JD or Kait

Who was the better main protagonist?

Attached: jd-kait-bg.jpg (1920x1080, 259K)

They both suck. I just want to play as Marcus.

True. But who was the better protagonist between them.

This, what the fuck are they doing with this shit, I dont get it. marcus isnt exactly an amazing character but he is the face of the franchise, these new characters have the reek of modern sensibilities about them and they just suck ass. We need another Coletrain and Dom buddy, not this no-mark shit.

Couldnt stand Kaits attitude, so I guess JD.
>its because shes a woman
Nope, being mad at your teammates who are trying to help you is not endearing or makes a likeable character, I just wanted her to shut the fuck up and follow Marcus lead, if it was a male character doing that shit he would come across as a whining bitch, its somehow alright to present a female character this way still though.

>discount Nathan Drake face
>La Goblina
I'd rather just play as old man marcus

Kait had some story at least

Kait was a better main protag. More interesting than JD who was bland.

>society falls apart
>humanity fighting an abomination
>every day is a struggle to survive
>"""""female soldier""""" still has access and time to cosmetics

Remember it's not from the original team so its full of a bunch of gay candians who want to make it theirs with their characters and stories. Same shit with halo where you end up with fanfic tier OD donut steel sonic the edgehog characters thrown in and forced on you.

Flop

Attached: GearsOfWar4_ConceptArt.jpg (1280x545, 145K)

Attached: D_NAAfiXoAIb1fs.jpg (1200x675, 165K)

>Game devs have never seen a woman without makeup so they don't know what women look like without makeup

>JD looks like a one liner spitting action hero determined to win
>Kait looks plucky, sort of like how Baird was
But we got
>bland nothing, he is a literally nothing personality, Carmines have more personality
>angry at everyone at all times, never smiles in the entire time shes on screen, full of angst and never lets up

>canadians shit up another series

THEY CAN'T KEEP GETTING AWAY WITH IT

Attached: 1537283450209.jpg (1692x921, 124K)

Is there anyone that preferred Kait over JD?

Is this game a flop?

JD for sure, Gears 5 only helped reinforce how much better character he is.

Attached: Gears 5 2019-09-06 22-56-30.png (1920x1080, 1.83M)

JD definitely got a lot more character development in this game.
It sucks because Gears 5 also made me like Del much more than 4 did.
I sure as hell wasn't going to make Marcus lose another family member though

Kait probably chooses Del tho. Kinda makes more sense that way.

REEE I JUST WANT TO PLAY AS THE OLD CAST WHERE THE FUCK IS THE CARMINE SKINS REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

Attached: 1567144881270.jpg (217x232, 10K)

Choosing JD is a much better ending though. That scene with Marcus hearing about Del and immediatly going towards JD (since he clearly relates to how he felt about Dom) was absolute top kino and so was the final scene. Meanwhile, if you choose Del he pretty much turns into a background character who doesn't even talk to Marcus about his son and friend.
The more i rewatch it, the more it makes sense that JD surviving is canon since his character has much more potential for 6.

Attached: Gears 5 2019-09-06 22-32-42.png (1920x1080, 1.75M)

Redemption it's easy to see the fanfic story the canucks are doing.

I agree with you but Kait probably chooses Del since he was with her for the entire game.

JD. Only because Kaits an annoying brat in both games

You might as well be asking if a German shepherd shitting on your floor or a husky shitting on your floor is better.

Goddamn user, i wish i could upvote you twice.

So, JD or Del......... who did you guys choose?

Kait is a faggot stryng indypyndynt wymyn who dynt nyyd ny myn, so she can fuck off immediately
JD is white, tall, blue and blond. there's nothing he could do wrong

neither because I refuse to play a game that relies on stupid "Chooses" like that to stir up drama. What is this a fucking Telltale game.

Is the dialogue less quippy this time?

JD, didn't take me 2 seconds. They tried to force Del on me for the whole game but didn't work.

Yes.

maybe less quippy but its still cliche as fuck.