we need to argue about the peak of Souls and only these 3 games are in contention
We need to argue about the peak of Souls and only these 3 games are in contention
Julian Murphy
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
Charles Phillips
Dark Souls > Demon's Souls > Dark Souls 3
End of discussion.
Jayden Price
>Best Atmosphere and feeling
Demon's Souls
>Best World
Dark Souls
>Best combat
Dark Souls 3
Connor Ortiz
>3
>peak
It ruined the franchise, retard.
Jack Price
killed the series the same way RE4 killed resident evil lmao...
James Myers
>>Best World
>Dark Souls
it's too gamey.
Demon's Souls better
David Martin
>the peak of Souls
>Dark Souls 3
Pick one
Lucas Wood
I love DeS's world, but it doesn't have that interconnected feeling DaS has.
How is it too gamey?
Brandon Hernandez
they're all in the trashcan, why should i care about which garbage smells best?
Aaron Cruz
All of that is garbage compared to King's Field IV.
Kayden Wood
I think this would be more interesting if it were demon's souls, dark souls, elden ring
Josiah Jackson
because within a span of hundreds of feet you can walk from a forest, castle, poison swamp and lava area with no transition
Daniel Gray
Dark Souls 3 is the best one since it's got the best overall gameplay, level design, and bosses. It has an incredibly straightforward upgrade system which ends up making it the best for replays because it's functional as fuck and there's no busy work looking for the specific ore you need.
Demon's Souls is amazing and I still think it's better than Dark Souls 1 to this day. I replayed Dark Souls 1 recently and there's a reason I stopped replaying it after Dark Souls 3 came out. It somehow feels older and slower than Demon's Souls. Demon's Souls has quicker movement, kick ass level design, and really great atmosphere going for it. It may be more linear and not interconnected, but it's more fun to play through those levels than the second half of Dark Souls 1.
Dark Souls 3 > Demon's Souls > Dark Souls 1
That's a pretty easy ranking for me any day. Dark Souls 3 feels too damn good to play.
Jacob Brooks
Demon's > Dark > Dark 3
End of discussion.
Josiah Edwards
First half of dark souls > demons souls > dark souls > dark souls 3
Caleb Nelson
i like that dark souls 3 brought back all demon's souls cool weapon upgrade paths after dark souls 1 removed them
Josiah Thompson
>interconnected feeling DaS has
I actually think that's precisely it. From clearly had to make some compromises to support the ambitious scale of the interconnected world. The loading caves and elevators connecting locations get really noticeable. The areas are too close to one another for gameplay convenience. That's never really an issue in Demon's Souls.
The view from Anor Londo to Duke's Archives for instance is as nonsensical as vistas in Dark Souls 2.
Ian Rogers
Dark Souls 2
Lincoln Murphy
DS1>DeS>DS3
Adam Long
Personally I don't have much trouble with it. They seem to do scale pretty well, even when the camera clearly sucks dick at it. see: ER.
Austin Sanders
Demon's Souls > Dark Souls 3 > Dark Souls
DeS mogs the other two when it comes to atmosphere. It has more consistent level design than DS1. It's original. DS1 is basically DeS 2.0 and DS3 is basically DS 1.5.
Cameron Davis
Lmfao demon souls has the worst roster of bosses and WT was a garbage system.
That and Bloodborne are the most Overrated games and it's not surprising they're "exclusives"
Jonathan Mitchell
demon's souls saved video games. show some respect dumbass
Matthew Rodriguez
pre-lordvessel dark souls is peak video games
Evan Russell
>DeS mogs the other two when it comes to atmosphere
this
youtube.com
Ryder Long
Bloodborne mogs all of them
Luis Torres
It's just one of the many things and little bits of references to Demon's Souls
Jaxson Kelly
DaS2 is undisputably the best soulsborne game there is
Colton Garcia
this destroys the soulsborne. considering a 3rd playthrough
Eli Cruz
I want more games like this.
Maybe not with guns, but first person melee that isn't made by fucking bethesda
Colton Ward
the best souls game is the one not pictured
Adam Perez
play dark messiah
Sebastian Stewart
I have. and it plays horribly nowadays with old jank source engine
Hudson Gray
Demon's Souls is the worst one though.
Luis Gutierrez
nigger
Hunter Wood
They've all got strengths and weaknesses over the other. DS3 has the overall weakest level design both layout and aesthetics.
Lincoln Bennett
I loved how Demons Souls feels like a real medieval world of humans only, where all of a sudden Demons and monsters started appearing and shit and everyone is afraid and trying to deal with it best they can. It's the most like Berserk in that way, how it was all hundred years war until shit hits the fan and Hell literally comes into the world. Dark Souls is fantastical right out of the gate with dragons and gods and monsters so the atmosphere isn't as good imo.
Cameron Cooper
I want a Demon's Souls 2 so badly
Josiah Bennett
>DS3 has the overall weakest level design both layout
Depends on the map, Dark Souls 3 has overall better level design than most of DS1
Anthony Carter
Weird that you left out the best one
Daniel James
DaS2 is actually the best and it's not a meme
I've played all and DaS2 is the only one that I come back to. That and ER.
Ayden Perry
Agreed. Personally i'm a sucker for fantasy, but the dark fantasy of DeS is way better than the half-assed dark/high fantasy of DaS.
Ian Sullivan
ST didnt have guns and was way creepier
Jace Rogers
>Depends on the map, Dark Souls 3 has overall better level design than most of DS1
No. Too many levels use the Chalice Dungeon level trick of making levels out of pre designed sections like a rogue dungeon. Catacombs, Izalith, Farron Keep all suffer with this copy pasted grey corridors with stairs. Its shit and once you see it you can't unsee it. Levels are outright toss compared to even the shittest level in DS1.
Leo Hughes
I was gonna yell at you for saying that as I just watched Iron Pineapples video about it at the mention, but that's ST:Abyss, not the first one. I didn't know they were different.
Regardless, I hope Lunacid becomes the modern KF/ST.
Isaiah Adams
same. but then i realized if they ever made a demon's souls 2 it would have just been what became dark souls with a different name.
Owen Sanders
I also dislike how the castle designs have become more and more Gothic rather than Normanesque. My favorite castle in Elden Ring was Mourne Castle because it was a proper big block castle with ramparts descending the cliffs. Everything else in the game was way too ornate and Gothic looking.
Jace Rogers
i only like to replay demon's souls. what's your point? ds2 isn't even a miyazaki game it's a shitty fanfiction
Jaxson Johnson
>Iron Pineapples video
Aesir aesthetics destroys him in every way
youtube.com
Tyler Rivera
Thank FUCK someone else is in on that.
I'll never touch the remake because fuck buying a PS5, but jfc make something believable for once.
style isn't everything.
Never heard of him. I'll have a look. More opinions to source from the better
Elijah Turner
They’re all pretty amazing, just shut the fuck up and play all of them you massive faggot.
Colton Cooper
>Aesir aesthetics
His reviews of the King's Field games are excellent. I'm glad he played them so I don't have to, I don't think I would have been able to enjoy the games with how antiquated they are. I would love a remake of KF1 to KF3 as one game, that shit is ripe to put the series back in the spotlight.
Andrew White
CONSOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOM
Charles Sullivan
>best combat
Dark Souls 2
>best fashion
Dark Souls 2
>best progression
Dark Souls 2
>best muisc
Demon's Souls
>best level design
they're all equally shit
>best atmosphere
Demon's Souls
>best lore
lol
>best enemies
Dark Souls
>best endings
Dark Souls 2
>best final boss
Dark Souls
>good at nothing
Dark Souls 3
Brody Morales
>multiple copies of the same game
>ps3 DeS in case
bruh
>ps4 versions all
can't even mod or get high fps. shame
Nathaniel Carter
>multiple copies of the same game
Yes
>ps3 DeS in multiple copies of the same game
>ps3 DeS in case
Yes
>ps4 versions all
Yes
Brody Taylor
John Cruz
Get rid of Dark Souls 3 and there is your peak. Of course BB and Sekiro are the best in this “genre” or whatever you want to call it.
Sebastian Ortiz
>I'm glad he played them so I don't have to
>a remake of KF1 to KF3 as one game
I couldnt imagine robbing myself of the expierence of playing kingsfield blind. The reviews are only good with context of the game
Logan Taylor
>Sekiro
>the best in this “genre”
It's not even the same genre. Sekiro is an action game, and quite honestly, it's not that good either way.
Colton Lewis
Nah it's still pretty fun.
Connor Bailey
never said it wasn't
Ian Howard
Aesir Aesthetics does a really good job explaining the lore and plot of the games as there really isn't much too the lore like there is in later Fromosoft games. A remake would expand and add to those original games. Guyra definitely should be be renamed Kalameet, or have two names with Guyra being given by the people and Kalameet being the real name of the black dragon.
Cameron Martin
this might blow your mind but I like Kingsfield gameplay way more than later From stuff, the plots were only flavor
Josiah Phillips
Even with 4-directional rolling, Dark Souls, all the way.