Let's settle this once and for all
P5 was good but it had a bad ending. Nier Automata was the best game of the last five years easily.
Both weeb trash. There, settled.
/thread
/double thread
Both waifufag garbage so I'll choose the one that's actually a fuckin game
overrated cinematic otaku wank bait vs overrated cinematic otaku wank bait
The one without turn based combat. Easiest question ever.
P5 > Nier, and it fucking pains me to say that, but I know Platinum can do better than Nier.
is this a joke, nier is only decent but persona 5 is fucking dogshit
>P5
>Bad ending
You go to jail but all your confidants testify or use their skills to back you up and get you absolved
By far the best ending for this sort of story. But I agree, Nier is much better.
Both, but it's hard for Yea Forums to like anything
It's a tough choice but I think Nier is the slightly better title.
Nier and it isn't even close.
Nier.
I was almost Spore levels of disappointed in Persona 5. Completely terrible.
I reject your choices
Nier, by far. Can't remember the last time I was as disappointed in a game like I was with P5. Story went to shit, the main party are a bunch of morons. Plot-induced stupidity drives most of the story and the fact this story was framed around the calendar system sabotaged it. If they have just done without it, it might have worked better. The Most of the game I spent wishing my confidants replaced the party because surely they wouldn't do the dumb shit these guy were doing. Also, it's one thing when the game firmly suggests you do something (head narration: It's getting late. I should go to bed.) and another thing to be told "Go to bed, faggot!"
I haven't played Nier but P5 was really good.
Yea Forums loves to shit on good games because they mistakenly think it gives them more serious clout amongst neckbeards.
I hate edgy action games. I hate Platinum. I hate perverted games from Yoko Taro and Hideo Kojima. I love Persona. But even I hate to admit Nier:A is better than P5. P5 is simply THAT horrendously bad.
Based
P5 easily. Nier is okay, but overhyped, literally the last of us of JRPGs. P5 wasn't perfect but it's one of the best turn based RPG ever made.
since you're throwing it out because your imagined online friends didn't like it, could you send it my way you fucking faggot? more internet points to you!