how come her music in elden ring was so weak? every good track is by someone else than her, and she was amazing in BB, DS3 and Sekiro
what happened?
How come her music in elden ring was so weak? every good track is by someone else than her, and she was amazing in BB...
Kevin Gray
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtu.be
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtu.be
youtube.com
youtu.be
twitter.com
Gavin Hernandez
She was really lackluster in Sekiro too. Very one-note and repetitive music. They need to hire a new composer. I suggest Yoko Shimomura who has a good grasp of orchestral music.
Nathaniel Jenkins
they should just keep a few from elden ring, like the guys who did radahn and lichdragon
she also did the ambient tracks to be fair, and those are stellar
Tyler Long
they shouldn't discard her entirely but she really should take a back seat and make fewer tracks that stand out more
Jonathan King
Yeah not sure if it was because i was too focus on the bosses but i don't remember a single memorable song in ER besides the Limgrave Ambience and Godfrey's theme
Elijah Ross
because its a woman lol next thread
Levi Lopez
>she was amazing in BB, DS3 and Sekiro
No she wasn't you tasteless idiot
Juan Hill
yall just hating on a woman getting her bag, its giving insecure nigga, child go play.
Gavin Gonzalez
What did she compose in BB and Elden ring?
Ian Jones
I'm actually going through the OST of BB and sekiro again and all my favorite tracks are not by her lol
Isaac Young
My heart's strings
Liam Morgan
>OOOH AAAAAH OHHHHHHH EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEH AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH AH AH AAAAAAAH OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHH UHHHH EEEEH EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE AAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
Souls music has always been uninspired gibberish but in the beginning there weren't enough tracks to realize they always follow the gibberish aahh oooh pattern that gets old fast. 3 games later I just want to mute that shit
Henry Nelson
The only track that was good in Sekiro is the one made by the Tenchu guy
Souls music is just bombastic and forgettably generic, Demon's Souls saving grace was the funny trumpets
Dominic Scott
Who composed Laurence the First Vicar? That's the only one that matters.
Dylan Morales
Lincoln Nelson
She did the only good track in DS2 (Alonne) and a lot of 3's tracks are very decent (Friede, Twin Princes etc etc)
Josiah Brooks
6 different people, kitamura among them
Lucas Sanchez
she was good in ds3
youtu.be
Jordan Young
This, holy shit. How can you honestly think her music in any of these games wasn't braindead trash?
Owen Foster
Name a better final boss track. I dare you, dollfucker.
Eli Jones
sounds like a marvel movie ost
Brayden Peterson
Ryder Smith
in what way?
Brandon Lewis
Only track I remember from Sekiro was Owl’s, and the Monk temple battle music of course. To be honest most of souls soundtracks just sound like orchestral cacophony most of the time
Alexander Baker
youtube.com
Of all the tracks in Elden Ring this is the one I actually liked. Straightforward, no bombastic choir or constant blaring horns or anything. Just a solid theme.
Asher Stewart
Yeah this was discussed before release, lots of Yea Forumsiggers guessed the OST was going to be shit.
She literally only made the most forgettable bombastic AAAHOOOOH ones that are just background noise.
Jeremiah Perez
>Boss so tragic :((( ooooooooooooohhhhh *violin* oooohoooohhhhh Boss was powerful once but is just a husk of its former self now ooooooooh aaaaaaaaahhhhh ;___;
Sekiro was the only semi original thing From has done in over 10 years.
ER bringing it all up to Skyrim tier mainstream was just the final nail in the coffin for me
Landon Wright
she was never good
you just thought she was because she's a woman
Parker Wilson
Christopher Collins
how was BB not original?
Parker Wood
The bombastic orchestra with choir thing would've been good if they did it ONLY for the final bosses.
Asher Rogers
that's not kitamura
Samuel Ramirez
Sekiro was lackluster, she just got popular bc simps loved the thought of crediting one woman for all of fromsoft's repertoire. The number of people I've come across who credit her with saitoh's work is unreal
Andrew Nguyen
Yeah at this point there is a full orchestra playing if you just kill a rat
Ryan Gray
Tsukasa saitoh and the new guy miyazawa made all the good shit in Elden ring. They should have them lead whatever they do next.
Daniel Hernandez
Christian Martin
No there isn't. Take your meds.
Eli Cox
Leo Gonzalez
>The number of people I've come across who credit her with saitoh's work is unreal
For some reason From Software tends to put her front and center whenever they talk about music. I can't remember them ever mentioning any other composers for Elden Ring before release, only Kitamura and she's not even responsible for most of the tracks you hear.
Sebastian Anderson
Literally a rat
youtube.com
Samuel Scott
Because she did most of DS3 and Sekiro.
Dominic Ramirez
because she 's a womEn and these people are fat virgin simps
Elijah Wright
Fromsoft music will never be better than this. youtu.be
Julian Harris
looks like a dog
Ryder Collins
>Malenia
I must've had at least 30 tries soloing her fight and I genuinely cannot remember a single thing about her theme.
Zachary Lewis
she probably sucked their dick real good
Luis Barnes
The best music in BB wasn't even by her.
Ryder Foster
That wasn't composed by Kitamura
Nicholas Morales
Saitoh, he's great
Adam Cooper
Literally all of Saitoh's music sounds the same.
Sebastian Adams
Owl's probably stands out because I'm 99% sure that it was a guest track from the composer of the Tenchu soundtrack, which is a fucking amazing OST and it has the same feel to it.
Jose Garcia
If people knew just how amazing the Tenchu soundtrack is
youtube.com
Imagine being a nine year old playing his first Playstation game and this shit starts blasting. I was overwhelmed in all my senses.
Connor Lopez
tbf she hard carried DS2 and DS3, and she had standout tracks in BB. From probably trusts her a lot.
Tsukasa Saitoh is good but he only does a few tracks for each game.
the rest of ER composers were former sound engineers who were promoted. Their tracks are pretty good too
Isaac Kelly
>she had standout tracks in BB
What the fuck are you talking about? None of the good tracks in BB were by her.
Chase Collins
She did Slave Knight Gael and Abyss Watchers for DaS3 right? Those are some legendary tracks. You can tell on Youtube those are the most popular Soulsborne tracks.
Josiah Nelson
>trusts her a lot
they just should pick whats good and tghrow the trash but also probably they dont give a single fuck, they never really did and relied on chance for shit to be good, except bloodborne but thats probably because sony was involved
Adrian Mitchell
but they both made that one with 4 other people
James Perez
Ebrietas, Maria
Ayden Rivera
> miyazawa composed Mohg theme
you are correct
Ian Morales
she also did the Twin Princes, Friede, Dragonslayer Armor etc
she's pretty much 90% of DS3's music. I think Saitoh did Gundyr's theme but that's it lmao. It's still great though
rip Suzuki, he doesn't work at From anymore. I always liked his music too
Kayden Bell
youtu.be
this dude should do more stuff next game, it's probably my favorite souls ost ever
Landon Moore
source?
Charles Evans
So according to this thread, Yea Forums seems to like braindead diatonic music with constant easy to follow ostinatos,