Attached: DC0EA157-2B7E-4368-B7F5-8B4CE922B57C.png (831x323, 39K)
Why is FromSoftware the only Japanese dev able to do non-cringey English voice acting?
Luke Morales
Other urls found in this thread:
youtu.be
youtube.com
twitter.com
Andrew Flores
It's also worth noting that the old English feel of From's writing can be at part attributed to the excellent translation team at Frognation.
Look at the credits for the games. They don't have credited writers, only designers/programmers/planners/directors. The English scripts are outsourced to other companies (like Frognation).
Look at the Dark Souls Credits:
(English) Script Writing
>Ryan Morris (Frognation Ltd)
>Lynn Robson (Frognation Ltd)
>Kengo Watanabe (Frognation Ltd)
>Ema Kodaka (Frognation Ltd)
No one else (not even miyazaki) is credited with writing the game script, and Frognation is an outsourced company.
DS2 credits:
Script Writer
>Toshifumi Nabeshima
(English) Script writing:
>Ryan Morris (Frognation Ltd)
>Lynn Robson (Frognation Ltd)
>Kengo Watanabe (Frognation Ltd)
>Ian Milton-Polley(Frognation Ltd)
>Ema Kodaka (Frognation Ltd)
Thomas Davis
they outsource it to competent people
Carson Flores
See Also it's recorded natively in English (usually) by English actors.
The one time it wasn't was sekiro. Que MMYY NAAMMMEEEE ISSS
Julian Turner
Trick is to not hire the same dozen VAs like western devs seem to do all the fucking time.
Jeremiah Reyes
They hire theatre actors for voices rather than overpriced and undertalented career vidya voice actors
Oliver Torres
educated high quality
William Young
to be fair that's because there's barely any real STORY in souls games. incidental dialogs and fluff pieces you put together are not the same as having a classically structured story to tell.
Matthew Collins
because in the Souls games the English voices are the original voices.
FromSoft doesn't outsource to some trash America localization company who'll shit it out with their go to roster of anime dub actors.
Sekiro's english voicing and translation was handled by Activision for example and it was way worse, unsurprisingly.
Nolan Hughes
Hey! They work hard to get those roles on the casting couch damn it.
Parker White
The English dub for Sekiro is pretty bad compared to the Japanese voice acting.
Easton Watson
To be fair all the souls games and bloodborne were heavily influenced by European history and mythology so it makes sense to have western script writers handle the writing of a heavily western-influenced setting. Sekiro's default voice acting is Japanese because, well, the setting is Japan.
Josiah Scott
>OOOOOOOOOHHHHHH
Brayden Rodriguez
Yeah, because that game wasn't even supposed to have an English dub originally.
Activision is responsible for that.
Camden Young
>the excellent translation team at Frognation
The one that made all those nonsensical mistranslations in 2 and even mixes up katakana symbols?
Connor Thomas
>excellent translation team
Not sure what are you talking about, DaSII and III had poor translations. Don't know about the first one
Grayson Anderson
They record it in the UK, not the US.
Robert Hill
It shows. Instead of getting a bunch of actors with a theater background like in previous Fromsoft games, Activision got youtube/twitter personalities for some minor characters in addition to the regular vidya VA's.
>MY NAME... IS GYOUBU MASATAKA ONIWA!
The only good line in the English dub just because the actor hammed it up.
Nolan Gonzalez
VA only sucks in burgerland
Benjamin Lewis
they don't allow americans to have a hand in it, and it's originally recorded in English with actual directing instead of some fucking anime dubbers reading their script aloud over the phone
Chase Flores
Pretty bad? It should be fucking outlawed.
Wyatt Bailey
Horrible delivery, but it was apparently customary for samurai to yell out their name as a challenge.
Parker Brown
>non-cringey English voice acting
youtu.be
You have got to either be deaf or retarded to think this is good voice acting
Lucas Howard
Most of Sekiro's VA was pretty flat, but Gyobu was fucking great. Isshin was great too.
HOW MY BLOOD BOILS
Angel Moore
That's pure kino that you just posted bro
Christopher Edwards
Who even plays Sekiro in English?
Colton Cruz
Good VAs in English include (and you can fight me on this shit if you don’t agree)
>Patrick Seitz
>Ian Sinclair
>Matt Mercer
>Charlie Schlatter, exclusively for his performance as Wonder Red
>Roger Craig Smith
>Johnny Young Bosch
>Josh Keaton
>Robert Atkins Downes
>Nathan Vetterlein
>Yuri Lowenthal
>Liam O’brien
>Helena Taylor
Colton Flores
If you don't think that's fantastic VA work you're legitimately tasteless, user.
Adrian Garcia
Just wanted to say Jap Genichiros voice is pure sex. Kenjiro Tsuda is also voicing Sam in the Jap dub of Death Stranding.
Anthony Reyes
It's like those VAs can only read from script and are unable to put some emotions in them, worst offenders being Wolf and Kuro. Even ones that are supposed to be emotional like Orin just feel really flat and generic.
Logan Thomas
Sekiro's dialogue felt really off compared to the prior Souls games and now I'm glad to see it wasn't just me.
Anthony Nguyen
youtube.com
This always gives me chills.
Kevin Edwards
Jap voices is the intended experience. I think it even says so when first launching the game.
Daniel Ward
And Gehrman does one too in Bloodborne in the middle of his boss fight. It's great.
Luke Jackson
So if Elden Ring is going to be Norse mythology, will a Scandinavian language be the "preferred" dub?
Matthew Morris
>Be decrepit mutant horseman for god knows how long
>Get smashed up by some nerd with a wheel
>Collapse from immense damage
>HMMMMMM??? AAHHHHH, YOU were at my side ALL ALOOOONGGG... my true MENTOR!!! My guiding moonlight! MHMHMHMHHMHM!!
>good voice acting
ok
Jacob Carter
icelandic is the best bet then, swedish, norwegian, danish and finnish have all deviated from the original nordic language
Ryder Reyes
It's just going to be ye olde English.
Christopher Clark
NMH and DMC say hi
Xavier Harris
Funny how most of them are males. Says a lot about the female "talent" in the industry
Jacob Wright
Should I play 4 before 4A? Should I play VD at all?
Daniel Rivera
>the regular vidya VA's
You mean anime dubbers.