If this game got completely remade from the ground up, but with the current VAs and a new script by Pontiac/Graff...

Make the battle mode online with more tracks and up to 4 players and you've got yourself a deal. Go ahead and make the robot battles actually enjoyable and fix the broken outer space maps for the treasure hunters. Actually just go ahead and trash it.

Attached: 1542937937363.jpg (1280x720, 73K)

Same

Sonic > Shadow > Knuckles > Tails > Eggman > Rouge

Attached: brian.jpg (550x545, 23K)

>treasure hunting is fun
Not if you're trying to get A-ranks.

I unlocked green hill
it wasn't worth it

Also another big problem with the game is that it only has like 6 levels: Pyramid, City, Base, Jungle, Mountain and Space. You see these same motifs over and over again. And it doesn't help that every single Pyramid level sucks

I would, but I doubt I'd enjoy it as much as the originals UNLESS they somehow made the Chao Garden better. Not really a fan of the new games' stories or Sonic's newest VA, so I don't think I'd enjoy the main game as much as I did originally.

Only if it has SOUL.
Oh wait, it's impossible to remake a game without sucking all the soul out of it, so no.

then don't go for A ranks
You aren't forced to unlock Green Hill, it's an easteregg/bonus thing

I agree that the levels could have some more unique motifs but I really consider that a small nitpick.

Stop being a score autist

Can we keep the old vas?

It'd be worse in every regard, excluding graphical fidelity. I'd maybe play it, I wouldn't buy it.

but muh green hill

Attached: Sonic2app_2017-03-02_17-22-25-181.png (1360x768, 1.12M)

They'd have to get new ones for Tails(old VA went through puberty) and Eggman(old VA is dead) regardless

>Nobody on this website will ever (and I really do mean EVER) know the joy that this game brought me
Lads, me and my uncle played the ever living fuck out of this game together. A ranked all the missions together but the thing we sunk the most time into was the Chao Garden. Hooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooly fucking shit we would spend hours just going into stages getting Chao Drives + Animals to make a metric fuck ton of different Chao. It was so goddamn good.

>new script by Pontiac/Graff
No

>Tails > Eggman
There's not a single tails level that can compare to Cosmic Wall.

only if they took the knuckles and tails parts. Also added more sonic levels

>Criticize terrible aspects of the game
>Accuse dissenting opinion of getting their opinions from youtube.
Like clockwork. You faggots are actually obsessed with PedoJared. I didn't get that information from a youtube video. I played the game you absolute faggot. It's even worse because they actually made the treasure hunting stages WORSE than they were in SA1 since now you are basically forced to collect the emeralds in some arbitrary linear order unless you autistically memorized all of their locations or just happen upon another by pure chance instead of all of the radars being active at once like they were in the previous game. Pure garbage. How does that promote exploration and freedom when you're almost being forced to approach the level in a very specific way the game wants you to? Also Eggman had exactly one good level which was Cosmic wall, and I attribute half of that to just the music. Don't kid yourself into thinking he was so much better than Tails since their stages are meant to be parallels of each other.

>I played the game
>that's why I repeated a youtuber's views word for word

>Accusing me of repeating someone's opinion word for word when you didn't even read my reasoning
Kill yourself please.

it's a not a hot take to say that SA2 is a garbagefire you autistic little faggot. bottomfeeders like you used to stay on deviantart where you belonged but now you feel bold enough to come to Yea Forums and pretend you're not a smelly sonic tard. fuck off already.

>Youtuber has a common and extremely obvious criticism
>WOOOOAH NOBODY ELSE IS ALLOWED TO THINK THAT NOW

Attached: 1565881701463.png (200x209, 63K)

Yes. I don't care how much hate it gets, it's one of the best games ever. The only way I would reconsider buying a remake is if they did something like remove the chao garden.

question, do you seriously think egoraptor and projared were the first people in recorded history to criticize the dreamcast era games? they were polarizing games since they launched my friend.

They're just popular so kids parrot their opinions

Tails easily has the worst levels in the game. The open-ness of Eggman's stages makes them occasionally enjoyable but Tails' stages are more linear and straightforward which makes them a real chore to play.

only if it have the chao garden

Attached: images (12).jpg (320x240, 21K)

>with the current VAs and a new script by Pontiac/Graff,

Attached: EB5EA835-5F85-4E84-A86C-08910CC7858F.jpg (500x563, 54K)

>new script

Attached: erase.jpg (700x479, 42K)

kind of like how you parrot "you must like projared" if anyone says anything bad about sonic adventure 2. i see this exact non argument in every single thread about this game. you bring up e-celebs first.

then come up with an original idea nigga

it is an original idea. the funny thing is Yea Forums was even more polarized about SA2 before pedojared came along because it wasn't full of children who just remember it fondly because they played it when they were young and you were allowed to criticize it without faggots like you who CANNOT defend your actual points beyond a youtube boogieman.

pretty sure someone posted some points in defense that had nothing to do with youtube
but keep up that strawman

No. 3D Sonic is trash.

Literally no one had anything bad to say about the Sonic Adventure games until the first one got remastered for XBLA. I believe it was IGN that wrote a review saying it "aged poorly." That was the first time I'd heard that term used about a game, but after that it's became an extremely common buzz phrase. Now, you can't just dislike an older game, you have to claim it aged poorly. So we have dumbass little kids talking about how games aged despite not even being alive when the game came out, or dumbass twenty-somethings saying a game didn't age well because they don't enjoy something they did when they were 6.

yeah i bet he got those points from [youtuber], also he voted right wing and is a raped me 30 years ago. so he's wrong.

> also he voted right wing and is a raped me 30 years ago
learn to type in english to continue this conversation

Found the a raped me.

you also raped me 30 years ago with projared shut up bigot

The treasure hunting is fun it's just some of the levels sucked dick. Security Hall was the least fun level in the entire game.

If nothing else I would play it for the bat tats.

Attached: 1484195716342.jpg (793x968, 313K)

>it's good because someone else said so
Isn't this what you are accusing that user of supposedly doing only you're admitting to it

>Security Hall was the least fun level in the entire game.
Security Hall is good. I disliked it as a child because of the time limit, but it's more than enough time to complete the level. The Space levels are trash, I'll admit.

>I disliked it as a child because of the time limit, but it's more than enough time to complete the level.
So what you're saying is 5 minutes should be plenty?

It's not that it's particularly hard, I just find it a fucking slog to traverse and shit to look at. Run along an endless wall of identical doors until you find the one that blinks red wheeeeeee

Sonic & Shadow levels are all pretty fun. Rouge & Knuckles levels are fun aside from Meteor Herd & Mad Space. Eggman levels are shitty but Tails ones are the absolute worst. Eternal Engine is one of the worst levels in the entire game, especially for getting A rank.

The emerald hunting stages would have been way better if they'd just let you track all three shards at once, like in Adventure 1