The great debate

what if I enjoy both?

Minecraft>terraria in terms of:
Building
Modding
Servers/multiplayer potential

Terraria has a base game that’s a lead up to the moon lord but after that there was nothing left to do

3D>2D in term of building games

They're both amazing video games. Minecraft is more comfy, Terraria is more exciting.
Anyone who says either is bad is either retarded with shit taste or hasn't actually played both.

Attached: watercookie.png (353x351, 52K)

I like both? Can't we like both? These kind of threads always devolve into tearing one game down to prop up the other but that's just not fun anymore. I like both, period.

This.
If I want to relax and build shit, I go to Minecraft, if I want an exciting adventure, I gravitate towards Terraria.
Anyhoo, I enjoy both games equally.

Attached: 1480348208226.jpg (125x100, 4K)

Terraria by a light year

one of those is enjoyable without heavy modding

Minecraft

For some reason, the controls in Terraria never felt great to me. Breaking blocks and placing items just feels clunkier compared to Minecraft.

Minecraft is better for aesthetic buildings
Terraria is better for adventuring

left if you want to build shit, right if you want a game. Both are only worth playing with friends

why would you compare 2 games of completely different genres?

>He never bro'ed it up and beat expert mode with buddies, each person specializing in a different weapon type

I've played both, each scratches a different itch. It's like comparing Rugby with Golf

>Minecraft but 2D Tier
Terraria

>Terraria but 3D Tier
Minecraft

>modding
But that's where you're wrong. Terraria mods are better that Minecraft mods on average, you need to install a fuckton of mods in a pack for the effect to be anywhere near noticable.

Minecraft endgame turns into "automation simulator" no matter what mods you pick because the combat inherently sucks, theres not enough weapon variety to be a psuedo-RPG, and progression is linear as fuck in every playthrough.

Terraria endgame turns into "play the game normalyl once and then download every mod because it makes the entire game completely different with progression and gameplay"

What's the fucking debate? They're both fun for entirely different reasons

I never liked Terraria, it feels like a cheap flash game and it's controls are awkward. Minecraft is also boring but at least it's playable. Both are procedural boring shit.

>le holohoax am i rite fellow rwdditos lamonroflnxd fuckejnkek akshdkakakwnd

Minecraft has better building mechanics.
Terraria has better combat and exploration.

Attached: everything I say is right.jpg (800x600, 88K)

Why not both?

youtube.com/watch?v=o77MzDQT1cg

Anyone else looking forward to hytale?

Attached: chicken.jpg (1920x1080, 366K)

cope

reminder that notch didnt make minecraft

looks neat

2d >>>>>>>>> 3d

No the art style is ass

ok twitter tranny

The character models look a bit weird, but the game seems to have a much better art style than minecraft.

Attached: art.png (590x303, 355K)

Both are pretty awful

can the fucking journey's end update come out already ffffffffff

Left is boring and only major autism can make it remotely enjoyable

Right is amazing, with lots of shit to do and explore on top of building stuff.

SEETHING kike

Yea Forums is a National Socialist board, please leave.

National?

We all know there's only one right answer to this thread

Attached: 1566866093297.png (1000x1000, 230K)

Terraria, no contest.

>Vanilla game
Terraria wins

>With Mods
Minecraft wins

i have 200 hours of minecraft but never modded it, is there an essential list?

I don't believe in failed ideology.

Underrated post.

Attached: 1519465542309.png (912x905, 1.23M)

oof

based

mad

Just google minecraft modpacks and out of the popular ones pick the pack with the most mods for 1.12

The only thing Minecraft has going for it is that it's in 3D. Terraria is far better in every other aspect. Better progression, more interesting world, better enemy variety, a huge number of bosses and a great feeling of "I am growing stronger". Like Minecraft you get all your diamond armour and weapons and tools and shit and then a creeper explodes while you're mining and pushed you into lava and you fucking die instantly still. Meanwhile terraria chad knew he was going lava diving in hell itself so he brought an obsidian skin potion so he can just dick about in lava like he gives a fuck or use his grappling hook to quickly and smartly prevent himself falling in in the first place.

It really depends on what you want to do with it. Some things I would consider staples though are Sildurs shaders, Optifine, and snow accumulation

Heres a pretty good channel showcasing some mods youtube.com/user/asianhalfsquat

Attached: both mutually exclusive.png (1000x650, 120K)

Base game
Terraria

With mods
Minecraft

Not only that, but Terraria's progression is permanent. Getting a cool new set of armor in Minecraft makes you go "I better not go into combat now, lest I lose all my armor that's supposed to help me survive in combat." In Terraria, it feels more like "Cool, now I've permanently advanced, and can take more risks."

>Terraria is far better in every other aspect. Better progression, more interesting world, better enemy variety, a huge number of bosses and a great feeling of "I am growing stronger".
Thats my biggest gripe with Minecraft. I really wish they'd do an cave update and add a shit ton of underground biomes, theres so much real estate under the surface thats just going to waste. Also, more mobs, bosses, weapons/armor would be nice too

The bosses in Minecraft are just so shit. Like the Ender Dragon is literally 90% a "puzzle" fight and 10% shooting arrows. That doesn't even compare to the first time you stocked up on all your potions, dug down to hell, pulled out your minishark, dropped the voodoo doll into the lava and fought a giant wall of flesh, flying backwards down the tunnels of hell with an antigrav potion on, avoiding shit coming at you from all directions by the fucking seat of your pants, shooting thousands of bullets and hoping you have enough ammo to finish him off, hoping you can do it before you run out of fucking space and the wall of flesh just crushes you. That shit was fucking hype.

Earlier pre-release Starbound looked promising but then they removed a lot of cool shit and it's super boring now

I think we're going to wait until December
Then they'll give an apology announcement that it's got a few more months to go

Still find it funny how a large portion of you faggots think hardmode in Terraria is impossible, stick to your hugbox game lol

terraria is way better, but minecraft is still pretty good

based

Friendly reminder that the only entertaining thing in starbound is the fat mod

I'll be pissed if Master mode doesn't have increased loot chance, some unique loot and maybe an extra accessory slot because multiplying health and damage without that just turns it into true artificial difficulty IMO.
The mobility in vanilla is already kind of spotty and getting oneshot by late game projectiles will be aids as hell.

Remember when being retarded wasn't considered "cool"?
475617792 doesn't.

is this a bot? You post this after every single mention of shitbound

Agreed. I loved playing through Expert Mode, and just Expert Squared would be exactly what I'd like.
Had better not just be cosmetic stuff.

Keep crying, Schlomo

Attached: 1566431377872.png (1482x450, 163K)

>literally stole all his arguments from other retards who were debunked by actual historians
Is this the best deniers can do? Man, I miss the times when people weren't proud of their stupidity.

The Wither is pretty fun if you don't cheese him. The only downside is his reward drop is dogshit consider the amount of effort it takes to fight and collect skulls for it. Beacons are cool and should be in the game but going through all that just for a beacon is wack as fuck

minecraft is the better sandbox terraria is the better game.

I know the holocaust happened because I was there.

I didn't even know what that was so I googled it. Fucking really? A static AoE boost to your stats in a game that is more or less infinite in every direction? What the absolute fuck and shit.

>posting /pol/ screenshots as evidence

Attached: kill yourself.png (1024x1387, 1.28M)

DUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUH YOU HIT ROCKS AND TREES SAME GAME DURRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

Nice try mister goldberg

Based
NPC

Does that look like a "mister" to you?

Fetishfags have sub-80 IQ and are only capable of spewing a few phrases in response to specific stimuli.

I think you are a pretty vile creature closely resembling a male human being with a hooknose. So yes mister goldberg is fine.

more loot would be lovely.

i would like it if they made it so every slot had active effects. granted it would be "overpowered" but everything else would be as well, so it would even out.

First of all, I'm not that user, although you might consider me to be a "pretty vile creature with a hooknose" myself (although I would reject the description of me as "vile").
Second of all, if you think she has a hooknose, you need your eyes checked.

Let me correct myself; you are a vile creature closely resembling a male human being with a hooknose and retarded.

i finished building this in survival recently

Attached: file.png (1200x636, 627K)

I'm waiting for the part where you correct yourself.

absolutely beautiful.

10/10

if the holocaust isn't real then why are all my jews zombies?

Attached: 2019-08-26_18.48.55.png (1920x1080, 1.61M)

>failed ideology
That's not communism

ty user

no you didn't, you super retard

>preparing to launch
Fuck terraria, n-not like i wanted to play it anyway

Minecraft
>base game is extremely boring after a while unless you're a redstone autist or a buildingfag
>very shit combat
>best building game
>perfect game for modding, the community reflects this
Terraria
>great sidescroller and has some replayability
>combat is awesome, many bosses are unique
>late game gets extremely grindy and hard, specially solo
>most late game bosses are very tanky as well
>mods are way more autistic than Minecraft's, unnecessary complexity on the level of Gregtech and beyond
Starbound
>Starbound

woah you imported a sprite over into a creative map you must be so pro

holy fuck based

Attached: yellow laugh warped.jpg (746x500, 102K)

You sound pretty boring. I did a Charizard from Red/Blue with primarily colored wool, and then followed it with a glowstone Zapdos oriented horizontally in the sky, with added teal wool blocks simulating electricity around it.

Sprite work in survival is certainly doable, if not an utter bitch to get the resources for.

no, it was all done in survival. i am a retard for trying to build it without the proper equipment, however. it overall took like a week of off and on resource collecting and a good 3 days after that to build it. it wouldve been much faster if i found a mesa biome for clay but alas, i didnt manage to find one. heres the rest of the world if insterested. its a bit shit and lacking because i was focusing all my efforts on building the sprite though
this
building wasnt even the hard part it was finding the resources for it. shit takes forever

Attached: file.png (1920x1017, 2.84M)

There's no comparison other than building shit, the core gameplay and progression is way different

Based.

Terraria = Minecraft pre-Adventure > Early Starbound > Minecraft post-Adventure > Early Terraria >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Starbound

>great debate
maybe between braindead faggots

kek btfo

>Terraria just gets better every update
How on earth did they do it? Every other game seems to get worse.

I've only played through Terraria with friends, and it's really fun. Every time I try to play Terraria by my self I just can't seem to get into as much.
I got spoiled fug

I want hytale to be 3d terraria but I think it will end up being minecraft but different