19th best game of all time

>block puzzles
This doesn't even belong in the top 1000.

Of course I agree with them.
They have always been the source of objectively correct opinions.

Who the fuck are they again?

I probably enjoyed the puzzle aspects more than the story honestly. The bar atmosphere was nice, and the horror aspect was interesting early on, but I thought Vincent was a real tool, and the whole "twist" explanation for the nightmare didn't make much sense to me.

Attached: Catherine_Boss.png (797x827, 364K)

I think the game is great but top 100 or even top 500. no

> 1. NieR: Automata
> 2. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
> 3. NieR: Replicant
> 4. Persona 4 Golden
> 5. Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc
> 6. Doom (1993)
> 7. Metal Gear Solid
> 8. EarthBound
> 9. Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem
> 10. Sonic The Hedgehog 2
> 11. Sid Meier's Civilization II
> 12. Beyond Good & Evil
> 13. Chrono Trigger
> 14. Castlevania: Symphony of the Night
> 15. Super Mario 64
> 16. Animal Crossing (2002)
> 17. SoulCalibur II
> 18. The Sims
> 19. Catherine
> 20. Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth
> 21. Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly
> 22. Final Fantasy X
> 23. Journey
> 24. Life is Strange
> 25. Mass Effect 2
> 26. Mega Man 2
> 27. Dragon Age Origins
> 28. Fire Emblem 7
> 29. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
> 30. Samurai Warriors 3
> 31. Pokemon Red/Blue/Yellow
> 32. SimCity 2000
> 33. Spec Ops: The Line
> 34. Pac-Man
> 35. Papers Please
> 36. Final Fantasy VI
> 37. Metroid Prime
> 38. 1979 Revolution: Black Friday
> 39. Ori & The Blind Forest
> 40. Street Fighter II
> 41. Bound
> 42. Yakuza 5
> 43. American McGee Alice
> 44. To the Moon
> 45. Maniac Mansion: Day of the Tentacle
> 46. Pokemon Gold & Silver

Other way around. People come for the story, stay for the gameplay. The puzzles ended up being a lot deeper/more complex than they initially looked. The game's a blast.

at least this list isn't as generic as most others. However every single best games list loses all credibility if it includes Life is Strange anywhere.

>NieR: Automata
Fucking lol

Amazing game, seethe more

Niet automata is a nice game but it's a strange choice for number 1
Botw as 2 is straight up retarded, it's one of the worst games ever made

>game
lol

As someone who loves Resident Evil, is Eternal Darkness really THAT good?

>Nier automata beats BOTW

Oh no no no no

This list confuses me in many, many ways. It feels like someone wanted to do an approachable list while keeping it original. I don't know if it's based on someone's personal taste or if whoever wrote it was trying too hard

Attached: 1495145246558.png (600x600, 175K)

>NieR Automata number 1
No dignity
Eternal darkness is pretty good but don't go in expecting resident evil. It's less a survival horror game and more a psychological horror game

>dark corners of the earth
Based

Attached: 20170801230838_1.jpg (1920x1080, 265K)

Exposed yourself

let me guess, ocarina of time was listed as no.1?

If we were talking about art style and story then sure but unfortunately there's more to a game than that.
Game had an awesome variety of endings. The best ending of them all is in the Full Body though

Attached: New Catherine ending pic 1.png (1005x581, 799K)

Who gave it this rating? I'm about to play it, but I find it hard to believe it's that high up.

The only Atlus game that deserves a spot in the top 50 in Innocent Sin.

>Nier: Automata is a movie game
Jesus, I know you guys like repeating memes, but maybe at least try playing the game before you call it a movie.

well at least its a somewhat original list

> 4. Persona 4 Golden

Attached: 1563217578831.jpg (534x465, 83K)

This looks like my gfs favorite game list except it sucks Paradox's cock less than she does.
Women have bad taste in games user

Pretty fucking pretentious

>> 1. NieR: Automata
aahahahahaha
Yeah no

>this hipster ass contrarian list
lmao what fucking site did this?

I'm not even sure I'd call Catherine a good game, let alone one of the best.

It was novel but clumsy as fuck, and design-wise the actual gameplay was all significantly underwhelming.

ayyyy lmao

Attached: ayylmao.png (350x350, 180K)

I actually have a lot more respect for this list than most since it's not just the same
>1. OoT
>2. SM64
>3. Red Dead Redemption
Copy and pasted garbage.
Much respect for Eternal Darkness and SoulCalibur II being there

> 24. Life is Strange
How the fuck is this garbage number 24? This is one of the worst pieces of shit I've """played""", horrible story, horrible characters, no game play, choices don't matter, the only thing it has going for it is the sketchbook aesthetic and that's it.

>life is strange in a top 100 tier list
I wouldn't put it on a top 10000 list that game is garbage

>Life is strange 7 not only in the least but better that mas effect 2, better than dao, better than kotor, better than fuxling spec ops the line
Holy shit, nigga, are you for real?

This looks like it was made by some faggot in Yea Forums.

>Life is Strange
>To The Moon
>Call of Cthulhu
>American McGee's Alice

This was made by a boomer female, wasn't it?

should of been higher

>Automata above BotW
But why?

Pretty decent list but a couple entries are just weird, including NieR at the 1st and 3rd spot of course

> NieR Automata
> Metal Gear Solid
> EarthBound
> Eternal Darkness
> Chrono Trigger
> Beyond Good/Evil
> Mario 64
> Castlevania SOTN
> SoulCalibur II
> Final Fantasy VI & X
> Fatal Frame 2
> Persona 4 Golden
> Metroid Prime
Only good games everything else is mediocre or completely shit

who is this by?
all i can tell is that they're entry level weebs

>> 5. Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc
>no Ace Attorney

>Why Yes, I'm a Tranny, How Could You Tell?
:
The List

They gave a 10/10 to Blue Reflection & Multiple Atelier games that’s all that needs to be said

You forgot Doom in there you zoomer nigger, opinion discarded.

It's pretty good if you enjoy lovecraft style stories.
It uses a madness mechanic really well in an original way.
I'd say give it a go if you never got to play it.