After putting on another five-star classic at last night's TakeOver PPV...

After putting on another five-star classic at last night's TakeOver PPV, does Johnny Wrestling have a legitimate claim to being the greatest wrestler of all time? At least the greatest to wrestle for the WWE?

Attached: 20170802_JohnnyGargano--c659f4936892cb276f2bfde54f7269d1[1].jpg (1200x675, 69K)

I heard it was a real thigh-slapper

He wasn't even the best wrestler in his match. This guy is so overrated, good lord.

Five stars? I thought it was five kickouts

yea homeboys's up there cuz off top the matches he be workin rn are off the ding-dong diddly hinges.

he's no Naruto Sasuke

>implying Meltzer stars mean jack shit to anyone but a handful of incels
Money and miles, marks. Only a retard would think Gargano ranks above guys like Andre, Hogan, Rock... only a retard.

>He wasn't even the best wrestler in his match.
He's definitely overrated, but he's way better than generic ass Cole.

Certainly one of the best WWE has ever had to offer.
There are not many in the promotion's history who have the ability to tell stories in the ring the way he does.

he has like 5. okada has like 15

Have fuckin sex nigga

Even if guys like Gargano and Cole are actually amazing wrestlers, how can you make them look credible on the main roster? When he was briefly called up and was standing next to Sheamus and Cesaro, he looked like a fucking 205Live geek. And Cesaro/Sheamus are midcarders at best. How can you have Gargano look like a threat to McIntyre or Lashley?

Isn't Okada also younger than Gargano?

Nah Gargano is younger by like 4 months

1. Jim Londos
2. Johnny Ratings
3. Some other people

nobody cares about him outside smarks

Hogan is the best wrestler ever

Doesn't matter if he becomes popular with the fans and they are willing to suspend disbelief when he goes against bigger opponents.

>story
kicking out of everything for 30 minutes, including the other guy's finisher at least 3 times and then winning isn't story

*superkicks you*
*superkicks you again*
*canadian destroyer*
*reverse rana*
*more superkicks*
*Mauro being an autist on commentary*

All this while no-selling and slapping your thigh. Modern wrestling was a ding-dong diddly mistake.

I like both guys but that match was as hacky as they come. You can tell these are Shawn's guys because they literally feel the need to shout the "story" in each others faces towards the climax of the match every single fucking time.

If you're just basing your rankings off how many Meltzer stars they have he's not even close
Misawa has twenty-five matches that are at least 5 stars, including two 5*+/6* matches

Worked

AEWtists out in force to discredit Johnny it seems. They're just jealous that we have he real beast bout machine in wrestling working for us in WWE, not AEW.

Shouting at each other is fine, the problem is that gargano doesn't differentiate himself from any other superkick spamming indie shitter