You carry me? I carry YOU!
Sorry guys I just gave Seth/Bex vs Corbin/Lacey 7.5 stars, better luck next time.
no one cares about your opinion, colby
Imagine having this level of delusion,Shingo yesterday also carried him to a four star match by selling his leg the entire time.
americans are better than japs at wrestling
Carried
It's okay, maybe one day your guys can carry out a match worthy of my very well-researched and completely objective ratings
Reddit went over, the thread
Is that why American wrestling is dying?
Might want to check the stock price, the saudi deal and the tv revenue figures there chief ;)
I mean it was really great but a perfect match? Nah.
I'm talking about the American interest in wrestling,WWE went global because they knew that their product would eventually suck so hard that the people from their home country would lose interest,poo in loos for example don't have standards and will pay regardless of quality.
5 stars is not perfect,Okada/Ospreay got 5.75.
Dont you have some tickets to sell in america? Oh wait, njpw cant sell out, just like wwmeme
They already sold out before,inb4 they needed le Omemega.
And they sold how many tickets last time,5000? That's more tickets that the average RAW or Smackdown and they didn't even pay for the arena.
Dave is crazy generous. Does he just have low standards?
Dave is crazy generous with AEW employees
>he says American wrestling is dying
>you respond with a company struggling to sell tickets in America
Brainlet move honestly
desu the only match I'd give 5 would be Okada vs Ospreay but whatever Dave's gonna shill
Wrestling is dying in America.
>>Ibushi vs. Ospreay: 5
>>Okada vs. Ospreay: 5.75
I thought these would be reverse becaue Dave falls for the match length/bumps meme
Holy shit he might actually have taste
I preferred Shingo Vs Mockoosley, but whatever. Seethe Boillins BTFO
I see from Youtube Indians are making the switch to AEW and even a few to NJPW lol, and some are shitting on WWE.
AEW will bring it back
>AEW will bring it back
Based Chad Mox making virgins seethe.
KENTA is the only one unironically deserving of 5 stars because he is the best wrestler on that roster. But of course semen slurpers gonna semen slurping
>believing what Jews tell you
Cope. Seethe.
Ever get through your tiny cum brain that people might listen to him the same way people like to listen to Cornette? Less personal validation and more wanting to hear a perspective? Not everything needs to be a fucking echo chamber you dorks. I can disagree with Dave sometimes but I still like hearing him talk about a match.
OMG DID YOU HEAR DEAN AMBROSE VERSUS NARUTO GOT 5 STARS???!!!!!
If Dean Ambrose and Seth Rolins had the same exact match Meltzer Magoo rates it 3.75 maybe 4
God I love her.
It's literally impossible for Seethe to work an Ishii match
Seethe is going to kill himself by this point next year
Mox confirmed better than Daniel Bryan. Bryanincels SEETHING
I was being half ironic,only half because they still have to start their TV shows and i want to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Kek based big choppa pump
I like Moxley's character but his in-ring skills are very lacking. His offense is slow and lacks impact.
yes, you should have realised this by now. he's not reliable anymore when it comes to ratings
Fag
SETH ON SUICIDE WATCH!
The CHADblade is a good heel that Meltzer hates him and marks down his matches
>Ishii vs Mox = 5 stars
>BBDRR vs Brock Lesnar vs Joe vs Braun = 4.75
>Seth Rollins = 0 stars
Bazed
Jesus you don't pay attention do you?
C O P E harder jasethy
Cobb, what a bitch
He had fucking AJ Styles in front of him twice and didn't do shit. If anything this proves either he's fucking shit or WWE is a fucking shit company.
>Seth was a better wrestler than dean. This proves if Tyler black went to njpw he'd prob get 6 stars.
>All this proves is go to Japan get higher ratings
>THE STATE OF ROLLNETTY
BTFO
You are unironically correct though. It is impossible to put on an organically good match in WWE in any way unless you have more sway than vince somehow.
I don't think WWE gives enough time to wrestlers to put on great matches,not even in PPVs.
They are also scared of people injuries so they can't let them have matches with a high workrate.
Mox vs Ishii deserves it for standing out. Favorite match of the G1, which has been good but not blown me away despite the incredible talent in it so far.
Dude... And I use to respect this guy back in mid-late 00's.
In The Shield's debut match the very first thing Dean did was go right for Bryan. It was a kino callback.
This guy is a ridiculous person. Why does anyone respect or listen to him? Anyone can have a fucking podcast and make up fake news and give out silly inconsistent ratings about something. He's less valuable to pro wrestling than Maffew.
based dean
Based Jon
>Dean
>Never won a 5 star match in the entirety of his wrestling career
>gets one in the first month of setting foot in Japan
Weeb smarks are the biggest fanboys in wrestling.
Name a better Dean match than Mox/Ishii
The Ishii effect brother
I don't understand how he comes up with these scores, but I also don't care because they don't matter.
Kek what a bitch
Shut the fuck up, Jasethy
Dean/Trips